Two Seb @ 9/7/2018 11:56

Mercator @ 9/7/2018 11:52 How do you account for there being the same amount of kills the last two nights when I blocked Christian one of the nights? SK's aren't unblockable. Says who? In vlady's 80s Music Mafia, the SK was unblockable.

:vlady:

If you look at every other game though, especially OG crowd

Mercator @ 9/7/2018 12:00

Two Seb @ 9/7/2018 11:56 Mercator @ 9/7/2018 11:52 How do you account for there being the same amount of kills the last two nights when I blocked Christian one of the nights? SK's aren't unblockable. Says who? In vlady's 80s Music Mafia, the SK was unblockable. :vlady: If you look at every other game though, especially OG crowd

I mean that's a host call and not a point of discussion that has much merit in my eyes.

JJ @ 9/7/2018 11:58

Did Vlady say what his item was?

Vlady @ Post #1: 5th Jul 2018 1:06 PM

Ha- I knew scum would take a shot at me, which is why I saved myself last night. I don't know if that means scum is afraid because I was going after curtis or if they were trying to railroad curtis last night. BTW- I'm the town doctor and I softclaimed it D1. My item is chocolate pudding that saved people. I have used it the following: N1: Me N2: Buffy N3: Buffy (blocked) N4: Me I'll post link to my softclaim in a sec.

Christian hasn't fully claimed his item/role yet unless I'm mistaken. Just said that it's religious because his name is Christian.

I heavily lean Vlady as SK over Christian

Oh yeah chocolate pudding. idk how that auto translates into saving people except he's saying he specified that.

I could see Boc giving someone who specifics asks to save people a mafia doc role or sk who can "save themselves."

Badger is almost certainly mafia and should have one partner left over two. The nice thing about potentially hitting Badger’s partner is it’d be the same as lynching the SK, the kill will still be reduced since Badger won’t submit it

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 12:14

Badger is almost certainly mafia and should have one partner left over two. The nice thing about potentially hitting Badger’s partner is it’d be the same as lynching the SK, the kill will still be reduced since Badger won’t submit it

Not the worst idea.

Two Seb @ 9/7/2018 15:20

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 12:14 Badger is almost certainly mafia and should have one partner left over two. The nice thing about potentially hitting Badger’s partner is it’d be the same as lynching the SK, the kill will still be reduced since Badger won’t submit it Not the worst idea.

The problem is I feel much better about Vlady being SK than I do about which of you is Badger’s partner (probably)

I wish Badger died many many nights ago

Yeah whoever's killing "for town" needs to make a good choice.

I feel best about Josh or Nav being Badger's partner. Probably Josh.

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 12:26

Two Seb @ 9/7/2018 15:20 Curtis @ 9/7/2018 12:14 Badger is almost certainly mafia and should have one partner left over two. The nice thing about potentially hitting Badger’s partner is it’d be the same as lynching the SK, the kill will still be reduced since Badger won’t submit it Not the worst idea. The problem is I feel much better about Vlady being SK than I do about which of you is Badger’s partner (probably)

I feel better about the SK being one of vlady/Christian with a 60-40 lean on vlady over Christian.

Hey Christian, if you ARE the SK, please don't fucking kill me this time.

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 12:35

I also really don’t like Vlady’s constant “I’ll hold this over you for many games to come!” scare tactic that he keeps using against different people. It doesn’t feel authentic at all

When people accuse me of being SK, then I'm pretty damn clever to have put in a doctor softclaim D1, knowing full well that said doctor would be able to CC me and have me killed. Either that or you have to believe that there isn't a doctor in the game *and* I knew on D1 there wouldn't be a doctor in the game.

Alternatively, there is Ahoda's mafia doctor accusation, which is funny given I pushed getting the godmother/father/whatever when Wikey was the clear contender for lynch. I also have called out a number of mafia players. If I'm mafia doc, I'm a terrible teammate.

Alternatively, I could just think that townies pushing so hard on the town doctor are ignoring evidence and acting like a bunch of idiots, prompting me to exclaim in frustration. Because this isn't the first game with me as town it's been like this. Or the second. Or the third. So maybe you might see the reason I bring it up. I mean sure- I could just smile knowing I got lynched after claiming vig a few games back while the town kept the SK around for days afterwards. Or when nobody believed my Carlos claim in PBS mafia. And so on. And so on.

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 12:35

I also really don’t like Vlady’s constant “I’ll hold this over you for many games to come!” scare tactic that he keeps using against different people. It doesn’t feel authentic at all

JJ @ 9/7/2018 13:00

Mercator @ 9/7/2018 13:54 I asked Boc and he said that I could block the same person again, which makes me think that Vlady is telling the truth about his role. Why would he gamble on saying he protected JJ twice in a row if he wouldn't know for sure? Because maybe he's mafia doc and he was told this? idk Also, it's bring your own item game so I could see some interesting rules. He may also have pinned himself down to something and was forced to say he could protect back to back. Either way, I think it's the weakest evidence. If you, me, Curtis, Ahoda, Christian are all town... that leaves: Nav, Josh, Vlady, Badger If Vlady is doc that means Nav or Josh are SK unless Badger is inactive sub submitting actions and I don't think so.

I wasn't pinned down to nothing- I volunteered the info because I knew people seeing my survival would immediately push for me to be scum. And I was right. And then people said me claiming info was scummy. At this point, I can't win on either argument.