If Rose is town, then there has to be another powerful third party in play.

Maybe the mass claim thing isn't such a good idea after all.

Mike @ 29/10/2018 12:51

Why Merc last night Mittens? You said yourself that Mafia ain't doing too good right now, and Merc was a suspect going into today

I like to play dangerously.

Mike, is there a reason why you think we have a powerful 3P? Maybe you’ve said already and I missed it.

I honestly thought you had a census which is why you seemed so insistent. Idk if that’s the case now but just wanna check.

I love this role, and if it's not real this game, someone should make it real in the next

Mittens @ 29/10/2018 12:53

Mike @ 29/10/2018 12:51 Why Merc last night Mittens? You said yourself that Mafia ain't doing too good right now, and Merc was a suspect going into today I like to play dangerously.

But in all honesty, I had forgotten to submit an action until yesterday afternoon - quick went on to send it in (didn't want it to be randomized or some shit), and thought it'd be worth the risk to try and clear someone who had lots of suspicion on him, including from me.

Mittens couldn't become mafia, learn who they are, then be town the next night

And no way does he visit merc.

Thisisbad @ 29/10/2018 12:56

Mittens couldn't become mafia, learn who they are, then be town the next night And no way does he visit merc.

I don't have any clue if I learn who they are. Did you read the two possibilities I posted?

Did mittens comment on the herm vote round 2? Was he defensive for him since he would know he was town

Mittens @ 29/10/2018 12:57

Thisisbad @ 29/10/2018 12:56 Mittens couldn't become mafia, learn who they are, then be town the next night And no way does he visit merc. I don't have any clue if I learn who they are. Did you read the two possibilities I posted?

So you've never asked the mods what happens?

Mittens @ 29/10/2018 13:34

Before this gets too late into the day, I'll just claim. I am the Nomad I began the game unaligned, and end up taking on the alignment of the person I visit each night. I have been town aligned ever since N1, even though I've tried to become something more interesting a few times. Rose, Merc, Mike, and Herm are the people I have visited which are still alive - so they can be trusted (assuming there aren't any alignment shifts/recruitments)

i hate this claim because it literally makes no sense and its just being a cop but vaguely risky but if i scream bullshit too loudly the dr3rdparty cries just get louder

but srsly this literally doesnt make sense

Shadow @ 29/10/2018 12:58

Did mittens comment on the herm vote round 2? Was he defensive for him since he would know he was town

I didn't mean to dislike i was trying to quote.

Mittens was gone when herm got lynched.

Thisisbad @ 29/10/2018 12:59

Mittens @ 29/10/2018 12:57 Thisisbad @ 29/10/2018 12:56 Mittens couldn't become mafia, learn who they are, then be town the next night And no way does he visit merc. I don't have any clue if I learn who they are. Did you read the two possibilities I posted? So you've never asked the mods what happens?

Of course I did. I didn't get an answer

ZacharyB @ 29/10/2018 12:54

Mike, is there a reason why you think we have a powerful 3P? Maybe you’ve said already and I missed it. I honestly thought you had a census which is why you seemed so insistent. Idk if that’s the case now but just wanna check.

The number of players made me think there had to be more than just Mafia/SK/Survivor in play, otherwise this game would be heavily biased towards town.

The only solutions to this were a buffed up mafia, or yet another third party, as dangerous as SK.

I thought Rose fit the bill, but that's suddenly seeming less likely. But it still leaves the problem that the town has an unjustifiable amount of firepower.

Which leaves me swinging back to thinking there is a cult. Seems amazing that we wouldn't have seen evidence of one yet though.

If mittens gets lynched he potentially clears a few people

Basically you are a cop who hasn't shared any leads?