Rodney @ 11/3/2021 12:53

It's most overrated probably and mal's answer is the same no matter what the fox question is

KR is NOT overrated what

AhrNav @ 11/3/2021 21:52

Lamps @ 11/3/2021 12:50 Kaoh Rong and Amazon both stand out as odd anwers. Maybe it is most underrated season. Or season with the most undeserving winner. Most forgettable winner? This is why Curtis/Jacob is a good combo. u say that but Mal + literally anyone is possible bc Mal would answer that way for any Survivor question

Yeah so Mal is a fox bcuz of that answer or he is not a fox cuz he got the same set of questions 🤷🏽‍♀️

KC is wrong. He is very notably off on Mondays so this is a great answer for him. He also specifically chose a celebrity whose only FE claim to fame is being related to someone.

AhrNav @ 11/3/2021 15:53

Rodney @ 11/3/2021 12:53 It's most overrated probably and mal's answer is the same no matter what the fox question is KR is NOT overrated what

It is to Jacob who hangs out with Michele stans and has been known to dislike it

Lamps @ 11/3/2021 12:54

AhrNav @ 11/3/2021 21:52 Lamps @ 11/3/2021 12:50 Kaoh Rong and Amazon both stand out as odd anwers. Maybe it is most underrated season. Or season with the most undeserving winner. Most forgettable winner? This is why Curtis/Jacob is a good combo. u say that but Mal + literally anyone is possible bc Mal would answer that way for any Survivor question Yeah so Mal is a fox bcuz of that answer or he is not a fox cuz he got the same set of questions 🤷🏽‍♀️

what do you meeeeean

the Foxes also clearly got a SURVIVOR question just not the question that Hens got

i feel like the Fox q is probably just "best season" which is why i think its Mal and Xian but whatever

AhrNav @ 11/3/2021 15:53

FTR Kaoh Rong is a fantastic season but idk if Stallord would put that down as the season for a new viewer. he does kinda sound believable but ehhh Wednesday ##unvote Christian ##vote Jacob

Quote

Aight, well let me take you through this thought exercise: 1) I would want to recommend a season of modern Survivor to a first time user. This is more a matter of preference but if they were going to get into it long-term, I would want them to know what they were getting into. This leaves something like 27-40 2) I would not want to recommend a season with any returnees. This leaves 28, 29, 30, 32, 33, 35, 36, 37, and maybe 39. 3) I would not want to recommend any season with the dumb final 4 twist lol. This leaves 28, 29, 30, 32, 33 4) Not Worlds Apart lol. 28, 29, 32, 33 5) Controversial but not Cagayan because it's just so atypical with its winner and I just didn't like it as much as most people. It's solid but it might be the most overrated season imo. 29, 32, 33 6) I have been documented as disliking 29 as well, and I wasn't even really distracted when I was watching 29 as I watched it over the summer and then I explained why I chose 32 over 33. Kaoh Rong is just a very normal, modern season without any absurd twists or returnees

And honestly I think Wednesday, especially with the reasons I have given, is better than any generic Saturday answer. Do you really think Penner's fox question wouldn't also be likely to lead to a Saturday answer if it corresponds to favorite day of the week?

Oh yeah herm makes sense for putting a returnee season

ALright rod

##unvote KC
##Vote Mal

I guess I'm between Mal Jacob and Herm with a chance of Nav but this is his 3rd fox answer about the 3rd Reich so hard to lynch him for it

If I get voted out over Herm who put an all-returnee season, their best friend, an attractive young actress, and Friday, I will riot

I feel way more confident about Herm than Mal or anyone else. That is who we should be trying to match with

It's hard to believe 4 of you actually dislike Reese's

idt Herm's HvV answer is bad at all hes a casual so its natural to put down a season that was really good TV. just bc to superfans the whole returnee aspect means a lot and u would wanna watch all seasons b4 that doesnt mean its a necessity. if u assume the 20 ppl in HvV are all newbies its still a fantastic season and would get anyone hooked to the show

jacob's posts are starting to sound desperate tho so i'll stick with him

If it’s Herm for the survivor season, then celeb may be which celeb would you date/do you find most attractive? Any other answers that would fall in that category?

Things I can't get past:

Jacob liking Koah Rong all of a sudden
Herm putting a returnee season

And then there's Mal where none of them are terrible but I don't like any of them.

Really wish we lynched one of these three instead of Cody who had all great answers lol