Was not aware that I wasn't playing.

@Cultis,

I don't believe his role but other, more vocal Townies (people who I think are Town aligned) do so it's not worth beating a dead horse. There's other Mafia out there (which we can all agree on) so my time is better spent trying to find them.

Zersch @ 25/11/2018 15:11

I felt like Curtis was claiming Mayor. Or an X-Menified version of the role.

if that were the case, they wouldn't be that similar.

My thoughts (which I never said would be good thoughts) are:

Brian's role as it appears, doesn't seem like a scum role, or at least not part of the mafia. If he wasn't caught up, etc. when he came out with that information, does this make him look better or worse? I mean, he only had one vote on him, but it did seem like he was trying to maybe goad people into joining the train.

If Curtis has the same type of role, as scum, would he try to counter the claim, exposing himself to catch someone, who may have been lynched without any kind of help at all. :P

I think it's possible both are town, but if their roles are exactly the same-ish, then I don't. Maybe. Help.

But I also don't know how much Curtis should share right now.

Mads @ 25/11/2018 15:23

Was not aware that I wasn't playing.

I just don't it to be a thing every game. And, I meant in relation to me - why is it so hard to agree with me? :P

I am leaning scum on nav now.
I am almost sure Helios is scum.
Wikey is probably scum.
Jamie protecting Shawn makes no sense. Then again, going after a guy who never posts for not posting on d3 looks like a lazy scum move.

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 15:27

Mads @ 25/11/2018 15:23 Was not aware that I wasn't playing. I just don't it to be a thing every game. And, I meant in relation to me - why is it so hard to agree with me? :P

I think when you don't think I'm scum, everyone should agree with you. :P

Christian @ 25/11/2018 15:26

Zersch @ 25/11/2018 15:11 I felt like Curtis was claiming Mayor. Or an X-Menified version of the role. if that were the case, they wouldn't be that similar. My thoughts (which I never said would be good thoughts) are: Brian's role as it appears, doesn't seem like a scum role, or at least not part of the mafia. If he wasn't caught up, etc. when he came out with that information, does this make him look better or worse? I mean, he only had one vote on him, but it did seem like he was trying to maybe goad people into joining the train. If Curtis has the same type of role, as scum, would he try to counter the claim, exposing himself to catch someone, who may have been lynched without any kind of help at all. :P I think it's possible both are town, but if their roles are exactly the same-ish, then I don't. Maybe. Help.

I don't even know what kind of role Brian is alluding to - and I'm not trying to pull out any info about it. I don't know why it was necessary to put it out there, esp if he's not targetable at night, which he seems to be saying. I'm not sure if that was a town or scum declaration so idk. Probably lean town atm I guess.

Primate @ 25/11/2018 14:27

I am leaning scum on nav now. I am almost sure Helios is scum. Wikey is probably scum. Jamie protecting Shawn makes no sense. Then again, going after a guy who never posts for not posting on d3 looks like a lazy scum move.

Forgot to mention, this brings me back to leaning scum on herm.

##lynch helios

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 15:30

Christian @ 25/11/2018 15:26 Zersch @ 25/11/2018 15:11 I felt like Curtis was claiming Mayor. Or an X-Menified version of the role. if that were the case, they wouldn't be that similar. My thoughts (which I never said would be good thoughts) are: Brian's role as it appears, doesn't seem like a scum role, or at least not part of the mafia. If he wasn't caught up, etc. when he came out with that information, does this make him look better or worse? I mean, he only had one vote on him, but it did seem like he was trying to maybe goad people into joining the train. If Curtis has the same type of role, as scum, would he try to counter the claim, exposing himself to catch someone, who may have been lynched without any kind of help at all. :P I think it's possible both are town, but if their roles are exactly the same-ish, then I don't. Maybe. Help. I don't even know what kind of role Brian is alluding to - and I'm not trying to pull out any info about it. I don't know why it was necessary to put it out there, esp if he's not targetable at night, which he seems to be saying. I'm not sure if that was a town or scum declaration so idk. Probably lean town atm I guess.

he said it's possible for him to die, but more difficult, so I don't know what exactly that means. But the Mafia had a Godfather who was immune to attacks, so would it make sense to have both in the same faction? Assuming of course, that he's telling the truth.

Primate @ 25/11/2018 15:31

##lynch helios

I believe Helios is voting for Mike, right now. I don't hate the Mike vote, but it seems kind of lazy/safe?

I don't see mafia having more than the 2 night survivals we have already seen unless we have one or more really small mafia groups.

Christian @ 25/11/2018 15:35

Primate @ 25/11/2018 15:31 ##lynch helios I believe Helios is voting for Mike, right now. I don't hate the Mike vote, but it seems kind of lazy/safe?

very

Or cult or town.