I mean, Penner is pretty much confirmed as town, but what he did is pretty much the same as quoting his pm from the mod. Very much against the spirit of the game.

itsbrianyay @ 29/4/2020 13:24

The leader is able to do whatever they want at night, it’s only the lookout who cannot as far as I can tell. I’m happy to be leader but would not like to be lookout. No helios I don’t know how I got it, just that someone gave it to me. Also a trader (same one maybe? I don’t know) contacted me again and I’ll probably be accepting this offer so at least I’ll have a little extra.

clearly i need to pay more attention to the details

Lamps @ 29/4/2020 13:08

Oh I hate that type of mod confirmation. (And I’ve been guilty of it in the past, too) Penner would you like my vote for leader or lookout?

I should be leader

Timmah @ 29/4/2020 13:29

I mean, Penner is pretty much confirmed as town, but what he did is pretty much the same as quoting his pm from the mod. Very much against the spirit of the game.

It’s not a quote. I used my own words.

you used a specific piece of your role pm to mod confirm yourself. It's a shit thing to do, and is the same spirit as quoting your pm.

Timmah @ 29/4/2020 13:37

you used a specific piece of your role pm to mod confirm yourself. It's a shit thing to do, and is the same spirit as quoting your pm.

I don’t understand why you’re getting heated over something that, if you are Town, would benefit you

I don't know, I still don't buy it. He still could have just seen they were colored in general and gotten context clues from old games about what colors the hosts use. It's not that much of a stretch to think Penner would do something like that.

But I agree, it's a shitty way to play either way. It's already turned it into a meta conversation rather than actual mafia. Are you having fun, Penner? (:

I have fun when scum die.

Penner @ 29/4/2020 12:38

Timmah @ 29/4/2020 13:37 you used a specific piece of your role pm to mod confirm yourself. It's a shit thing to do, and is the same spirit as quoting your pm. I don’t understand why you’re getting heated over something that, if you are Town, would benefit you

Because I dislike playing the game that way. Always have. To me it is like cheating. I don't like mass claiming either because it puts the game on easy mode and makes it hard on non town to win, but it's not really against the rules so I go along with it grudgingly.

Penner @ 29/4/2020 12:38

Timmah @ 29/4/2020 13:37 you used a specific piece of your role pm to mod confirm yourself. It's a shit thing to do, and is the same spirit as quoting your pm. I don’t understand why you’re getting heated over something that, if you are Town, would benefit you

Game integrity.

If what you're saying is true, then Timmah is 100% right. Regardless of whether or not it benefits Town, if you did what it seems like you did, it may not break the letter of the law, but it sure as shit breaks the spirit of it.

Penner @ 29/4/2020 12:41

I have fun when scum die.

So you have not had any fun yet in this game.

Elect Brian: he believes in the Spirit of the Game

##elect Brian leader

Catching up.

Timmah @ 29/4/2020 13:42

Penner @ 29/4/2020 12:41 I have fun when scum die. So you have not had any fun yet in this game.

No, and I didn’t have fun last game either. Let me have my first fun in weeks.

Guys i'm not a seasoned mafia veteran but like, if you could just accurately state your role font color on Day 1 then be confirmed as soon as someone turns up dead, wouldn't town just do that every single game?