so the question is who do you think JJ would have trusted enough to hide behind?

im317 @ 10/8/2013 16:42

i was not inactive day 3, i was silenced. night 2 i apparently fell through a trap door into the labyrinth. Quote Night 2 I watched 317 and got nothing as a result. either he is lying or he was bussed because i blocked Rob night 2, which may also have been why there was no apparent mafia kill. Paul killed Mal and Rob? ball of light, is how mafia kills?

Maybe that's why I didn't see you? If you fell through a door I wouldn't see you.

Well at least now everyone knows why I was saying JJ was town!

This sucks though!

Science Man, can we get a list of players still alive?

Role: Serial Killer

Description: Each night choose a player to kill. You are immune to night kills and will be scanned as Town Bulletproof.

You take the appearance of your victim and is able to mimic his/her ability once as well.

^ Paul's role. So Paul probably killed Mal N1 and Rob N2. That means Paul got Mal's roleblocker ability, but I have no idea if he used it or not. Doesn't really make a difference right now cause I don't think we've heard of anyone being roleblocked

Curtis @ 10/8/2013 17:46

Role: Serial Killer Description: Each night choose a player to kill. You are immune to night kills and will be scanned as Town Bulletproof. You take the appearance of your victim and is able to mimic his/her ability once as well. ^ Paul's role. So Paul probably killed Mal N1 and Rob N2. That means Paul got Mal's roleblocker ability, but I have no idea if he used it or not. Doesn't really make a difference right now cause I don't think we've heard of anyone being roleblocked

So Sam could plausibly have been roleblocked?

Mal @ 10/8/2013 17:44

so the question is who do you think JJ would have trusted enough to hide behind?

Definitely not Paul I'm sure, cause those two didn't trust each other at all and Paul went for her all day. Unless there was a bussing or something, whoever she hid behind is likely scum

I wish I had been awake during that lynch! Lynching your own killer isn't something you get to do in Mafia a lot.

Curtis @ 10/8/2013 17:48

Mal @ 10/8/2013 17:44 so the question is who do you think JJ would have trusted enough to hide behind? Definitely not Paul I'm sure, cause those two didn't trust each other at all and Paul went for her all day. Unless there was a bussing or something, whoever she hid behind is likely scum

Either scum or Jesus/Dylan, that's for sure.

Samm @ 10/8/2013 17:46

im317 @ 10/8/2013 16:42 i was not inactive day 3, i was silenced. night 2 i apparently fell through a trap door into the labyrinth. Quote Night 2 I watched 317 and got nothing as a result. either he is lying or he was bussed because i blocked Rob night 2, which may also have been why there was no apparent mafia kill. Paul killed Mal and Rob? ball of light, is how mafia kills? Maybe that's why I didn't see you? If you fell through a door I wouldn't see you.

falling through a door was just elaborate flavor for me being silenced imo. my question is why nobody reported having been silenced day 2. i can think of a few possibilities.

the silencing could have been an inventor or the person who was silenced day 2 could have died night 2 and thus not been able to tell us they were silenced on day 3.

1. Curtis
2. Matt
4. Dutchiee
6. Shawn
7. Mal
8. Soccer
11. Greenday
12. Samm
13. DD
14. Patrick
15. Mercator
17. Jen
18. Nofo
19. Nobert
21. im317
22. Henry
23. Dylan
24. Ari
25. Bryce

Putting that there for convenience.

im317 @ 10/8/2013 16:50

Samm @ 10/8/2013 17:46 im317 @ 10/8/2013 16:42 i was not inactive day 3, i was silenced. night 2 i apparently fell through a trap door into the labyrinth. Quote Night 2 I watched 317 and got nothing as a result. either he is lying or he was bussed because i blocked Rob night 2, which may also have been why there was no apparent mafia kill. Paul killed Mal and Rob? ball of light, is how mafia kills? Maybe that's why I didn't see you? If you fell through a door I wouldn't see you. falling through a door was just elaborate flavor for me being silenced imo. my question is why nobody reported having been silenced day 2. i can think of a few possibilities. the silencing could have been an inventor or the person who was silenced day 2 could have died night 2 and thus not been able to tell us they were silenced on day 3.

There was no day 2.

Mal @ 10/8/2013 16:48

I wish I had been awake during that lynch! Lynching your own killer isn't something you get to do in Mafia a lot.

I wish I'd been asleep during that lynch. -grumbles at 6am in general-

Curtis @ 10/8/2013 17:48

Mal @ 10/8/2013 17:44 so the question is who do you think JJ would have trusted enough to hide behind? Definitely not Paul I'm sure, cause those two didn't trust each other at all and Paul went for her all day. Unless there was a bussing or something, whoever she hid behind is likely scum

Oh I'm dumb. Was thinking that Paul died during this night (:

Yeah she definitely could've hid behind Dylan

im317 @ 10/8/2013 17:50

Samm @ 10/8/2013 17:46 im317 @ 10/8/2013 16:42 i was not inactive day 3, i was silenced. night 2 i apparently fell through a trap door into the labyrinth. Quote Night 2 I watched 317 and got nothing as a result. either he is lying or he was bussed because i blocked Rob night 2, which may also have been why there was no apparent mafia kill. Paul killed Mal and Rob? ball of light, is how mafia kills? Maybe that's why I didn't see you? If you fell through a door I wouldn't see you. falling through a door was just elaborate flavor for me being silenced imo. my question is why nobody reported having been silenced day 2. i can think of a few possibilities. the silencing could have been an inventor or the person who was silenced day 2 could have died night 2 and thus not been able to tell us they were silenced on day 3.

they could have been biding their time and holding back a silence. Someone to just suddenly fall quiet after being vocal would be suspicious. And no record of silencing would only serve to strengthen the appearance of guilt on the silenced party.