Prince Navneeta @ 23/12/2019 13:23

farlig @ 23/12/2019 10:19 But if he is telling the truth, failing is not being home, i.e. last night so IM knew wikey was lying from D2 so by picking him at least he learned something. Taking it to the grave yields nothing since the role is revealed anyway. Not getting any results out of his role because of his target dying is the same as failing, FUNCTIONALLY SPEAKING which is what I meant My point was that after seeing his role go to waste on N1, town!317 SHOULD have wanted a more sure thing rather than gamble on someone who may or may not have had a visiting role. His reasoning for picking Wikey sounds meh at best but Primate also looks just as bad if not worse so I don't think we can go wrong with either lynch.

So are we left to decide which role would be more beneficial to town if they both are telling the truth?

farlig @ 23/12/2019 10:29

Prince Navneeta @ 23/12/2019 13:23 farlig @ 23/12/2019 10:19 But if he is telling the truth, failing is not being home, i.e. last night so IM knew wikey was lying from D2 so by picking him at least he learned something. Taking it to the grave yields nothing since the role is revealed anyway. Not getting any results out of his role because of his target dying is the same as failing, FUNCTIONALLY SPEAKING which is what I meant My point was that after seeing his role go to waste on N1, town!317 SHOULD have wanted a more sure thing rather than gamble on someone who may or may not have had a visiting role. His reasoning for picking Wikey sounds meh at best but Primate also looks just as bad if not worse so I don't think we can go wrong with either lynch. So are we left to decide which role would be more beneficial to town if they both are telling the truth?

I don't think they're both telling the truth at all so this is a moot question for me.

Remember that primate was on Josh’s suspect list while IM wasn’t, so I think there is slightly more damning evidence against Primate

Prince Navneeta @ 23/12/2019 10:49

Good morning to everyone except Penner. I'm feeling better today and will be around to participate later when I get to work. Nothing happened to me for eating the cookie to my knowledge. I'll state on the im317 vs Primate thing that I don't think Primate is lying about being a Tracker. He could be scum tracker tho. I thought Caroler fit in to the theme better and still lean that way. Consider my vote on Primate in spirit.

Well you don’t think primate is lying about being tracker. You think that caroler fits the themes bet so your vote is on primate in spirit. Then you go on to have pause about IM so color me confused 🤷🏻‍♂️

farlig @ 23/12/2019 13:36

Prince Navneeta @ 23/12/2019 10:49 Good morning to everyone except Penner. I'm feeling better today and will be around to participate later when I get to work. Nothing happened to me for eating the cookie to my knowledge. I'll state on the im317 vs Primate thing that I don't think Primate is lying about being a Tracker. He could be scum tracker tho. I thought Caroler fit in to the theme better and still lean that way. Consider my vote on Primate in spirit. Well you don’t think primate is lying about being tracker. You think that caroler fits the themes bet so your vote is on primate in spirit. Then you go on to have pause about IM so color me confused 🤷🏻‍♂️

Nav is having a tough time trying to decide how much it’s worth putting up a fight to keep one scummate

farlig @ 23/12/2019 10:36

Prince Navneeta @ 23/12/2019 10:49 Good morning to everyone except Penner. I'm feeling better today and will be around to participate later when I get to work. Nothing happened to me for eating the cookie to my knowledge. I'll state on the im317 vs Primate thing that I don't think Primate is lying about being a Tracker. He could be scum tracker tho. I thought Caroler fit in to the theme better and still lean that way. Consider my vote on Primate in spirit. Well you don’t think primate is lying about being tracker. You think that caroler fits the themes bet so your vote is on primate in spirit. Then you go on to have pause about IM so color me confused 🤷🏻‍♂️

I can't have pause after re-reading? In order of likelihood I think it's

1. Primate = scum!Tracker and 317 = town!Caroler
2. Primate = town!Tracker and 317 - scum!???

The possibility of
Primate = town!Tracker and 317= town!Caroler doesn't exist for me

So should I make primate go poof and be 1 for 2?

farlig @ 23/12/2019 10:45

So should I make primate go poof and be 1 for 2?

Eh no need to end the day early imo. Let it marinate.

I think the only thing left to learn today is whether anyone is swapping presents.

And whether ahoda knows what is supposed to go in them.

Penner @ 23/12/2019 14:56

I think the only thing left to learn today is whether anyone is swapping presents. And whether ahoda knows what is supposed to go in them.

I don't. You want to co-mod for me?

Ahoda @ 23/12/2019 14:09

Penner @ 23/12/2019 14:56 I think the only thing left to learn today is whether anyone is swapping presents. And whether ahoda knows what is supposed to go in them. I don't. You want to co-mod for me?

I hear Curtis is available.

The "For Ginny" Day 3 Lynch Count

Primate (5/7) -- Christian, Penner, im317, farlig, Badger, Wikey
im317 (2/7) -- Farlig, Primate, Buffy

=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

WITH 13 PLAYERS ALIVE, IT'LL TAKE 7 VOTES FOR A LYNCH. DEADLINE IS AT 9 PM ET ON MONDAY.


NOTE: As of 8 AM ET Monday morning, Ahoda is in charge, so you will send any questions and all actions to him. I will try to check in as I can, but it'll be spotty until Friday night.

So do we plan to continue the game as currently paced? Or is there some type of holiday break? Even I’m celebrating this year.

Current Gift Order

Gift Order:
1. Penner - has gift from D2
2. Primate - has gift from D2
3. Buffy - keeps gift
4. Nav - keeps gift
5. Gmaj - keeps gift
6. Wikey - keeps gift
7. Farlig - keeps gift
8. Havo - keeps gift
9. Christian - keeps gift
10. im317
11. Badger
12. Jamie
13. Herm

Penner @ 23/12/2019 15:23

So do we plan to continue the game as currently paced? Or is there some type of holiday break? Even I’m celebrating this year.

The next day phase may last 48 hours unless you guys lynch early. I honestly haven't decided yet.


Like this post for 24 hour day

Dislike this post for 48 hour day

Do nothing if you worship Satan.