Great!

##unvote

##vote Herm

I'm not trying to pick on you, just trying to figure stuff out. :P

Christian @ 4/12/2016 14:16

so you learned both Wikey's alignment and his role?

yeah this stood out to me. Maddie please clarify.

Christian @ 4/12/2016 12:15

did you think about scanning anyone else, like Ahoda or DS, someone who had been getting a lot of attention on Day 1, just to be sure of their alignment? And if you "totally buy that Ahoda is Town", why would you think there's a possibility he'd be making up the carolers thing and the names? Assuming you're Town, which of Angi or Herm isn't?

I feel like it's a perfectly logical decision not to scan someone like Ahoda or DS, who would just as easily be scrutinized the next day. But my main reasoning for not scanning ahoda was that I was pretty convinced his double vote was a town role, at least for the time being.

Like I said, I think Wikey is a good player and I can't get reads on him so I scanned him. That's my reasoning and you can take it or leave.


I only said I thought it was possible ahoda made up the names because it seemed really convenient that I was included in the three considering ahoda was after me day one. It's not like I was totally insistent that he did make them up. And like Angi said, it's possible the carolers weren't honest either. I don't see why ahoda would make it up, but that coincidence seemed weird to me.

im317 @ 4/12/2016 12:18

Christian @ 4/12/2016 14:16 so you learned both Wikey's alignment and his role? yeah this stood out to me. Maddie please clarify.

No, it was essentially a little clue that included the word "vanilla."

Christian @ 4/12/2016 12:17

I'm not trying to pick on you, just trying to figure stuff out. :P

Haha it's fine. No one signs up for mafia if they're not willing to be scrutinized. :P

Maddie S. @ 4/12/2016 14:21

Christian @ 4/12/2016 12:15 did you think about scanning anyone else, like Ahoda or DS, someone who had been getting a lot of attention on Day 1, just to be sure of their alignment? And if you "totally buy that Ahoda is Town", why would you think there's a possibility he'd be making up the carolers thing and the names? Assuming you're Town, which of Angi or Herm isn't? I feel like it's a perfectly logical decision not to scan someone like Ahoda or DS, who would just as easily be scrutinized the next day. But my main reasoning for not scanning ahoda was that I was pretty convinced his double vote was a town role, at least for the time being. Like I said, I think Wikey is a good player and I can't get reads on him so I scanned him. That's my reasoning and you can take it or leave. I only said I thought it was possible ahoda made up the names because it seemed really convenient that I was included in the three considering ahoda was after me day one. It's not like I was totally insistent that he did make them up. And like Angi said, it's possible the carolers weren't honest either. I don't see why ahoda would make it up, but that coincidence seemed weird to me.

I'm not criticizing you choosing Wikey, I can never get a read on him either. :P I was more interested in your thought process is all. And if Ahoda is Town, he's not going to make up a name to try to get someone lynched if he's not sure that they're not also Town.

The epic mafia Caroler role says the person sang to (if they didn't go out at night) is given three names. These come from the moderator, if it came from another player, there's no way to know that one is scum for certain, and the role would be pointless? That's my understanding of it anyway.

Christian @ 4/12/2016 11:16

so you learned both Wikey's alignment and his role?

interesting. i overlooked that.

Christian @ 4/12/2016 11:42

Since DS received that letter recently, it's most likely someone's day action? Is it possible that a watcher or tracker saw Lamps visit farlig and is also able to send someone else that info? Not sure what to make of the sender's intentions at this point, but farlig might be able to shed some light on that. It does sound kind of like a distraction?

I can't explain someone knowing I was attacked last night but also being able to send a note during the day. However, I was attacked but wasn't told by who. Looks like my friend Lamps carried over a grudge from last game (:

I was hoping not to have to claim until I had time to try and draw out the other killer so thanks DS for ruining that. But yes, I was the town BP.

now Maddie, final question, lol.

Assuming that one of you, Angi or Herm is scum...who is it?

So Farlig is claiming bulletproof, which would mean that mafia killed Lamps, so who killed Jamie?

Christian @ 4/12/2016 12:27

now Maddie, final question, lol. Assuming that one of you, Angi or Herm is scum...who is it?

Tbh I don't have much of a read on either one of them, either, but Angi seems less scummy to me than Herm. Herm seemed more willing to throw Angi or me under the bus without much thought, so that stood out to me.

farlig @ 4/12/2016 14:26

Christian @ 4/12/2016 11:42 Since DS received that letter recently, it's most likely someone's day action? Is it possible that a watcher or tracker saw Lamps visit farlig and is also able to send someone else that info? Not sure what to make of the sender's intentions at this point, but farlig might be able to shed some light on that. It does sound kind of like a distraction? I can't explain someone knowing I was attacked last night but also being able to send a note during the day. However, I was attacked but wasn't told by who. Looks like my friend Lamps carried over a grudge from last game (: I was hoping not to have to claim until I had time to try and draw out the other killer so thanks DS for ruining that. But yes, I was the town BP.

if that's true, then we don't hear about people surviving attacks.

Maddie S. @ 4/12/2016 15:22

im317 @ 4/12/2016 12:18 Christian @ 4/12/2016 14:16 so you learned both Wikey's alignment and his role? yeah this stood out to me. Maddie please clarify. No, it was essentially a little clue that included the word "vanilla."

Quick question: Did you only get the little clue, or did you get alignment also?

Note: I ask because if you only got the clue, then you're a flavor cop and not a regular cop, which means that your scan does not fully clear Wikey.

It's important, etc :D