Jack @ 20/4/2017 21:22

WHY are you disliking that? Because I said I didn't see that Lamps was scummy?

No cause I knew you'd get mad and post about me disliking. As always :yay:

FUCK THE HATERS CHERRY

I cleared Townies by scanning them and you cleared them as Townies by killing them. It was the perfect strategy

No hate, just my God-given right to voice my opinion in a game I died way too soon in! :P

Jack @ 20/4/2017 20:09

Lamps @ 20/4/2017 17:58 Vic @ 20/4/2017 22:22 God what a frustrating game this was I believed you :\ So did I. I believed Vic and you were both town. And Merc. And Angi (not that she got vig-killed). Also, Curtis trying to get people to stop Lamps from using his powers... lol. Mafia why would you kill me N2 when you had at least 2 claimed PRs that day? I'm glad you wasted your kill on the only town vanilla. :P Anyway, thanks for the game Badger & Brian!

we had the destroy info ability to use on Maddie, plus we figured she would be protected, oddly it was you and Herm that visited her. we also thought we could silence her the next night until we were told otherwise, at which point we just killed her.

we basically just let Chris kill you. we should have gone with Jamie's idea to kill Primate

Don't worry guys, like half the players didn't believe me either.

Yeah I figured Maddie would be protected but Primate had soft-claimed. Anyway, that answers it. Chris. I figured.

Curtis @ 20/4/2017 21:25

FUCK THE HATERS CHERRY I cleared Townies by scanning them and you cleared them as Townies by killing them. It was the perfect strategy

I just...like...ugh. I killed people that there was discussion around lynching anyway. The shoe wasn't ever on the other foot because we were so good at lynching Scum, but had I not Vig-killed some of them and we mislynched them the next day instead, I can promise I would not have been antagonizing someone just for being on the wrong side of the vote if they had a decent reason for lynching. That's all my kills were based on - our hunches.

And no offense to Vic because he didn't design his role, but we'd mass-claimed a few days in with a lot of people broadcasting all of their actions, so forgive me for being willing to sacrifice an investigative role that tells us things we already knew. :-/

Cherry I thought you were a good player in that you were questioning and analyzing everything. And you did bring a different perspective to things. Town really was great at lynching scummies!

Cherry was great and anyone who says otherwise can take a flyin' leap!!!

Cherry made primate proud/jealous.

I haven't been playing mafia long, but Cherry was one of the most eloquent mafia players I've seen.

Nofo is my favorite doctor ever for protecting me N1.

And for that I will always be thankful and fiercely loyal.

im317 @ 20/4/2017 15:54

Nofo @ 20/4/2017 15:30 how the fuck did i never die after retracting a doctor claim on day 2 you really shouldn't have given a running list of who you protected. as long as we knew who you couldn't protect it gave us free kills. that plus other roles being more of an issue. Nofo @ 20/4/2017 15:32 Bravo to Timmah for somehow being able to survive a survival while refusing to claim and an outed BP and literally giving droplets of information, none of which fit together. no bravo to Timmah, he was beyond terrible this game. as a SKer you have to be the last player standing. to stop killing for such a long time arguably goes against playing to win the game. delaying the inevitable doesn't help you win when there are more confirmed town alive then the mafia can kill alone. it just means eventually you will be policy lynched for having survived a kill.

Respectfully, I have to disagree with you.

Winning as a SK is very hard to start with. Killing every night, and thus pretty much making sure that everyone knows there is a SK, just makes it that much harder. Eventually everyone is going to claim anyway, and it's hard to fake a claim as scum, especially when you have to fake it all the way to last player standing like a SK does. Odds are i would be policy lynched as SK either way because there will be more confirmed roles out there anyway. Unless mafia is winning, in which case mafia has more numbers to get me lynched anyway. It did not go against my win condition in the slightest, and I even discussed it with the hosts before we started.

With my role - BP and scan town - I wanted to see if I could hold off on killing and slide deep into the game. Even better if the cop scans me, and best of all if mafia gf has also flipped. Once I was your N1 target and survived, convincing town that I was BP town and that there was no SK was pretty much my only play.

The goal of my game was to win for me, not to kill so that I can help the mafia win. I Honestly think you're jaded because my lack of killing did you guys no favors. After I made it through the first few days, I actually thought I may have an outside shot, but ultimately curtis' flip did me in I think.

I think that last line was it. Curtis flip really got you. Until that point we thought there was no sk



Funny how n1 killed cult and put the sk on notice. This game could have been totally different

Otherwise, good game town!

Thanks for hosting Brian and badger. I had a great time, and really enjoyed the game.