farlig @ 9/4/2017 8:51

thisisbad @ 9/4/2017 9:45 Protects her from getting the truth? Lets go fishing for more information.

So you think i should just stop there and take what he said as ok? You are really ok with that?

He targeted her and she got no info on her. He said he was protecting her and thats good enough for you? Wow far i am surprised.

got no info on him it should say

Maddie said she tracked herm. Herm admitted to targeting maddie. Did he have to admit to that? Not based on what maddie said. It's enough to make me want to pause.

farlig @ 9/4/2017 8:58

Maddie said she tracked herm. Herm admitted to targeting maddie. Did he have to admit to that? Not based on what maddie said. It's enough to make me want to pause.

I respectfully disagree, but ok. Herm isn't really talking and you got his back so that's that i think.

For as much as you think herm is guilty, where's the lynch vote?

Also please explain the difference between socks role and what you think herms role might be.

farlig @ 9/4/2017 9:04

For as much as you think herm is guilty, where's the lynch vote?

This all has happened in the last couple minutes. I am still processing. I was willing to listen and hear more from Herm before casting a vote.

So let me get this straight, i am not allowed to ask for more info from him, but i should also have cast a vote on him. Those don't seem to go together.

Is the right action just questioning anyone who doubts Herm? That's the better play?

farlig @ 9/4/2017 9:06

Also please explain the difference between socks role and what you think herms role might be.

Again i am not sure, that's why i am asking questions.

I think it's weird you are so ready to believe his vague claims. You are doing more work than he is right now.

You honestly think his actions right before those were normal (i'm busy right now, more info later). that's scummy stuff.

I'm not going to get into a back and forth with you. It will detract from the game. But honestly me asking questions is totally legit here. You not is weird.

Look back, I asked him to confirm whether is role would stop maddie from getting info. He has since said no. He's claimed a protective role. It's day 3.

Please process this and tell me how you think more info then what he has given so far would be helpful to town.

What can he do? Claim doc or similar role? Hurts town if true. Claim doc or similar role and force a counter? Hurts town.

But hey, like I said. Process away and let me know.

Damn I sound a lot like spin right now.

I'm too hungover for this discussion so shhhhhhh

CherryBerry @ 9/4/2017 15:47

Herm @ 9/4/2017 10:44 I don't think my role would cause that. It helps against certain scum actions, which is why I targeted her. Can you confirm with Brian or Tom?

I could, but both my actions are submitted so the information is all here. If I had targeted someone else, I'm not sure Maddie's condition would change.

If someone else hadn't messed with her she should've been able to see me visit her.

Sorry, busy today and yesterday, which is why there's a lack of contributions from me rn.

Herm's vague claim seems like one that could be CC'd. There is hidden text in play this game so it's not impossible that it could be a hidden passive ability? idk if that fits the flavour of his role/character but best not to speculate about that. It could be someone else's role that affected maddie's findings and not herms doing at all