Spin @ 29/12/2017 16:35

Helios Garabandia @ 29/12/2017 15:31 Tattooed Tooth @ 29/12/2017 14:36 Spin, since we have 2 factions and we probably have 2 specific cops (if DS' role truly is in-cop law), I wonder if it makes any sense you be scanned as scum for both... Simultaneously appearing as in-law and kids' table, that's very weird >.> I guess this would depend on if both factions are Mafia or not. If both factions are Mafia, then Spin's claim doesn't work, and he's lying scum (since Miller scans as Mafia-aligned, he'd have to specifically scan as one of the Mafia factions). I scan as guilty, not mafia-aligned.

You've said this already. I'm saying that Millers don't scan as Guilty. They scan as Mafia.
(and they certainly can't visit anyone, either)

Helios Garabandia @ 29/12/2017 15:37

Spin @ 29/12/2017 16:35 Helios Garabandia @ 29/12/2017 15:31 Tattooed Tooth @ 29/12/2017 14:36 Spin, since we have 2 factions and we probably have 2 specific cops (if DS' role truly is in-cop law), I wonder if it makes any sense you be scanned as scum for both... Simultaneously appearing as in-law and kids' table, that's very weird >.> I guess this would depend on if both factions are Mafia or not. If both factions are Mafia, then Spin's claim doesn't work, and he's lying scum (since Miller scans as Mafia-aligned, he'd have to specifically scan as one of the Mafia factions). I scan as guilty, not mafia-aligned. You've said this already. I'm saying that Millers don't scan as Guilty. They scan as Mafia. (and they certainly can't visit anyone, either)

My role PM would disagree with you. Zashua doesn't mod like you or me so shove your meta argument.

The visits I do, I'm doing to spread my message of hope for the great white renaissance. Depending on who I visit, something good might happen. Nothing good has happened yet.

My ~reads~ so far

Leaning Town
4. Nav - Confirmed sexy Townie
10. Merc - I'm 99% sure that Merc is town after reading Z's posts.
13. Maddie - I think I have an idea of what she was hinting at. But even if I'm wrong about that, this seems like town Madz to me.
15. TT - Pretty much confirmed town.
18. farlig - I'm getting warm and fuzzy Town vibes from Farlig. Have no idea about his role and originally I thought that if Cultis was the SK kill then Farlig would be a very likely SK but since it seems like Sock is caught SK I'm feeling better about Farlig.
25. Buffy - Un CCed tracker who helped us catch Sock.
31. Helios - I like his posts and he seems to be trying to gamesolve hard.

Undecided
6. Jamie - Leaning scum but he's half cleared by DS so I will say neutral right now Hard to read because he got offended by the Nofo stuff on D1/2 and then by Chris on D3.
7. Rose - She was the first one to point out the Christian breadcrumb which made me feel good about her But then complete absence after that makes me think she could be scummy. For now I will give her the benefit of the doubt.
8. Herm - IDK. Some of his posts are very weird. Some are helpful. Could go either way.
11. DS - Not sure if In-law cop or traitor. And I probably won't be sure until the end.
16. im317 - I can't read im well. He doesn't post a lot regardless of his alignment. And when he DOES post he usually makes good points, also regardless of his alignment. Wouldn't mind him being checked.
19. Timmah - Timmah is another one I can't really read too well because he sounds logical regardless of alignment.
27. Primate - I was feeling good about Primate till one of his posts early in this day phase. He is more likely Town than scum given his role but there ARE scum roles with the ability to send messages too so not committing fully on Primate yet.
29. Darkus - I townread him hard early on. Now not so sure. Would still lean more Town than scum though.
30. PORL - No idea. Wondering why he is still alive tbh.

Leaning scum
12. Sock - Caught scum.
14. Bryce - Town Bryce is way more of a pain in the ass. This feels like scum Bryce laying low because he doesn't know what to post.
21. Spin - I can't wrap my head around the way spin has played this game. He is scum even if he is town.
23. TiB - Looks like caught scum.
26. Chris - Chris is always scum.

No offence taken Buffy. You just havent played enough games with me to realise that I don’t play meta-mafia. Which is why I always appear scummy to the meta gamers. Which is all of you.

Also since we're on the subject, spin's role the way he describes it and DS' role the way he describes it seem like they can't co-exist.

I also care deeply about dying if I am town and would rather throw the whole town under the bus than be lynched. Always hilarious watching the salty players when that happens.

Hellow.

Been busy today, Sock's still getting lynched I guess.

D2: "let's lynch Nofo because if they are town, they are still scum"
D4: "let's lynch Spin because if he is town, he's still scum"
D5: "let's lynch Chris because if he's town, he's still scum"

And by D6, you are down at least two town, and possibly 3.

Sebta Claus @ 29/12/2017 15:57

Also since we're on the subject, spin's role the way he describes it and DS' role the way he describes it seem like they can't co-exist.

Why not? If there can be two negative town roles, why can't there be two cop-like roles?

Spin @ 29/12/2017 22:06

D2: "let's lynch Nofo because if they are town, they are still scum" D4: "let's lynch Spin because if he is town, he's still scum" D5: "let's lynch Chris because if he's town, he's still scum" And by D6, you are down at least two town, and possibly 3.

Makes it easier when there are less loose cannons to worry about.

Spin @ 29/12/2017 14:10

Sebta Claus @ 29/12/2017 15:57 Also since we're on the subject, spin's role the way he describes it and DS' role the way he describes it seem like they can't co-exist. Why not? If there can be two negative town roles, why can't there be two cop-like roles?

...
You're role is not a cop-like role ... ?

your *

fml

Sebta Claus @ 29/12/2017 16:13

Spin @ 29/12/2017 14:10 Sebta Claus @ 29/12/2017 15:57 Also since we're on the subject, spin's role the way he describes it and DS' role the way he describes it seem like they can't co-exist. Why not? If there can be two negative town roles, why can't there be two cop-like roles? ... You're role is not a cop-like role ... ?

Are you really that dumb?

Spin @ 29/12/2017 14:20

Sebta Claus @ 29/12/2017 16:13 Spin @ 29/12/2017 14:10 Sebta Claus @ 29/12/2017 15:57 Also since we're on the subject, spin's role the way he describes it and DS' role the way he describes it seem like they can't co-exist. Why not? If there can be two negative town roles, why can't there be two cop-like roles? ... You're role is not a cop-like role ... ? Are you really that dumb?

Not as dumb as you seeing as you completely missed my point and went on a tangent.