That's right. I couldn't kill last night.

A Vlady flip probably tells us the most, I'd lynch him but I'm not sure what the vote count is at all. If he flips killer priest, then Brian looks good. If he flips as Bulletproof SK, then Brian is pretty much outed scum and we get a two-for-one lynching special.

Vlady's claim looks pretty bad, (sorry Vlady ily and think you're great), if only because we have an odd-numbered night killer and a cop in the game already, so a killer priest seems kind of redundant.

Bryce (Tatiana Rose Petal) @ 2/5/2016 11:46

Herm @ 2/5/2016 11:39 Well, might as well come out with it since it's bound to get confusing, even for town. I only kill every other night. I think I might have missed the part where you claimed a killing role. Why did you claim Herm, and who have you killed? You couldn't kill this last night, right?

We literally talking about that for multiple pages. Have you even read anything today??

Curtis @ 2/5/2016 19:48

Bryce (Tatiana Rose Petal) @ 2/5/2016 13:43 Curtis @ 2/5/2016 11:41 Brian flipping would be incredibly telling with Vlady. If Brian is Town Doc, Vlad looks way better. If Brian is Mafia Doctor, Vlady looks very guilty. If Brian is some other Mafia, Vlady looks good because Brian was likely sent to kill him Ugh Curtis, you advocating slightly for a Brian flip makes me nervous, since I think you're scum and now I'm worried I outed a town doctor :( Luckily you are VERY wrong! I expect Brian to claim Doctor one way or the other tbh. Unless he claims some Town role that happened to visit Vlady and do something other than attack/protect him but that'd harder to buy

Not necessary.

Curtis @ 2/5/2016 14:36

I could use a spreadsheet right about now

When I get out of class I'm gonna make one. OLD TIMES SAKE

Not necessarily!

Eben Etzebeth @ 2/5/2016 11:48

So what happens if Brian claims Doctor and we wait all day until someone counter claims him? lol, this is just craziness with all these claims

It'd be stupid for somebody to counter-claim doctor, nobody else needs to claim. I debated holding my information back until tomorrow to avoid any more mass confusion, but I figured if I died tonight I would hate myself 5ever. Vlady's flip would tell us everything we would need to know about Brian, or vice-versa.

Bryce (Tatiana Rose Petal) @ 2/5/2016 13:51

Eben Etzebeth @ 2/5/2016 11:48 So what happens if Brian claims Doctor and we wait all day until someone counter claims him? lol, this is just craziness with all these claims It'd be stupid for somebody to counter-claim doctor, nobody else needs to claim. I debated holding my information back until tomorrow to avoid any more mass confusion, but I figured if I died tonight I would hate myself 5ever. Vlady's flip would tell us everything we would need to know about Brian, or vice-versa.

What if Vlady flips Town? What does that tell us about Brian? He still either protected or attacked him (or something else)

So then no need to wait, right? I guess we can wait for Brian to see what he claims so we can decide which role is more dispensable.

I'm still leaning toward Vlady being bad since we have a cop confirmed and vig claimed (as has been pointed out multiple times). But if it is in fact his role, it is quite useful..

I was not RBed last night, yet I didn't kill. I can't make things much clearer than that to defend myself.

I expect to be dead tonight either way.

One point against Vlady (and Brian too tbh). After seeing Vlady survive on the mod error, why would a town Doctor decide to protect Vlady the next night? They would think Vlady was probably supposed to survive on that night on his own, so why protect that person? I don't get it

I could see Vlady being SK and Mafia sending Brian (who had done nothing and is good to send) to go kill him. Especially after they saw the mod error, maybe they thought Vlady was doc who protected himself that night

So let me get this straight, (and yeah a spreadsheet would be amazing tbh)

NIGHT 1:

JC was mafia kill

Lamps was attempted kill by Vlady (or so he says)

NIGHT 2:

Merc was mafia kill

Free Candy was killed by Herm

NIGHT 3:

Vlady was attempted mafia kill.

Timmah was attempted Vlady kill but it failed because Timmah is town-aligned (or so Vlady says)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Night 2: Both me and Vlady were roleblocked

Night 3: Buffy was roleblocked by Angi

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Takeaways: Was anybody else RB'd on Night 3? It's really weird to go from two roleblock's on night 2, to none on night 3 other than Angi's one-time use.

The kill sheet lines up. A mafia kill every night, the opportunity for a Vlady kill every night, (either as an SK or priest-killer thing), and a Herm on even-numbered nights. What looks good for Vlady is that he says he was roleblocked on night 2 and we're missing a kill there, although I find it odd how there were two roleblocks on night 2 but then neither of them showed up again on night 1 or 3, which is why if people were roleblocked they should come forward. The good thing is that this clears Buffy using a killing role last night, we had a mafia kill against Vlady and if Herm couldn't kill and if Vlady really IS killer-priest and failed, we aren't missing a kill. (Doesn't clear her of being scum though ofc, but I'm less worried about missing a kill)

I'm leaning in the middle when it comes to believing Vlady, but there's too many loose ends when it comes to this whole mess. I also asked Christian a clarifying question about my role which will shine more information on what information I was given about Brian.

Redster @ 2/5/2016 11:49

Bryce (Tatiana Rose Petal) @ 2/5/2016 11:46 Herm @ 2/5/2016 11:39 Well, might as well come out with it since it's bound to get confusing, even for town. I only kill every other night. I think I might have missed the part where you claimed a killing role. Why did you claim Herm, and who have you killed? You couldn't kill this last night, right? We literally talking about that for multiple pages. Have you even read anything today??

UM I'M SORRY I woke up to twelve pages to read, information that Brian visited Vlady, info that Vlady survived another attack, info that Vlady claimed being RB'd on the same night that I was, info that Angi RB'd Buffy this previous night, and my adderall had not yet kicked in. So I'm SORRY I skimmed info that Herm was an even-night killer.

Stop oppressing me with your white cis male privilege.

It didn't fail because Timmah is town aligned, it failed because Vlady was roleblocked. I think

I'm so mad I can't edit

On that little breakdown, on night 2, add that Vlady was supposedly roleblocked.