I’m just seeing it as black and white here. We have a known killer forced fo out themselves by a role of the person they killed. I’m thinking it’s strong odds they are bad. I’m just very opinionated and y’all don’t need to agree. But I think some of you can see my logic here. Even if he is the vigilante he’s useless now. He’s exposed to both other factions. So he’ll last a couple more nights and meanwhile kills a few more town by accident in the process? Then meets his maker by mafia. (This is all IF he is the good role in 1/3) so no I don’t really see his value to town long term at all.

Spin @ 4/10/2020 22:35

Christian @ 4/10/2020 21:34 yeah, im317 is a Vig kill for sure. There was nothing in those posts. BuT hE wAs tOwN!!!!

I would have done the same.

Zersch must pay for his crimes

Not in blood but in fanfic

Or fanart

That’s my opinion and my lynch vote - but if you think he will kill to the better of town for whatever reason keep him!

Shadow @ 4/10/2020 21:36

I’m just seeing it as black and white here. We have a known killer forced fo out themselves by a role of the person they killed. I’m thinking it’s strong odds they are bad. I’m just very opinionated and y’all don’t need to agree. But I think some of you can see my logic here. Even if he is the vigilante he’s useless now. He’s exposed to both other factions. So he’ll last a couple more nights and meanwhile kills a few more town by accident in the process? Then meets his maker by mafia. (This is all IF he is the good role in 1/3) so no I don’t really see his value to town long term at all.

His value to town is that he is a voting member (well, not today, but going forward) of the town. Town is still town, and still helps advance us towards our win condition.

I would hope as the game goes along, more information comes out where he can make a more informed decision, or use his kills to help us narrow down suspects, which is all that a Vig can hope to do.

well i activated my role so start actually scum hunting

or listen to me and vote Herm for confirmed scum

Shadow @ 4/10/2020 22:36

I’m just seeing it as black and white here. We have a known killer forced fo out themselves by a role of the person they killed. I’m thinking it’s strong odds they are bad. I’m just very opinionated and y’all don’t need to agree. But I think some of you can see my logic here. Even if he is the vigilante he’s useless now. He’s exposed to both other factions. So he’ll last a couple more nights and meanwhile kills a few more town by accident in the process? Then meets his maker by mafia. (This is all IF he is the good role in 1/3) so no I don’t really see his value to town long term at all.

if he's going to die soon anyway, I'm willing to focus on other people today. And then if he isn't dead a few days from now and he's continued to kill Townies, then it should be a serious consideration. I get your point though. What would you do in the that situation?

Christian @ 4/10/2020 21:34

yeah, im317 is a Vig kill for sure. There was nothing in those posts.

Harsh

NaVenom @ 4/10/2020 21:38

well i activated my role so start actually scum hunting or listen to me and vote Herm for confirmed scum

So you set the bomb on Nofo. Awesome.

Someone has activated their ability. Someone has came and saved Nav. All votes are voided and he can't be voted for the rest of the day


Day 2 Go Get'em Tiger

Kyle(2/12) - Stargate, Farlig
Herm(2/12) - Nav, Nofo
Zersch(1/12) - Shadow
Farlig(1/12) - Kyle
Spin(0/12) - Shadow
Nav(4/12) - Timmah, Spin, Mittens, Herm

Day ends 8pm eastern

Spin @ 4/10/2020 21:38

Shadow @ 4/10/2020 21:36 I’m just seeing it as black and white here. We have a known killer forced fo out themselves by a role of the person they killed. I’m thinking it’s strong odds they are bad. I’m just very opinionated and y’all don’t need to agree. But I think some of you can see my logic here. Even if he is the vigilante he’s useless now. He’s exposed to both other factions. So he’ll last a couple more nights and meanwhile kills a few more town by accident in the process? Then meets his maker by mafia. (This is all IF he is the good role in 1/3) so no I don’t really see his value to town long term at all. His value to town is that he is a voting member (well, not today, but going forward) of the town. Town is still town, and still helps advance us towards our win condition. I would hope as the game goes along, more information comes out where he can make a more informed decision, or use his kills to help us narrow down suspects, which is all that a Vig can hope to do.

Did he even claim vig?

So, Nav's scum team has a lynch save. Good thing they had to use it on D2.

as for those other people, I'd like to vote Nav because Timmah came in hot today with that lynch.

And Stargate is being a little bit something.

And maybe Kyle. What bothers me about him was that very, very quick vote on Farlig, almost like he needed to prove that he didn't kill im317.

Spin @ 4/10/2020 19:40

So, Nav's scum team has a lynch save. Good thing they had to use it on D2.

yawn