Songs advancing to the Winners Bracket
Hex Girl by Moon Sisters, The Nostalgia Girls -- 6 votes
November Rain by Guns N' Roses -- 6 votes
Autumn by Paolo Nutini -- 5 votes
The Witch's Daughter by Ashley Serena -- 5 votes

Songs advancing to the Consolation Group Stages
Autumn's Here by Hawksley Workman -- 4 votes
Wake Me Up When September Ends by Green Day -- 4 votes
Moths by Darkher -- 4 votes
Autumn Almanac by The Kinks -- 4 votes

Songs eliminated
Get Your Freak On by Missy Elliot -- 4 votes
Haunted House by Teenage Bottlerocket -- 3 votes
The Chill of an Early Fall by George Strait -- 3 votes