Angi @ 24/1/2016 13:51

Vic @ 24/1/2016 14:49 Ok I literally haven't been tunneling you at all lol BUT really anyone could be Cult in my opinion, I just think because of the scan from a Cultist he ABSOLUTELY had to have reported that he got an innocent scan on you to whoever the leader is, making you an easy person to recruit Wait, I'm assuming that is directed to Timmah lol I thought you were talking to me in the tunneling thingy

No it was directed to JC, sorry lol

JC @ 24/1/2016 13:45

There is no way I am cult leader. You really think, if I was cult leader, I'd have Timmah (whom I've already recruited, based on your claim), visit me at night to clear me as town, when everybody already says Cult Leader would scan town anyways? What, I just knew Timmah would be tracked? Are you serious? I know I'm not following along all that closely, but there is 0% chance of me being Cult Leader.

Or

N5: Cult Leader JC recruits Timmah the same night as:
N5: Town Timmah scans JC as Town

D6: Timmah is now in JC's Cult and reveals to JC that he got a Town scan on him last night. They talk about it and (STUPIDLY!) decide it's best for Timmah to reveal that JC is innocent in order to clear both of them

Cult Timmah's decision to publicly clear you was silly to me no matter what the scenario is really. ALTHO now that I think of it, Bryce had already called Timmah out for visiting JC so maybe Timmah felt like his hand was forced

I don't think you're Cult Leader but there's not really a 0% chance of anything in this game

Vic @ 24/1/2016 12:49

Ok I literally haven't been tunneling you at all lol BUT really anyone could be Cult in my opinion, I just think because of the scan from a Cultist he ABSOLUTELY had to have reported that he got an innocent scan on you to whoever the leader is, making you an easy person to recruit

I really think the only reason anyone suspects me of cult is because Timmah visited me right before he died. If he visits anyone else, nobody even bats an eye that I'm cult. It's the problem of recency. Once you get beyond that, you'll see your arguments make no sense.

Plus, there are other people (bryce, herm, angi) who would make much more valuable recruits right now, because nobody is questioning their "town-ness". Everybody is questioning mine after Timmah's flip, so why again would I make the "best recruit"?

I think either Brian or Ari needs to be lynched today. One of them is probably lying about saving me a few nights ago....

What I would like to hear from Brian is why he tracked Timmah if he thought he was town

What I would like to hear from Ari is just a little more info because he was so vague with his explanations. With only 10 people left and both cult AND mafia factions in the game, if someone has helpful information then they should share it. I understand the fear of being killed at night, but I'm likely dying tonight so they'll have at least two days, (but then again I thought I was dying last night too)

Vern (0/6) - Bryce, Herm, Vic
Brian (4/6) - Herm, im317, Angi, Ari, Vernon, Vic, im317
Herm (1/6) - Vernon
Angi (0/6) - Vic

The way the scenario played out, I think its more likely Brian is lying. Brian basically had to claim after I called him out for visiting Timmah N4, Ari didn't have to claim anything. I don't see why Ari would call Brian out on lying if he himself was lying instead

Also like I said the tracking Timmah thing doesn't make sense to me at all if he felt strongly about him being Town. The only thing that doesn't make sense to me about Ari is why he didn't protect Patrick N4 but we don't really the know the extent of Ari's role so maybe there's something we're unaware of idk idk

Bryce @ 24/1/2016 14:56

What I would like to hear from Brian is why he tracked Timmah if he thought he was town

itsbrianyay @ 24/1/2016 6:57

wow i am super illiterate on my phone as drunk. please let me interpret. okay i', kinda drunk but i'll explain my tracking. i picked timmah because i like to confir my feelings about people. i know it's dumb but i thik i work better when i find town and then work from there. obviously the cult changes things but that's just the way it is. as i said before i understand if you lynch me since i'm the only one whose proven to visit timmah but all of my actions have been legit so i dunno what ari means

i think it would be a bad assumption to just say ari or brian are lying. i don't think that's necessarily the case.

i DO think ari has some questions to answer.

"NIGHT 5: protected bryce. there may or may not be a back-up doc but if there's not (there probably isn't since they would've been on timmah last night), i saved bryce's life. if there is, we doubled-up. "

This part in Brian's claim bothers me. If I was truly the person who protected Bryce that night I'd of course assume I was the only one since at this point any protection at all seemed unlikely

So that line about doubling up stands out. If Scum Brian fake claimed he protected Bryce, he'd know that someone else out there actually did and will call him out on it, so he adds these lines about how there may or may not still be a back-up doc (why?) and "if there is, we doubled-up". It's like a built in excuse for when the real person who protected Bryce shows up and counters. I just don't get why a townie who saved Bryce would phrase things this way

that being said, because of him not protecting patrick n4 i'm pretty sure ari is lying.

but does that make him cult leader? i dunno. could go either way with cult member or leader

Curtis @ 24/1/2016 15:05

"NIGHT 5: protected bryce. there may or may not be a back-up doc but if there's not (there probably isn't since they would've been on timmah last night), i saved bryce's life. if there is, we doubled-up. " This part in Brian's claim bothers me. If I was truly the person who protected Bryce that night I'd of course assume I was the only one since at this point any protection at all seemed unlikely So that line about doubling up stands out. If Scum Brian fake claimed he protected Bryce, he'd know that someone else out there actually did and will call him out on it, so he adds these lines about how there may or may not still be a back-up doc (why?) and "if there is, we doubled-up". It's like a built in excuse for when the real person who protected Bryce shows up and counters. I just don't get why a townie who saved Bryce would phrase things this way

what? we had back-up cop and vig already die.

i don't get what you mean

D4:

itsbrianyay @ 18/1/2016 0:03

i don't have any role-relavant information to add yet fyi BUT if i have a role i have been using it, i haven't been missing night actions.

Today:

Quote

NIGHT 2: didn't do shit, was away and missed deadline NIGHT 3: didn't do shit, was away and missed deadline

YUP!

i said that

"NIGHT 1: i watched curtis because I figured he'd be prime watcher material (it's actually what i had planned to do N1 of that game i actually WAS watcher but you dumb shits lynched me d1). shockingly no one visited him."

ALTHOUGH, how could Cult Leader Brian make this claim if he was lying? Anyone could've said hey one problem JACKASS I visited Curtis N1 and then Brian's claim goes to shit

The only way it makes sense for Ari to be lying is if Cult has heavy numbers and are about to win, even if they don't win right away with a mafia member left

5 Cult
1 Mafia?
4 Town

Ari lies to get a quick Townie Brian lynch. Cult recruits tonight

6 Cult
1 Mafia
2 Town

Mafia kills one of town or Mafia but it doesn't matter. At this point Cult just plays games with whoever is left. It would blow so bad if Cult is this big right now or even close

Curtis @ 24/1/2016 13:08

"NIGHT 1: i watched curtis because I figured he'd be prime watcher material (it's actually what i had planned to do N1 of that game i actually WAS watcher but you dumb shits lynched me d1). shockingly no one visited him." ALTHOUGH, how could Cult Leader Brian make this claim if he was lying? Anyone could've said hey one problem JACKASS I visited Curtis N1 and then Brian's claim goes to shit

Unless there is a Town Watcher out there who hasn't done anything useful yet, it's actually an easy claim to make. The Tracker (Bryce) already laid out his claims, and the Town Roleblocker and Town Motion Detector are already dead, so who would be left to counter his claim?