Wikey @ 10/4/2016 16:40

This is a mess. I wish I'd stayed inactive!

I wish you had to. lol

And "It might actually not be a bad idea to consider our options outside of the list"?

Hopefully the game doesn't end after the list is taken care of, but yeah, we should always be discussing everything and everyone.

Boc @ 10/4/2016 16:52

Wikey @ 10/4/2016 16:40 Yeah flavour wise, it definitely would make more sense for Boc to be affiliated with the raiders if he is an infiltrator. Rose actually defended him a fair bit, it should be noted. The problem is that one scum team having an infiltrator makes less and less sense the more I think about it. It seems like a rather unfair advantage to confer on just one mafia team. But at the same time...Bocs actions were shady. This is a mess. I wish I'd stayed inactive! The fact that my actions were shady I feel helps clear me if anything. Like I said before, there was NO reason for me to out Zook unless it was for a side win. I'd like someone to name a single reason for Scum Boc to do that getting scummy vibes from this post tbh and it's not just because it's against me (:

I've said already that if you was a scum traitor who didn't know the identity of your teammates, trying to get the backup vig lynched makes sense. You wouldn't be able to steer kills in your preferred direction if you didn't know who your team were, so trying to take the vig out might be preferable.

thisisbad, first of all, you think I"m Mafia? Secondly, you think I'm on the same Mafia team as Wikey and Lamps?? Thirdly, if you think I'm Mafia, why are you not voting for me right now???

thisisbad @ 10/4/2016 16:56

Boc @ 10/4/2016 15:49 Christian @ 10/4/2016 16:32 Boc, what are your thoughts on the people outside of you, me and Curtis? I still think Wikey has acted fishy this game, but his posts today have put at least some context into it. I could see him jokingly talking about his "powerful role" on D1 if he got stuck with vanilla I honestly don't have any strong reads on most people because I've been shit and skimming a lot of the game The ones that are lurking I'd look at the most. Even though Chris is like this every game regardless of alignment, his posts come off as more scummy to me. Sabataged, Zero, Patrick, thisisbad, and maybe Vernon I feel fall under the possible scummy lurker category as well Vlad has seemed pretty town to me. Maybe Herm too, though it's hard to get a read on him either way usually I keep seeing my name thrown out.mbut I've been clear in posting ,y suspicions and throwing out names. People here read want they want. Lamps is scum to me, the. Christian/Curtis have taken up much of the day. Why would I add to that mess? And certain people are breaking up their thoughts into 4 posts just to seem more active. Is that what you prefer? I just got home and can switch to the laptop

why so defensive? (: Your name was one of five I was throwing out

I'm not just talking about today, from what I can remember you've been like this most of the game. It's not like you've been making these huge posts breaking stuff down so I'm not sure what the second part of your post is about

ftr you're probably the last out of those five (six counting Chris) that I'd go for tho. I do agree that at least you're throwing out concrete suspicions for the most part, rather than just posting to appear active

Wikey @ 10/4/2016 17:23

Boc @ 10/4/2016 16:52 Wikey @ 10/4/2016 16:40 Yeah flavour wise, it definitely would make more sense for Boc to be affiliated with the raiders if he is an infiltrator. Rose actually defended him a fair bit, it should be noted. The problem is that one scum team having an infiltrator makes less and less sense the more I think about it. It seems like a rather unfair advantage to confer on just one mafia team. But at the same time...Bocs actions were shady. This is a mess. I wish I'd stayed inactive! The fact that my actions were shady I feel helps clear me if anything. Like I said before, there was NO reason for me to out Zook unless it was for a side win. I'd like someone to name a single reason for Scum Boc to do that getting scummy vibes from this post tbh and it's not just because it's against me (: I've said already that if you was a scum traitor who didn't know the identity of your teammates, trying to get the backup vig lynched makes sense. You wouldn't be able to steer kills in your preferred direction if you didn't know who your team were, so trying to take the vig out might be preferable.

considering his plan was to take out all the investigative roles, I definitely would've just let him be (:

Christian @ 10/4/2016 16:24

thisisbad, first of all, you think I"m Mafia? Secondly, you think I'm on the same Mafia team as Wikey and Lamps?? Thirdly, if you think I'm Mafia, why are you not voting for me right now???

Thats a guess. It's between you and Curtis it seems. I haven't sorted that in my head, so i'm reluctant to vote.

I feel comfortable voting Lamps. No one has given me a single reason not to. I'd like to think if i came in and said everything he/she did, i'd be voted out.

The scan he did was wrong. The poisoning thing was a flat out lie. We actually had someone else claim that AND THEN DIE.

for reference, if Lamps claimed cop, then someone else claimed cop, and person b died and was revealed as cop, we'd have speed lynched Lamps.

It's hard for me to want to lynch Christian/Curtis because they are both active and hunting. If they are scum, they are playing it off really well. I want to believe Boc is scum over the two of them. But Christian's role/claim is one of the worst ever. If that's your actual role, i'd have a stern talking with Ahoda. Maybe even use a curse word.

Boc @ 10/4/2016 16:26

thisisbad @ 10/4/2016 16:56 Boc @ 10/4/2016 15:49 Christian @ 10/4/2016 16:32 Boc, what are your thoughts on the people outside of you, me and Curtis? I still think Wikey has acted fishy this game, but his posts today have put at least some context into it. I could see him jokingly talking about his "powerful role" on D1 if he got stuck with vanilla I honestly don't have any strong reads on most people because I've been shit and skimming a lot of the game The ones that are lurking I'd look at the most. Even though Chris is like this every game regardless of alignment, his posts come off as more scummy to me. Sabataged, Zero, Patrick, thisisbad, and maybe Vernon I feel fall under the possible scummy lurker category as well Vlad has seemed pretty town to me. Maybe Herm too, though it's hard to get a read on him either way usually I keep seeing my name thrown out.mbut I've been clear in posting ,y suspicions and throwing out names. People here read want they want. Lamps is scum to me, the. Christian/Curtis have taken up much of the day. Why would I add to that mess? And certain people are breaking up their thoughts into 4 posts just to seem more active. Is that what you prefer? I just got home and can switch to the laptop why so defensive? (: Your name was one of five I was throwing out I'm not just talking about today, from what I can remember you've been like this most of the game. It's not like you've been making these huge posts breaking stuff down so I'm not sure what the second part of your post is about ftr you're probably the last out of those five (six counting Chris) that I'd go for tho. I do agree that at least you're throwing out concrete suspicions for the most part, rather than just posting to appear active

Yeah i'm defensive. If this game ends and Lamps flips scum and wins, i'll be unhappy. But because i'm not in the middle of the Christian/Curtis debate, people think i'm not breaking it down.

thisisbad @ 10/4/2016 16:33

Boc @ 10/4/2016 16:26 thisisbad @ 10/4/2016 16:56 Boc @ 10/4/2016 15:49 Christian @ 10/4/2016 16:32 Boc, what are your thoughts on the people outside of you, me and Curtis? I still think Wikey has acted fishy this game, but his posts today have put at least some context into it. I could see him jokingly talking about his "powerful role" on D1 if he got stuck with vanilla I honestly don't have any strong reads on most people because I've been shit and skimming a lot of the game The ones that are lurking I'd look at the most. Even though Chris is like this every game regardless of alignment, his posts come off as more scummy to me. Sabataged, Zero, Patrick, thisisbad, and maybe Vernon I feel fall under the possible scummy lurker category as well Vlad has seemed pretty town to me. Maybe Herm too, though it's hard to get a read on him either way usually I keep seeing my name thrown out.mbut I've been clear in posting ,y suspicions and throwing out names. People here read want they want. Lamps is scum to me, the. Christian/Curtis have taken up much of the day. Why would I add to that mess? And certain people are breaking up their thoughts into 4 posts just to seem more active. Is that what you prefer? I just got home and can switch to the laptop why so defensive? (: Your name was one of five I was throwing out I'm not just talking about today, from what I can remember you've been like this most of the game. It's not like you've been making these huge posts breaking stuff down so I'm not sure what the second part of your post is about ftr you're probably the last out of those five (six counting Chris) that I'd go for tho. I do agree that at least you're throwing out concrete suspicions for the most part, rather than just posting to appear active Yeah i'm defensive. If this game ends and Lamps flips scum and wins, i'll be unhappy. But because i'm not in the middle of the Christian/Curtis debate, people think i'm not breaking it down.

The second part of my post is exactly what i just did. I could have put it into one post, i broke it into 2, and now i seem more active. Yay me

With two mafia's, it's easier for scum to appear active and scum hunt while still being mafia. I think that's what's throwing me off with the top 2 (Curtis/Christian)

Lamps and Vernon are now my top 2 suspects.

ok just caught up on Curtis/Christian's claims and they both seem pretty sketch to me

Christian's is very TOWN SHOPPA-like. A convenient non-vanilla claim which is essentially unprovable. If his posts didn't seem so town-ish to me I would strongly consider lynching him

Curtis says his role is a "typical" hermit (a role that me and him basically made up for ATTWS iirc, I don't think it's been used outside that series) and then says the mods would confirm him as town? wut?? That wouldn't be typical at all. The way the hermit role has worked is that that person is protected from kills/lynches for a night/day phase. Nowhere did it ever say that the mods would confirm them as town. I'm really surprised Herm didn't call him out on this, unless I missed it

The whole thing seems like a ploy by him to survive one extra day

3 Users Viewing (3 Members):
Boc, Curtis, Christian

lel

Curtis said he could prove his role.

Boc

Curtis says his role is a "typical" hermit (a role that me and him basically made up for ATTWS iirc, I don't think it's been used outside that series) and then says the mods would confirm him as town? wut?? That wouldn't be typical at all. The way the hermit role has worked is that that person is protected from kills/lynches for a night/day phase. Nowhere did it ever say that the mods would confirm them as town. I'm really surprised Herm didn't call him out on this, unless I missed it

No. I did not call him out on this, I lynched him for this.

He then got super frustrated because I didn't believe him so I'm not sure what that's about. If he's scum I'm lynching him next game.

It's really just a tree stump Boc. They called it Hermit but it's just a typical tree stump really, there's no difference. That's what I meant (: . Maybe it's to fit the theme more idk