You made your lynch after we had all talked it out and realized that there was a great chance Jeff was lying for the good of the town, aka concealing his true and more powerful role. Once I started to realize that I backed off

Curtis @ 21/2/2013 22:42

Quite a bit changed by the time I made my post about Jeff to the time you made yours. I was pretty much lynching him for his :| roleclaim so early, where as you just seemed to want to get the possible BP/Doc/SK out of here at the right time. I changed my mind later and really wasn't cool with the Jeff lynch and helped lead the switch to Mal, while your vote sat on Jeff

I didn't realize blindly following the majority was the way to play this game, sorry!

I kept my lynch on Jeff because because I thought there was a good chance he would be scum. Curtis, you yourself said there was a 2/3 chance of him been Don or SK on day 3. I have already quoted that in this thread.

Tom Brady @ 21/2/2013 17:44

I aren't suspicious of Curtis at all...I am simply pointing out that he is basing his suspicions on me on mistakes he also made. As a matter of fact I have a lynch vote on Kiwi. I think he is trying to hide in plain sight, throwing out lots of strong accusations but never really doing anything.

I didn't realize you had the vote on Kiwi. Actually, I've been taking his "ARE YOU SCUM?" and "X DO YOU THINK Y IS SCUM" posts as just being paranoid toen, but at the exact same time, he's actually been quite calm and collected otherwise, joking around for a while with us last night.

I still think Wikey jumped on the end of that Greenday train to look good also. There was no reason for him to add his vote other than that, his vote wasn't needed at all. But when he did he made sure to bring up some other theory against Jeff to possibly divert it

About a half hour, guys...

Tom Brady @ 21/2/2013 17:47

Curtis @ 21/2/2013 22:42 Quite a bit changed by the time I made my post about Jeff to the time you made yours. I was pretty much lynching him for his :| roleclaim so early, where as you just seemed to want to get the possible BP/Doc/SK out of here at the right time. I changed my mind later and really wasn't cool with the Jeff lynch and helped lead the switch to Mal, while your vote sat on Jeff I didn't realize blindly following the majority was the way to play this game, sorry! I kept my lynch on Jeff because because I thought there was a good chance he would be scum. Curtis, you yourself said there was a 2/3 chance of him been Don or SK on day 3. I have already quoted that in this thread.

Yes, I realize that. And you just quoted where I responded to it! There seemed to be a 2/3 chance of him being scum, then we ran through more scenarios, then we held back because it wasn't a good idea. You didn't. You kept saying that if he was bulletproof then we can do without him for some reason, and that if he was a doctor he wouldn't have protected himself

There was no blindly following the majority at all. We talked it out like I said and realized that the odds weren't as clear cut as we first thought with the Jeff lynch

Now that I think about it the whole LSF thing could of very easily been a hey whats up to the members of the mafia that he isn't who he said he is.

I keep going back and forth on him and to me he's the most suspicious. I am not sure about Kiwi or Shawn.

I feel like metagaming wise Natalie could be scum. On one side she could be really busy but she is known for keeping tabs on everybody and knowing what is going on and being said. I don't want to go after her if she is just being busy but I am keeping my eye on here.

Last round we changed at the last second and that could of bit us in the butt. Not sure we wanna do that again.

Though my gut is telling me that Wikey isn't scum. I am not claiming to have a Scum Killer gut and it could just be the shitty lunch meat I had earlier.

Wikey, I hate asking this, but if you have a claim, you might want to claim it! You're very close to being very dead very soon. You only have 20 minutes.

I'm leaving. Might be able to get on via phone. Wikey literally fits every single suspicious scum behavior that I wanted to look for. I made a better argument against him earlier today than I have these past few minutes because I'm distracted. No other lynch makes as much sense to me today at all

DO THE RIGHT THING!

Curtis @ 21/2/2013 22:47

I still think Wikey jumped on the end of that Greenday train to look good also. There was no reason for him to add his vote other than that, his vote wasn't needed at all. But when he did he made sure to bring up some other theory against Jeff to possibly divert it

I tend not to jump on the first train that comes along so most of my votes come in towards the end of a phase or the middle. And since I have been out most days this week it has been the former. I don't know what time I lynched Greenday, but you could just as easily say I look scummy if I hadn't joined the train.

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 21/2/2013 22:55

Wikey, I hate asking this, but if you have a claim, you might want to claim it! You're very close to being very dead very soon. You only have 20 minutes.

I'm a Hider.

lol

Jeff do you think Wikey is scum?

Night 1: Hid behind Henry
Night 2: Hid behind Curtis
Night 3: Hid behind DR