I'm really tempted to replay through this, I miss it. Only prob is I'm honestly not sure how many stones are left unturned (that I care about, like side missions/strangers - still have plenty of collectibles/challenges I never touched). I know I only hit like 4/12 of the "secret cabins"(?) that you can stumble across, I remember one of them being really cool where there was like this entire gang party scene going on inside that you could just stand and watch through the window for like five minutes, after which everyone drunkenly passes out and you can choose to sneak inside and try to steal from them (which doesn't go so well (: )

i did every side mission and found every collectable except for fishing for all the big fishies cuz that got old fast

Boc @ 1/10/2019 17:59

I'm really tempted to replay through this, I miss it. Only prob is I'm honestly not sure how many stones are left unturned (that I care about, like side missions/strangers - still have plenty of collectibles/challenges I never touched). I know I only hit like 4/12 of the "secret cabins"(?) that you can stumble across, I remember one of them being really cool where there was like this entire gang party scene going on inside that you could just stand and watch through the window for like five minutes, after which everyone drunkenly passes out and you can choose to sneak inside and try to steal from them (which doesn't go so well (: )

I missed a lot of things as far as collectibles go. I don't think I got any dinosaur bones or any of the things for that guy in Saint Denis. Think I gave up on the treasure map after the second one and didn't want to look it up online. Also the crafting challenges. I just got into upgrading the camp in the late game. It's kind of fun doing it in New Hanover when everything is joyful and fun.

KC @ 20/10/2016 18:57

This... might actually push me to the edge of getting a PS4. Red Dead is really just a perfect game all around. Only thing that worries me is that John Marston cannot be topped as a protagonist.

This aged well

FYI I'm finally playing this and Arthur Morgan is great

I just got drunk with Lenny in Valentine.

I can't believe that alone is a mission, what a game!

I finished the main story (finally) I took my time with this.

Spoiler	+
Because I had high honor it was quite a sad and honorable way to die. Fit the story of Arthur's redemption arc. I'm curious how playing dishonourably will change the ending. I might actually do this again sometime in the future. FYI I just started the epilogue with John.

Nobert @ 20/5/2020 15:14

I just got drunk with Lenny in Valentine. I can't believe that alone is a mission, what a game!

Best mission in the game

Finished the epilogue

Spoiler	+
The John stuff really slowed things down, but I get why. Bridging the gap between the first game. The final shootout with Micah, the John Marston theme being played as you run up the mountain. The meeting with Dutch, all of it was glorious. Even the end credits sequences were great.

I started a new game a few days ago. I tried a replay shortly after finishing it but it was TOO FRESH and I was doing a shitty low honor run which I don't have the HEART to do! It's been a couple of years now. This game is so good and it's crazy that years later I'm finding new things. Pretty much taking every chapter very, very, very slow and taking everything in that I can.