Chris25 @ 18/1/2015 17:39

What's FOS mean?

Finger of Suspicion

Angi @ 18/1/2015 18:40

Why is there a Wikey lynch? Can someone explain it to me in 100 words or less?

Inactivity, a general display of apathy to the game, and no serious contribution to ousting scum.

I believe that is why people are lynching me.

Angi @ 18/1/2015 17:39

And sorry I make you cringe JJ. But sometimes you are an abrasive bitch <3 but you're my abrasive bitch <3

this isn't funny or cute

Angi @ 18/1/2015 17:40

Why is there a Wikey lynch? Can someone explain it to me in 100 words or less?

This is Vic's reason:

Vic @ 17/1/2015 19:00

Looking at Korr's posts yesterday, he really only made two game related posts. The first one was in response to Lamps lynched Wikey and he asked why Wikey and why not someone like Matt or Nofo. THEN literally less than two minutes later he totally changed gears and said "Well looking at Wikey, he seems a bit odd to me. We got little time and I don't want Curtis to be lynched today." Maybe he was trying to protect Wikey when he started getting a little heat but then backed off because he knew it might not be necessary and could be obvious if either of them flipped? It's a stretch for sure, but it's possible!

JJ @ 18/1/2015 17:56

Angi @ 18/1/2015 17:39 And sorry I make you cringe JJ. But sometimes you are an abrasive bitch <3 but you're my abrasive bitch <3 this isn't funny or cute

Made me laugh lol :P


ok, well I don't get the Wikey lynch so I'm not joining it. lol

Angi @ 18/1/2015 18:09

ok, well I don't get the Wikey lynch so I'm not joining it. lol

I don't either.

I'll either stay with Paul or I might go back to Nofo. Re-reading his Day 2 posts he really didn't commit to anything. A lot of FOSing Matt but never lynching him. He lynched Ahoda to tie the vote between Ahoda/Curtis. Boc lynched him and I think Boc may have been right.

Day 3 a few posts agreeing with Vic on Wikey, then going against it, then going against Matt. Then pushing very hard for my lynch and then turning around and saying it was personal after I called him scummy for doing it. But no other talk of any suspects since and no votes.

Don't understand Rob's vote on Curtis. Or why he'd scan him twice. He could have told us the name of another person who's likely not a werewolf today.

Moose and Tony are lynching each other. lol and I wouldn't mind either being the candidate today.

Chris and Ahoda are lynching each other. Of the two, I'd lean toward an ahoda lynch. Mostly because he's wrong about me. He made the comment about me protecting Chris, so I brought up our relationship in general and last game, and how it relates to Chris in this game, and my opinion of him. That's how it's relevant. :P

The reasons Wikey gave himself for why people are lynching him are good reasons to lynch him. I'd jump on that train myself, but it seems weird to me that he's not really defending himself other than saying it's a stupid idea. I feel like maybe if he were scum, he'd put up more of a fight?

And I'm getting a town read from Lamps the most of everyone right now.

JJ @ 18/1/2015 19:25

Angi @ 18/1/2015 18:09 ok, well I don't get the Wikey lynch so I'm not joining it. lol I don't either. I'll either stay with Paul or I might go back to Nofo. Re-reading his Day 2 posts he really didn't commit to anything. A lot of FOSing Matt but never lynching him. He lynched Ahoda to tie the vote between Ahoda/Curtis. Boc lynched him and I think Boc may have been right. Day 3 a few posts agreeing with Vic on Wikey, then going against it, then going against Matt. Then pushing very hard for my lynch and then turning around and saying it was personal after I called him scummy for doing it. But no other talk of any suspects since and no votes.

If you're waiting for a claim, you're not getting one so go ahead.

Christian @ 18/1/2015 18:46

The reasons Wikey gave himself for why people are lynching him are good reasons to lynch him. I'd jump on that train myself, but it seems weird to me that he's not really defending himself other than saying it's a stupid idea. I feel like maybe if he were scum, he'd put up more of a fight?

I think Wikey's been catching up. He was reading Day 1, then Day 2 and Day 3. It could all be a big ruse I don't see it. He hasn't seemed like he's hiding anything to me.

Christian @ 18/1/2015 19:46

Don't understand Rob's vote on Curtis. Or why he'd scan him twice. He could have told us the name of another person who's likely not a werewolf today. Moose and Tony are lynching each other. lol and I wouldn't mind either being the candidate today. Chris and Ahoda are lynching each other. Of the two, I'd lean toward an ahoda lynch. Mostly because he's wrong about me. He made the comment about me protecting Chris, so I brought up our relationship in general and last game, and how it relates to Chris in this game, and my opinion of him. That's how it's relevant. :P The reasons Wikey gave himself for why people are lynching him are good reasons to lynch him. I'd jump on that train myself, but it seems weird to me that he's not really defending himself other than saying it's a stupid idea. I feel like maybe if he were scum, he'd put up more of a fight? And I'm getting a town read from Lamps the most of everyone right now.

Translates to:


Ahoda should be lynched because I'm protecting Chris some more.


Got it. Thanks.

I still don't understand why Chris is town because he was town in that other game... very sound logic from Christian. Confused town can be confused mafia too.

ahoda @ 18/1/2015 18:59

Christian @ 18/1/2015 19:46 Don't understand Rob's vote on Curtis. Or why he'd scan him twice. He could have told us the name of another person who's likely not a werewolf today. Moose and Tony are lynching each other. lol and I wouldn't mind either being the candidate today. Chris and Ahoda are lynching each other. Of the two, I'd lean toward an ahoda lynch. Mostly because he's wrong about me. He made the comment about me protecting Chris, so I brought up our relationship in general and last game, and how it relates to Chris in this game, and my opinion of him. That's how it's relevant. :P The reasons Wikey gave himself for why people are lynching him are good reasons to lynch him. I'd jump on that train myself, but it seems weird to me that he's not really defending himself other than saying it's a stupid idea. I feel like maybe if he were scum, he'd put up more of a fight? And I'm getting a town read from Lamps the most of everyone right now. Translates to: Ahoda should be lynched because I'm protecting Chris some more. Got it. Thanks.

Actually translates to:

I would lynch ahoda over Chris.
I would lynch you, Moose, Tony or Wikey today.

Christian @ 18/1/2015 20:04

ahoda @ 18/1/2015 18:59 Christian @ 18/1/2015 19:46 Don't understand Rob's vote on Curtis. Or why he'd scan him twice. He could have told us the name of another person who's likely not a werewolf today. Moose and Tony are lynching each other. lol and I wouldn't mind either being the candidate today. Chris and Ahoda are lynching each other. Of the two, I'd lean toward an ahoda lynch. Mostly because he's wrong about me. He made the comment about me protecting Chris, so I brought up our relationship in general and last game, and how it relates to Chris in this game, and my opinion of him. That's how it's relevant. :P The reasons Wikey gave himself for why people are lynching him are good reasons to lynch him. I'd jump on that train myself, but it seems weird to me that he's not really defending himself other than saying it's a stupid idea. I feel like maybe if he were scum, he'd put up more of a fight? And I'm getting a town read from Lamps the most of everyone right now. Translates to: Ahoda should be lynched because I'm protecting Chris some more. Got it. Thanks. Actually translates to: I would lynch ahoda over Chris. I would lynch you, Moose, Tony or Wikey today.

He's about to add me to the list now that he saw my post

Nofo ☭ @ 18/1/2015 19:01

I still don't understand why Chris is town because he was town in that other game... very sound logic from Christian. Confused town can be confused mafia too.

I had to "meta-game" to explain my reasoning. Chris was a pretty bad Town Cop the last time. This made me believe he doesn't really know how to play these very well in general. All I originally said was that I buy his claims of being confused about this game's setup. So yeah, I might lean towards him being Town. I've also said that doesn't clear him.

Well, I am all caught up! That was a long read.

Firstly, this lynch on me is ridiculous, and the only 'evidence' against me of any merit is the two Korr quotes from yesterday that Vic brought up. It's a sketchy case at best. I find it interesting how often my name has come up whilst reading back. Several players have done so. Nobert, Vic, Ari and Lamps, to name a few. Lamps is the worst though. I seem to be his number one suspect, and have been so since early Day 2, when all he had to go on was my Day 1 activity. I find it a bit odd how much he is going for me.

Anyways, there are a few major things that struck out to me.

- Moose's vanilla claim. I don't know what possessed her (sorry Moose, it's hard to differentiate gender with pixels!) to claim so early. It would be a pretty clever move if she is scum. I think town would buy someone messing up like that, given the confusing nature of this setup. What we need to decide is whether or not Moose genuinely got confused, or if she is a nasty liar. It surprises me that we aren't pursuing this more. I wonder if KC would even allow players to have the choice between the same role.

I mean, what happened? Did Moose get a PM from KC saying:

KC

Here are your role choices: Vanilla Town A Vanilla Town B WHICH ONE DO YOU CHOOSE?!

If this is what happened, surely she would just get a PM saying:

KC

Hey you shit, you drew Vanilla Town TWICE, so you don't get to choose. FUCK YOU! Enjoy the game :)

I find it unlikely that Moose didn't get a choice between two roles. Really unlikely. It's the premise of the game is it not?

- Another major thing to look at more is the shit storm following Rob's results on Curtis yesterday. The first thing that happened was that JJ brought up the possibility of the Alien Pyschothing. I can't give her too much credit for bringing this up, since the role was easily visible to anybody who cared to check. If JJ didn't bring it up, somebody else would have. From a scum perspective, it would make total sense to bring it up asap.

Vic and Nofo both joined the train. I didn't really like that they both posted something along the lines of "Unless something else comes up" with their posts. That doesn't strike me as a particularly town reaction to a cop revealing a positive scan result. Here are the quotes:

Vic

##lynch Curtis I'll go with this for now. What's the difference between Aliens and Werewolves? I still don't understand that.

Nofo

##Lynch Curtis Unless something more concrete pops up, I'm willing to believe a claim like that.

I don't know why Vic felt the need to remind everybody he was still confused about the setup. And Nofo...what is more concrete than a town cop saying he has a positive result on someone? I know that JJ was quick to point out the pyscho thing, and those scans can't be trusted in hindsight. But at the time, I would have expected their reactions to be more aggressive.

Moose followed this with an eerily similar post!

Moose

I could go with a Curtis lynch. ##lynch Curtis. The claim seems pretty solid, unless something else pops up.

Plenty of others joined the Curtis train, but these ones stuck out to me as scummy.