Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 21/2/2013 17:03

Dylan @ 21/2/2013 16:51 I still think LSF serves no purpose in the game. If he's town he is of no use to us. If he's mafia that is one round earlier that the game ends because of mafia numbers. See, the useless if he's town argument is incredibly :| and the same reason I went on a war path against Curtis yesterday. Even the most useless townie is a numbers bolster on our side. We can probably afford the loss a bit more now that there are 3 scum down, but I'm not willing to lynch someone solely on the reason of being useless. The fact that Rob vouched for Alex as town but specified that the message was weird and unusual to open the floor for "oops, that scan must have been a scum trick!" if Alex turned up dead and scum is a mark against him though.

Oh I didn't remember that Rob vouched for Alex. Yea I don't think Rob would want to lose his credibility. Alright I'll go check that out. If that is the case than there is a good chance he is probably town.

I will...... On Day 5

Scum Killer @ 21/2/2013 17:06

I will...... On Day 5

Do in on Day 4

##unlynch LSF

The fact that Rob vouched for him as town probably means he is town. Unless he was protecting a scummy buddy knowing that he'd never be lynched (because we trusted him) and the mafia would never kill him because he's one of them.

But on that case I think if he had done that the mafia would know that Rob was lying and probably wouldn't of killed him last round.

I am back.

Yeah, the Rob/cop thing adds a lot of confusion into the mix. I can't figure out if it was a ploy to inform the scum of what he was doing (by claiming a pro-town result on a scum member) or if he was just confirming the most useless townie here. I think the main purpose was to oust who else was visited by Korr and possibly get them to oust Korr without getting the blame himself, but it's still something I keep wondering about.

I dont want to think Curtis is town.

Tom Brady @ 21/2/2013 17:11

I am back.

Wonderful!

Curtis @ 21/2/2013 18:44

It's weird to lynch the potential town BP or Doctor over Rito because Rito MAY have had a better role (based on nothing) than possible BP or Doctor. Especially since you say yourself that IF he happened to have a great role, he likely wasn't putting it to much good anyway I dunno, I don't really buy it. If Jeff was anything but the Don, which the mafia knows obviously, then the mafia would 100% want him dead yesterday when he was a target. If they thought he was the SK, or lied about his one time BP and was full BP or Doctor, they would want him gone so bad. They wouldn't want to hit him at night and risk wasting another attack on Jeff, assuming it was the mafia that attacked him the first time Not quite buying it Tommy boy!

Curtis day 3

##Lynch Jeff After looking through his posts I've made up my mind He did nothing but say hi on day one. Why would mafia attack him after that? I understand if the mafia is KIND and wants to take out someone not adding too much, or strategic and wants someone that wouldn't be a likely person for the doctor to protect, but Jeff just seems too random of a target to me. I just don't see them wasting a kill on him Then he decides to prematurely roleclaim in his third post in the game. The odds are greater that he's mafia/SK/cult over a townie. The chances that the mafia got so unlucky by hitting the quiet one time BP are so low I think he's the safest lynch today

about an hour left if anyone is interested

I have this crazy theory in my head that Rob and Curtis made this plan.

Rob throws Greenday under the bus
Curtis throws Grim under the bus

They both gain the towns trust

But im thinking last nights kill was bussed to Rob somehow and thus killing Grim and Rob (Maybe part of the plan was hoping Grim would be spotted by a tracker / watcher / cop / random lynch?)

Crazy crazy crazy

Ari @ 21/2/2013 17:17

I have this crazy theory in my head that Rob and Curtis made this plan. Rob throws Greenday under the bus Curtis throws Grim under the bus They both gain the towns trust But im thinking last nights kill was bussed to Rob somehow and thus killing Grim and Rob (Maybe part of the plan was hoping Grim would be spotted by a tracker / watcher / cop / random lynch?) Crazy crazy crazy

Ari the mafia didn't know what Rob was

It seems you forgot that you thought the same of Jeff as me Curtis. We were both wrong, yet you think it makes me scum.

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 21/2/2013 22:18

Ari @ 21/2/2013 17:17 I have this crazy theory in my head that Rob and Curtis made this plan. Rob throws Greenday under the bus Curtis throws Grim under the bus They both gain the towns trust But im thinking last nights kill was bussed to Rob somehow and thus killing Grim and Rob (Maybe part of the plan was hoping Grim would be spotted by a tracker / watcher / cop / random lynch?) Crazy crazy crazy Ari the mafia didn't know what Rob was

Crazy theory dismissed!

Ari @ 21/2/2013 17:17

I have this crazy theory in my head that Rob and Curtis made this plan. Rob throws Greenday under the bus Curtis throws Grim under the bus They both gain the towns trust But im thinking last nights kill was bussed to Rob somehow and thus killing Grim and Rob (Maybe part of the plan was hoping Grim would be spotted by a tracker / watcher / cop / random lynch?) Crazy crazy crazy

So Rob and Curtis conspired to massacre all their scum buddies? Ok.