Curtis @ 9/8/2023 23:43

And yeah I was gonna say there are two piano player/singers and I’m sure the second one is a character/role in this game, he was important enough. I don’t think we can necessarily assume TT was the singer, there should be two of them

The singer who visited Steph I mean

Yeah seems like the guy could be a scumsided version, but idk.

Did we get reports of both yesterday?

I think Steph was saying she thinks TT's passive might have been used on her because it's separate from the piano playing role.

But it could be that second character you all are talking about too

Josh @ 9/8/2023 19:46

I think Steph was saying she thinks TT's passive might have been used on her because it's separate from the piano playing role. But it could be that second character you all are talking about too

i just dont see why it makes sense to tell the player whose role is supposed to be randomly revealed to the Assassins that its happening to them

i agree with that, does seem a little pointless cause then the person would just claim right away anyways

Stéph @ 9/8/2023 23:20

TheNavneet @ 9/8/2023 21:26 anyways, no survivals announced and jamie claims the TT kill maybe TT blocked the Mafia kill? or they doubled up on TT? I think TT tried to block me? I got notified about hearing music. Dunno what that means.

it would make some sense for town to block you as a precaution thought i might just let the deaths per night do the work instead. im not sure it makes sense for scum to block you thought. even if they think you can still kill they kind of need a non mafia threat for town to have to deal with. it gets complicated if we think there are 2 mafia teams since that would probably make the odds of us having a serial killer much lower.

random thought. person who allegedly cured Steph, if that was the only thing your role does can you please claim. the benefit of knowing Steph is telling the truth outweighs giving mafia info on if Steph is not a threat, especially as it also gives us another more or less confirmed town member

There's no way someone randomly discharging vanilla cum blindly on N1 is town, buddy

BadgerMcBeaver @ 9/8/2023 23:31

Regarding Tib/Rod, even though I have been feeling like this is town Tib, his role kind of seems more geared towards the mafia. I feel like No Lynch days in general tend to be more beneficial to scum than town. In the very late game, that's a very powerful scum role because it can buy you the precious time you need to get majority. I don't think it really does that much to benefit town though - town tends to rely upon lynches to get rid of scum because the vig can only do so much. Canceling a lynch is kind of counter productive towards what town is trying to do as a whole. Also, I think there's a lot more reason for reason for Rodney to come forward with his role if he's town than if he's scum. If he was scum, he could just say nothing for the moment and avoid getting heat for having a similar role to Tib. Also, a double vote in the late game is somewhat powerful for scum and he'd be kind of wasting it by using it so early. As town though, I don't think there's the same benefit to saving it for later because it's so easy to die at night, so I feel like he'd be more likely to use it before he gets killed during a night phase.

In addition to this, Tib's logic about how mafia would have used the no-lynch to save Lamps day 1 doesn't really feel very well reasoned to me. Sure, they'd buy themselves a day by using it that way, but they also kind of 2 for 1 themselves when Lamps does end up flipping. I think most mafias would recognize that its in their best interest to let their inactive member fall by the way side rather than risk trying to save them and potentially outing themselves. This argument kind of felt like him grasping at straws and doesn't really make sense to me.

I'm willing to be open to other ideas, but for now...

##lynch Tib

I could see Steph picking

Rodney @ 9/8/2023 23:58

There's no way someone randomly discharging vanilla cum blindly on N1 is town, buddy

EXCUSE me?!

Gross.

gabagool @ 10/8/2023 0:03

I could see Steph picking Rodney @ 9/8/2023 23:58 There's no way someone randomly discharging vanilla cum blindly on N1 is town, buddy EXCUSE me?!

Ok oops the beginning of this was text I forgot to delete from an earlier post. Nvm.

I'm getting tased for that post

Can we all agree to never use the word "discharging" and "cum" in a post ever again?

You just did it