I wish this site would allow you to quote closed threads so I could actually make my case

in that post i just linked to she says she is not going to lynch either me or tib today (d1) and then d2 she susses Ahoda for not wanting to lynch DS/Tib.

Buffy @ 29/7/2019 14:35

I'm just going to ##lynch Ahoda for now - the Mittens lynch was sketch even though it turned out well for us in the long run. Like maybe a way to keep the DS/TIB thing unresolved? And there is def something up with either DS or TIB. I think I trust TIB more. Thoughts TIB?

Thisisbad @ 30/7/2019 19:09

While i do agree that the game setup speculation prob doesn't help, i can def buy into 2 scum vs 3 at this point. I don't hate the Ahoda lynch. He and Ds being after JJ is a little..odd at this point. I'm still trying to process the Herm/Havo thing for me, and Brian kinda pings my radar a little. I don't really have any original thoughts at this stage. I think if i buy into 2 scum (agreed the Mittens role could have been powerful) this this lynch isn't as dire as i once though.

I agree with your first sentence. Brian gives me good vibes. Havo does as well.

I think if Ahoda turns out NOT to be scum I'd put Josh up at the top along with DS. I feel kinda somewhat good about Herm and you atm, Cody kinda 50/50.

DS @ 30/7/2019 19:33

in that post i just linked to she says she is not going to lynch either me or tib today (d1) and then d2 she susses Ahoda for not wanting to lynch DS/Tib. Buffy @ 29/7/2019 14:35 I'm just going to ##lynch Ahoda for now - the Mittens lynch was sketch even though it turned out well for us in the long run. Like maybe a way to keep the DS/TIB thing unresolved? And there is def something up with either DS or TIB. I think I trust TIB more. Thoughts TIB?

There's this weird thing about how thoughts are fluid throughout the day based on posts, etc, when you're actually reading/processing. You should try it out. It's fun.

Nah, thats not a fluid thought, thats a complete and utter reversal of position on something which is scummy as fuck because you are just trying to push the lynch onto Ahoda here

Buffy @ 30/7/2019 19:34

Thisisbad @ 30/7/2019 19:09 While i do agree that the game setup speculation prob doesn't help, i can def buy into 2 scum vs 3 at this point. I don't hate the Ahoda lynch. He and Ds being after JJ is a little..odd at this point. I'm still trying to process the Herm/Havo thing for me, and Brian kinda pings my radar a little. I don't really have any original thoughts at this stage. I think if i buy into 2 scum (agreed the Mittens role could have been powerful) this this lynch isn't as dire as i once though. I agree with your first sentence. Brian gives me good vibes. Havo does as well. I think if Ahoda turns out NOT to be scum I'd put Josh up at the top along with DS. I feel kinda somewhat good about Herm and you atm, Cody kinda 50/50.

*first paragraph not sentence

Ahoda hasn't done anything even remotely scummy here. He called out Mittens for an obvious scum slip yesterday (and dont say oh mittens wasnt scum etc because he obviously was thinking of the game with the idea that he could be scum) and then he lynched him. Thats town ahoda 100%

DS people are not disbelieving you because you’re you, they’re trusting buffy because of their own reads and subtext

itsbrianyay @ 30/7/2019 15:38

DS people are not disbelieving you because you’re you, they’re trusting buffy because of their own reads and subtext

No one even commented on the case I was presenting, so Im asking you all to give thoughts on it.

DS @ 30/7/2019 19:40

itsbrianyay @ 30/7/2019 15:38 DS people are not disbelieving you because you’re you, they’re trusting buffy because of their own reads and subtext No one even commented on the case I was presenting, so Im asking you all to give thoughts on it.

Your case is incorrect. Those are my thoughts.

One thing ive learned from Mafia451 is to not engage with scum

I don't read Buffy as scum this game.

I think if you genuinely look at who Buffy is putting in her POE its just the low hanging fruit. To me thats obvious because I know im town and im in that poe, but she is saying that her potential scum is

Ahoda - who is a standard early game lynch
DS - who yall love to lynch
Josh - who was inactive like all of d1 because he was scooping ice cream

You see why I think this is total bullshit right? Shes pushing people who are easy to push

Buffy @ 30/7/2019 15:34

Thisisbad @ 30/7/2019 19:09 While i do agree that the game setup speculation prob doesn't help, i can def buy into 2 scum vs 3 at this point. I don't hate the Ahoda lynch. He and Ds being after JJ is a little..odd at this point. I'm still trying to process the Herm/Havo thing for me, and Brian kinda pings my radar a little. I don't really have any original thoughts at this stage. I think if i buy into 2 scum (agreed the Mittens role could have been powerful) this this lynch isn't as dire as i once though. I agree with your first sentence. Brian gives me good vibes. Havo does as well. I think if Ahoda turns out NOT to be scum I'd put Josh up at the top along with DS. I feel kinda somewhat good about Herm and you atm, Cody kinda 50/50.

Then here she says essentially

If Ahoda - her top scum read - doesnt turn out to be scum - we just go down the list and slot in the next person without even considering the alignment of others in relation to a town Ahoda

DS, who do you think is scum other than Buffy?