Everyone making the argument that scum would have refrained from voting on Day 2 seems to be forgetting that scum get called out all the time for sitting back and lurking, going with the flow and not coming up with any thoughts of their own. Experienced players know not to do this.

Also, why are we assuming that Dadd's actions represent the entire Mafia?

Vic @ 20/1/2016 18:30

Jay Badger im317 That's who id like to lynch in that order

And you have still given 0 reasons why.

Jayadamo @ 20/1/2016 13:34

Vic @ 20/1/2016 18:30 Jay Badger im317 That's who id like to lynch in that order And you have still given 0 reasons why.

My gut!

Vic @ 20/1/2016 18:36

Jayadamo @ 20/1/2016 13:34 Vic @ 20/1/2016 18:30 Jay Badger im317 That's who id like to lynch in that order And you have still given 0 reasons why. My gut!

You should have a doctor look at that for you because it is all kinds of messed up.

It's also interesting that you showed up as soon as you got some heat after the end of yesterday. Did your scum team tell you over night??

Vic @ 20/1/2016 18:40

It's also interesting that you showed up as soon as you got some heat after the end of yesterday. Did your scum team tell you over night??

I voted Herm and went to bed. I got up took my wife to the doctor and then came back and read the day. Would you prefer that I just don't post?

No I'm just saying it's the first time you're consistently active this game

Jayadamo @ 20/1/2016 18:41

Vic @ 20/1/2016 18:40 It's also interesting that you showed up as soon as you got some heat after the end of yesterday. Did your scum team tell you over night?? I voted Herm and went to bed. I got up took my wife to the doctor and then came back and read the day. Would you prefer that I just don't post?

And where is this "heat" I got at the end of yesterday? I don't see my name on the final vote count.

Wikey @ 20/1/2016 13:32

Everyone making the argument that scum would have refrained from voting on Day 2 seems to be forgetting that scum get called out all the time for sitting back and lurking, going with the flow and not coming up with any thoughts of their own. Experienced players know not to do this. Also, why are we assuming that Dadd's actions represent the entire Mafia?

I don't think anyone is saying that scum would not have voted on D2, only that in all of that chaos, there were a lot of different options that wouldn't involve voting a scum buddy in a volatile and rapidly changing situation. Perhaps they did, but the simplest logic would suggest that mafia probably would not have. Plus, starting with the premise that it is unlikely that mafia voted Miko at the tail end of D2 provides a frame of reference for analyzing other aspects of the game. Without using something as a frame of reference, it's impossible to figure anything out in a game like this, barring a power role feeding us info. Could that original premise be wrong? Sure. But, we have to start some place.

Vic @ 20/1/2016 18:42

No I'm just saying it's the first time you're consistently active this game

I have explained why I haven't been playing. Have you seen my name on the list of people online anytime this game when I didn't post?

Curtis @ 20/1/2016 12:54

##Lynch Badger Still my top read atm etc. Plus I want him to talk more

Unfortunately I can't really talk that much before work finishes which is after deadline. I'll check in at lunch break to see if you guys want me to claim. Honestly I don't have much to contribute about who I think is scum anyways.

Sorry for not being active today. I was around last night but found myself actually getting angry about this thread which is stupid because it's a game and really who the fuck cares. But for some reason it was legitimately getting under my skin and if I participated I'd just fly off the handle at people and maybe say things I'd regret (which I realize how rediculous that sounds but whatever it is what it is) so I decided not to post at all.

Anyways, I'm legit town but this game has been purely annoying for me so I'm past the point of caring if you change your lynch vote.

I'll check in shortly when I have a real break.

Wikey, why the hard push on me? you say i could have voted Miko to distance myself from him. in that case Miko could have voted you to distance himself from you, also you didn't vote for anyone.

Badger if you were me you would've gone on a mass shooting spree years ago with the heat I always get. It's nothing to get flustered over

You don't have any scum reads at all Badger?

I'm confused about what has happened to make Badger so frustrated and angry?