Lamps @ 12/8/2019 6:55

Oh right yeah it was kind of obvious that Penner or Farlig were going to get killed? xD

Couldn't pick Penner again after N3

Right. Then what about Penner. Sure, Farlig could have self protected. But what about Penner? Possibly let our town tracker die?

Also. Saying “mafia I welcome your kill tonight” is by no means “baiting a kill” but uh... nice try?

Prince Navneeta @ 12/8/2019 7:57

Lamps @ 12/8/2019 6:55 Oh right yeah it was kind of obvious that Penner or Farlig were going to get killed? xD Couldn't pick Penner again after N3

So during N2. Who was your scum read and town read between Penner and Farlig?

##Lynch Herm


I submitted the daykill for Josh just FYI

Oh oh. You bussed Penner and Herm. Nvm move along.

Fine. I might believe Nav.

I hope Josh is mafia and not a 3P

We're running out of scum suspects.

Ftr, if Josh/Cavin were the scum, I believe we're only dealing with 2 Mafia, so two more to go.

If Josh is Mafia Poisoner, I think we're dealing with a total of 6 Mafia players.

7 total scum in a game of 22 sounds logical to me.

I just don’t see why a 3P poisoner would wait until N3 to use their action

Cody @ 12/8/2019 10:09

I just don’t see why a 3P poisoner would wait until N3 to use their action

I tried to use it N2 <3

##lynch Herm

i cannot believe y’all wasted a daykill on me

MADNESS!

Calvin's Win Condition

Win Condition: You win when everyone else is dead, even if you aren't alive.

Does this specific win condition lend credibility to Josh's role?

Also. I wonder if Cavin meant by “wonky results” that Curtis died instead of Rodney. He claimed unsuccessful later but I’m willing to bet he did kill rod-> Curtis

Which actually brings me to my next point. Cavin said he visited Rod and had unsuccessful. And then Nav said that would make sense? How would that make sense? Wouldn’t any action go to curtis and still go through? At that point Nav should have known he was SK. Yet didn’t fully out him until days later? Sounds like mafia wanting to keep a Sk around but! What do I know

You're still the cutest Joshie