Herm @ 25/11/2018 13:12

Out of Kat, Merc, Shawn, Brian, Wikey and Zersch, I would lynch most. Merc looks the best from his Day 1 lynch of Rose.

Still catching up, but this post makes me feel real good about Herm.

Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 14:49

Curtis @ 25/11/2018 11:45 Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 14:44 Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 11:32 Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 14:20 Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 11:16 Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 14:14 My thoughts on jamie haven't changed a whole lot. His role sounds very out of place to me. He looks better because of im317 going hard against him but that was during the time when I was the leading vote getter. Why is his role "out of place?" I can't even understand this reasoning. It's like you're speaking a foreign language. Of all the roles to be suspicious about... is it just that you've never seen it before? I think I've seen a variation of it before but nothing that's so detrimental. It just doesn't seem like it fits in with the theme of this game. What do you mean "all the roles to be suspicious about" what other roles are there to be suspicious about. brian's lynchproof/bulletproof claim? Thematically it makes sense for something like that to exist. Or he could be trying to draw a kill or lynch on himself. I mean of any roles in general. Also, I think you should stop trying to match it up with a character. The role name "The Leader" could have served enough of a thematic purpose for Shadow. If you're town, I think you're really way over-thinking the theme. I'm not going to lynch him or even bring him up for the foreseeable future if that is what you are worried about. Why? You’ve been so convinced he’s scum And I could very well be wrong. My D1 vote on him was for sheer laughs. Then when he claimed I didn't believe his role (and still don't) but there is no reason to tunnel on him. He's fully claimed with role name and everything so there's a decent chance he is telling the truth and I'm wrong about my suspicions. Even if he is Mafia, he isn't the only Mafia left. I can try to find the others before coming back to him again.

You don’t believe his role but you’re gonna look for other mafia instead

That’s a strategy

Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 14:44

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 11:32 Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 14:20 Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 11:16 Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 14:14 My thoughts on jamie haven't changed a whole lot. His role sounds very out of place to me. He looks better because of im317 going hard against him but that was during the time when I was the leading vote getter. Why is his role "out of place?" I can't even understand this reasoning. It's like you're speaking a foreign language. Of all the roles to be suspicious about... is it just that you've never seen it before? I think I've seen a variation of it before but nothing that's so detrimental. It just doesn't seem like it fits in with the theme of this game. What do you mean "all the roles to be suspicious about" what other roles are there to be suspicious about. brian's lynchproof/bulletproof claim? Thematically it makes sense for something like that to exist. Or he could be trying to draw a kill or lynch on himself. I mean of any roles in general. Also, I think you should stop trying to match it up with a character. The role name "The Leader" could have served enough of a thematic purpose for Shadow. If you're town, I think you're really way over-thinking the theme. I'm not going to lynch him or even bring him up for the foreseeable future if that is what you are worried about.

I'm not worried. I'm just wondering if you're scum or just stubborn. Not that everyone has to think like me (lord help us if they did) I'm just trying to wrap my head around your thinking process.

Jamie how do you have any sort of read on Shawn at all? Especially given the role you're claiming (which is not an investigative one) ?


JUST CURIOUS because we have so little to work with given Shawn's posts in this game.

Mads @ 25/11/2018 14:59

Jamie how do you have any sort of read on Shawn at all? Especially given the role you're claiming (which is not an investigative one) ? JUST CURIOUS because we have so little to work with given Shawn's posts in this game.

I feel it in my gut and correct where it does not have to do with my role at all

Curtis, current thoughts on Brian?

Everyone else, remember when I was banging about Nav and everyone was like "you're so silly, you scum"? You're all now doing what I was doing, but I did it first. :P

Helios posts D2 don't look great, either. I just read through them and he didn't vote or put hard pressure on anyone. Just talked about semantics of vote manipulation roles, etc. Gives me vibes. I do doubt Nav/Helios are scum together, given that they voted together on Jamie D1.

I have thoughts about the Brian/Curtis thing, but I'll wait for a couple of peeps to chime in first.

Christian is looking better to me, today, js.

I felt like Curtis was claiming Mayor. Or an X-Menified version of the role.

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 16:06

Christian is looking better to me, today, js.

Agreed.

I'm agreeing with Buffy too much in general...NOT SURE WHAT TO MAKE OF THIS JJ.

Mads @ 25/11/2018 15:14

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 16:06 Christian is looking better to me, today, js. Agreed. I'm agreeing with Buffy too much in general...NOT SURE WHAT TO MAKE OF THIS JJ.

tbh I think you should stop saying stuff like this every game and just play

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 16:17

Mads @ 25/11/2018 15:14 Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 16:06 Christian is looking better to me, today, js. Agreed. I'm agreeing with Buffy too much in general...NOT SURE WHAT TO MAKE OF THIS JJ. tbh I think you should stop saying stuff like this every game and just play

I think you took that the wrong way but ok

Maddie you just got fuckin' told.