Maddie @ 7/3/2017 23:52

So Spin and Badger both scanned Herm and he didn't scan mafia (or bully) but Zersch claims that Herm is mod-confirmed mafia. Is it possible that Herm is mafia but scans town?

I don't scan anyone. I was searching for the rest of my body. Only when I found Arthur, did I learn he was pro-town.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 7/3/2017 22:53

Bully isn't related to mafia. I think that bully is either related to ability to kill, character, or rng.

Ah ok--i thought you just came to this conclusion because your Herm scan contradicted Zersch's info.

spindoctor02 @ 8/3/2017 0:53

If Herm was scum, what incentive would I have right now to make up this claim (if you think I'm lying)? It would be much easier to just jump on the lynch train and look good. If you lynch pro-town Herm, I die too. Seeing how fast this lynch train built up, I had to speak up. I don't want to see scum push the eventual death of two townies.

spindoctor02 @ 8/3/2017 0:53

If Herm was scum, what incentive would I have right now to make up this claim (if you think I'm lying)? It would be much easier to just jump on the lynch train and look good. If you lynch pro-town Herm, I die too. Seeing how fast this lynch train built up, I had to speak up. I don't want to see scum push the eventual death of two townies.

Your incentive would be to save a re-director when there are known town killing roles.

spindoctor02 @ 7/3/2017 22:54

Maddie @ 7/3/2017 23:52 So Spin and Badger both scanned Herm and he didn't scan mafia (or bully) but Zersch claims that Herm is mod-confirmed mafia. Is it possible that Herm is mafia but scans town? I don't scan anyone. I was searching for the rest of my body. Only when I found Arthur, did I learn he was pro-town.

I just assumed this was a scanning type of role, but for your own purposes.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 7/3/2017 23:54

spindoctor02 @ 8/3/2017 0:53 If Herm was scum, what incentive would I have right now to make up this claim (if you think I'm lying)? It would be much easier to just jump on the lynch train and look good. If you lynch pro-town Herm, I die too. Seeing how fast this lynch train built up, I had to speak up. I don't want to see scum push the eventual death of two townies. Your incentive would be to save a re-director when there are known town killing roles.

But if Herm is still lynched, and shows up scum, I'm automatically the next lynch. It makes zero sense for me to defend what looks to be the obvious lynch candidate unless my life/game depended on it.

spindoctor02 @ 8/3/2017 0:54

Maddie @ 7/3/2017 23:52 So Spin and Badger both scanned Herm and he didn't scan mafia (or bully) but Zersch claims that Herm is mod-confirmed mafia. Is it possible that Herm is mafia but scans town? I don't scan anyone. I was searching for the rest of my body. Only when I found Arthur, did I learn he was pro-town.

Did you know all along what would happen when you found him?

I am going to be really busy tomorrow all day, so I needed to speak up tonight before going to bed, because I may only have a couple of minutes during my lunch break tomorrow to check back in. I won't be around at all near the deadline.

This is wild.

Maddie @ 8/3/2017 0:54

BadgerMcBeaver @ 7/3/2017 22:53 Bully isn't related to mafia. I think that bully is either related to ability to kill, character, or rng. Ah ok--i thought you just came to this conclusion because your Herm scan contradicted Zersch's info.

Yeah. That was my initial reaction. But Merc said his role mentioned being a bully, and mine says I'm looking for fellow bullies.

I think it probably references having a killing ability as a night action. So Ahoda would have scanned maf, but not any random maf member that could be sent for a kill? Or it could just be pure RNG, Brian has done that to me before lol.

Christian @ 7/3/2017 23:57

spindoctor02 @ 8/3/2017 0:54 Maddie @ 7/3/2017 23:52 So Spin and Badger both scanned Herm and he didn't scan mafia (or bully) but Zersch claims that Herm is mod-confirmed mafia. Is it possible that Herm is mafia but scans town? I don't scan anyone. I was searching for the rest of my body. Only when I found Arthur, did I learn he was pro-town. Did you know all along what would happen when you found him?

All I knew prior to finding Arthur, was that I needed to find him, and if he died, so did I. Only once I found Arthur, did I learn he was pro-town, and that I would now be able to protect him.

someone is giving us bad information.

Who could it be?

I feel like this game is what happens when crack and alcohol get together

So Spin, let me get this straight. Your role is just to literally look for Arthur and your reward is that if you find him, you die if he dies? And there is no faction change involved?

thisisbad @ 7/3/2017 23:59

I feel like this game is what happens when crack and alcohol get together

SoDope

so then Spin, what do you make of mod-confirmed Townie backing up Zersch's claim?