Badger'n'Brian @ 8/4/2017 22:35

Player list has been updated. Gonna follow the request that Vladdy made prior to the game and keep the role flips in that list as well.

Well at least I did something good this game!

Primate @ 8/4/2017 22:55

Helios Garabandia @ 8/4/2017 21:43 Angi @ 8/4/2017 22:38 Christian......you seemed most susaf to me reading yesterday. You seemed to detract from the Sock train. And now we see you visited Curtis. So for now ##lynch Christian I....am surprisingly okay with this line of thought. IIRC, Christian was one of the proponents of the "let's get a back-up plan" school of thought, which seemed incredibly suspicious to me. In a situation when caught scum is caught, I see no reason to waste time, energy, or votes on other people except to confuse vote analysis later on in the game when vote analysis is most important (because let's be honest, when vote analysis happens, the final votals are used, and the reasons for the switches are not really discussed). It's my intent to go back through and see who all was advocating for the back-up plan option, because I'm not a fan of that move. It's just looked like selfish play due to fear of a bomb to me.

I would agree with this, except at the time I think I was the final voter and, IIRC, Zersch voted after me at that point (haven't had coffee yet, but I think Christian was already on vote train).

Duh- just went and looked- there was no reason for Christian to fear bomb since he was early on the train already.

spindoctor02 @ 8/4/2017 22:57

Badger'n'Brian @ 8/4/2017 22:35 Player list has been updated. Gonna follow the request that Vladdy made prior to the game and keep the role flips in that list as well. I'm hurt, really hurt.

Oh I read this wrong. I mentioned this game about the player list not being updated, which is probably what bribadgebuldabearbridge is thinking.

Primate @ 9/4/2017 0:32

Hellos and ds look the worst out of that bunch to me. Selling theories without voting.

Much as I think DS looks scummy all the time, a lot of my strategy in games can be construed the same way, so I can't fault Helios and DS for throwing out possible theories without pushing them with a vote.

inb4dsandheliosflipscum

Angi @ 9/4/2017 0:35

Primate @ 9/4/2017 0:32 Hellos and ds look the worst out of that bunch to me. Selling theories without voting. DS is totally susaf BUT I believe his claim ugh

I'm still not sure I believe his claimed alignment, even if his claim is true.

Primate @ 9/4/2017 1:02

Darren Sanders @ 8/4/2017 23:57 Primate @ 8/4/2017 21:52 Darren Sanders @ 8/4/2017 23:50 Primate @ 8/4/2017 21:38 Darren Sanders @ 8/4/2017 23:37 Primate @ 8/4/2017 21:37 Angi @ 8/4/2017 23:33 Primate @ 9/4/2017 0:27 Hellos Ds Spin Angi All look a little suspect to me. Why? You pop in and throw out a vote, ds and hellos start puppet mastering theories. Cherry kind of helped that along, and spin comes in to build on your vote. Spin wouldn't get a second look, but he tossed in that disclaimer which looks a little bad to me. Come again? How tf did I start any theory? Don't play this silly game ds. You know what you posted, so does everyone else. "IF CURTIS IS SILENCED" I wasnt the person who brought up Curtis being silenced. I did not START anything. So you are arguing something I didn't say instead of addressing the actual issue? Strange tactic. You said that "ds and helios start puppet mastering theories" - you are saying that I started a theory. I did not. I was not the first person to say that Curtis might be silenced. You were the person who said you tracked him. I said IF (theory brought up by someone else) is correct, then (person who was tracked by you) might be the person who silenced (person in theory brought up by someone else) No. I was saying that you started throwing out theories. As in you weren't doing it, and then you were doing it. But, please, let's keep playing the semantics game instead of addressing your actual behavior. Even if I did mean started in the way you are trying to twist it, you were the first to arttempt to sell Christian as anti town.(which I guess he still could be.)

Isn't this what DS does all the time- try to play semantics? Lord knows this is the second game I've battled with him on it.

chris did u kill buffy this seems like a thing u would do to my mother

So Miko was the music we heard day 1 also, I guess that answers a bit of the mystery as to how the unlockable roles work. Still curious as to whos role gets unlocked by mikos song vs another role/doing. Not sure how we would figure that out since even miko didn't know his music unlocked roles.

Was about to quote "there's a lot fo people who haven't talked today, so it would be harder to find who is silenced", but then I checked and most the people I thought hadn't posted have posted once. I think only person who hasn't is chris.

Christian u scum? r u backup cult recruiter?

Maddie @ 9/4/2017 2:27

I'm very curious as to what anyone might have to make of the information I just provided.

With the disclaimer that I'm not well-versed in roles, I lean toward this being a passive ability that Herm has. The fact that you received a report from your visit before it burned (as opposed to being told you have no report) makes it feel inconsistent with a role blocker targeting you. Could it be a role blocker of sorts targeting Herm? I suppose so, but then it becomes a discussion of what reasons you and the hypothetical role blocker had for targeting Herm last night.

jamie ♂ @ 9/4/2017 6:19

Christian u scum? r u backup cult recruiter?

Remember Christian, you can't lie to Sunbaby God, or you go to hell.

Any thoughts on what happened, Herm?

Hi Herm hi chris

Burning a report could be a scum action from what weve seen so far. That or whoever floated the maddie as possible cult idea yesterday could be onto something. I mean is there really a rexport to burn for a tracker?

Do you have minions , maddie?