Darren Sanders @ 9/4/2017 0:09

spindoctor02 @ 8/4/2017 21:50 Maddie @ 9/4/2017 0:49 Damn Spin that was sassy af. They took my idea and credited Vlady with it. Its more than deserved. Primate @ 8/4/2017 22:02 Darren Sanders @ 8/4/2017 23:57 Primate @ 8/4/2017 21:52 Darren Sanders @ 8/4/2017 23:50 Primate @ 8/4/2017 21:38 Darren Sanders @ 8/4/2017 23:37 Primate @ 8/4/2017 21:37 Angi @ 8/4/2017 23:33 Primate @ 9/4/2017 0:27 Hellos Ds Spin Angi All look a little suspect to me. Why? You pop in and throw out a vote, ds and hellos start puppet mastering theories. Cherry kind of helped that along, and spin comes in to build on your vote. Spin wouldn't get a second look, but he tossed in that disclaimer which looks a little bad to me. Come again? How tf did I start any theory? Don't play this silly game ds. You know what you posted, so does everyone else. "IF CURTIS IS SILENCED" I wasnt the person who brought up Curtis being silenced. I did not START anything. So you are arguing something I didn't say instead of addressing the actual issue? Strange tactic. You said that "ds and helios start puppet mastering theories" - you are saying that I started a theory. I did not. I was not the first person to say that Curtis might be silenced. You were the person who said you tracked him. I said IF (theory brought up by someone else) is correct, then (person who was tracked by you) might be the person who silenced (person in theory brought up by someone else) No. I was saying that you started throwing out theories. As in you weren't doing it, and then you were doing it. But, please, let's keep playing the semantics game instead of addressing your actual behavior. Even if I did mean started in the way you are trying to twist it, you were the first to arttempt to sell Christian as anti town.(which I guess he still could be.) Oh really? Wasnt spin the person to cast a vote on him? Spin, Primate is trying to give me credit for something you did. This is a recurring theme today.

Arguing more stuff I never said. Are you drunk?

Maddie @ 9/4/2017 0:20

thisisbad @ 8/4/2017 23:18 Maddie @ 9/4/2017 0:14 HI I'm back. ALRIGHT SO--I tracked Herm last night, but my investigative reports were burned to a crisp and I didn't get any info on Herm's activity. I don't want to jump right on Herm and assume scum for the following reasons: 1.) Could be a passive protective town role? 2.) I'm assuming based on my PM that this has something to do with Herm's role, but not 100% clear if this is the case. That said, it seems a little scummy so I'd definitely like to hear from Herm about this. Could just be a roleblock That was my initial thought, but Sock was mafia roleblocker, so unless there's an apprentice role this wouldn't make a whole lot of sense.

Cult rb er?

Could be herm'so role that burned the report. Maybe a role or action who can't be scanned or tracked? Like a modifier to typical ninja or skin things.

I'm still OK with a helios or ds vote. I also don't like the disclaimer spin felt he had to make when he voted christian.

Darren Sanders @ 9/4/2017 1:33

Btw now you know nofo isnt a killer

We knew it yesterday when he said he visited Zersch N1

Zersch @ 9/4/2017 4:55

Hmm, yeah, why was a back-up lynch such a horrible idea? There were what, 19 votes on Sock? There was zero harm in the idea of having a back up lynch with those numbers. And it would have taken a total of 2 people to have solidified a back-up lynch candidate yesterday as everyone on the tally except for Sock only had 1 vote. And Helios' argument for preserving the lynch as it was before the "back-up lynch" idea was brought up is pointless. Sock was caught. Almost everyone voted for him. I'm sure his whole team is on there. If anything trying to sell the idea of a back-up lynch and seeing who might nibble at the idea would potentially be more helpful to vote analysis than the landslide we had.

If anything, I would read anyone that actually jumped off the Sock lynch at that point as more likely town. Mafia knew he was mafia and would absolutely want to be on the lynch for lynch count analysis reasons later.

I am not sure what to make of Maudie's info. I am leaning that it is likely due to Herm's role though, because I don't really see a town role targeting Maddie for that sort of thing, and the mafia already flipped a rb'er. Having a rb'er and that sort of obfuscation role seems redundant, or perhaps OP.

Here being ninja or something where Maddie would "lose him" or lose whatever info she did find, would make sense.

I could see Chris killing Buffy. But Tbf. ......scum kills her early almost every game........it's really hard to judge based on that alone

I'm about to go play golf. Then I've got to build a bicycle I bought my wife for her birthday. Then watch the masters. Then dinner for the wife's birthday. So, I won't be around a ton today.

People I feel pretty good about right now: maddie, nofo, Vic, primate, cherry, Zersch. And DS since the player list does list mittens as town.

People I feel not so good about: herm, farlig, merc, Vlady. A lot of this is just gut feeling.

People I haven't seen enough of to lean one way or another: im317, Aries, TIB

Primate @ 9/4/2017 0:32

Hellos and ds look the worst out of that bunch to me. Selling theories without voting.

I'm not one of you people who just throws votes around just for bullshit reasons (see also: vibes).

Me discussing my thoughts on what Angi said about Christian was simply that: me discussing thoughts. I wasn't a fan of the back-up plan discussion since I always believe in focusing exclusively on caught scum. HOWEVER, that's an opinion, not law. Just that alone is not a reason for me to cast a vote.

I also definitely see Buffy as the mafia kill. She is a good player so a threat to them. She was under the radar a bit, so not likely to be watched or protected. Good time for them to strike.

Timmah @ 9/4/2017 8:06

I'm about to go play golf. Then I've got to build a bicycle I bought my wife for her birthday. Then watch the masters. Then dinner for the wife's birthday. So, I won't be around a ton today. People I feel pretty good about right now: maddie, nofo, Vic, primate, cherry, Zersch. And DS since the player list does list mittens as town. People I feel not so good about: herm, farlig, merc, Vlady. A lot of this is just gut feeling. People I haven't seen enough of to lean one way or another: im317, Aries, TIB

On second thought I dunno about DS. I believe his claim. But, he may steal the role and not the alignment. Can definitely see that being a scum role - maybe third party or something. So he's in my "not listed" category for now.

Morning coffee underway.

DS forcing out more information for no reason.
Primate having real thoughts this game.
Christian has a visiting role, he must be scum, really?
Maddie being corrupted after busting scum makes a lot of sense and an active role having to do that would be risky except the town watcher is dead.
I thought it was pretty apparent angi was silenced. Why else couldn't she like posts?

I'd ask for votals, since the day is about half over, but I think there is only one or two votes total at this point. Looks like it's going to be a lynch fest near the end.

I see my name mentioned, busy right now but will be more available soon.