^^looks staged in retrospect

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 15:06

^^looks staged in retrospect

It really does. But I can't help but find it cute that 317 claimed to be operating under the assumption that he and Josh "had a thing".

Talk about OTP material.

I'd be suprised if two players had that same role here, if that's what's going on here?

Herm @ 25/11/2018 14:09

I'd be suprised if two players had that same role here, if that's what's going on here?

Or why Brian says he's hard to kill and hard to be lynched. I think those are his words, not that he can't be. I already had an idea of what Curtis was saying but what Brian is saying seems way OP.

Brian, if you're that invincible and you're refusing to help town, that's rude. :P

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 10:01

Does anyone have thoughts on why 317 completely avoided Nav's train until eod when he really had nowhere else to go? Or the exchange with Josh? I'm starting to get more sus of Nav tbh. Not because he won't use his role - I don't want him to use it, actually. I pretty much disagree with every suspect he has. Also, if Nav is scum Christian isn't imo - same with Curtis. I still think Timmah could be scum. I'd like to lynch Brian for every single one of his posts but there may be bigger fish to fry. Nav, what are your thoughts about Jamie now? Who else was all over Jamie's case?

My thoughts on jamie haven't changed a whole lot. His role sounds very out of place to me. He looks better because of im317 going hard against him but that was during the time when I was the leading vote getter.

Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 14:14

My thoughts on jamie haven't changed a whole lot. His role sounds very out of place to me. He looks better because of im317 going hard against him but that was during the time when I was the leading vote getter.

Why is his role "out of place?" I can't even understand this reasoning. It's like you're speaking a foreign language. Of all the roles to be suspicious about... is it just that you've never seen it before?

Re: using my role.

When I said I would use it D1 it was when Rose was getting lynched and I was operating under the assumption that she would flip town. If she had I'd have good targets to pick from. I'm not going to use my role for the sake of using it. I don't need to be alive to win the game and Town is doing fine without my help.

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 11:16

Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 14:14 My thoughts on jamie haven't changed a whole lot. His role sounds very out of place to me. He looks better because of im317 going hard against him but that was during the time when I was the leading vote getter. Why is his role "out of place?" I can't even understand this reasoning. It's like you're speaking a foreign language. Of all the roles to be suspicious about... is it just that you've never seen it before?

I think I've seen a variation of it before but nothing that's so detrimental. It just doesn't seem like it fits in with the theme of this game.

What do you mean "all the roles to be suspicious about" what other roles are there to be suspicious about. brian's lynchproof/bulletproof claim? Thematically it makes sense for something like that to exist. Or he could be trying to draw a kill or lynch on himself.

if i was going to stage a fight with someone, it would have been much more dramatic than that

Jamie's claim was the voting thing right? What were the stipulations on him?

He needs to be first on a scum lynch, I think, and he would die if he changed his vote.

Primate I will say that is a huge let down for this thing on Rose, felt like you had something actually useful. It was what made me think you could be town but it seems like you are just middle of the road and could go either way. Timmah and Josh are probably my biggest scum reads right now and any of the lower lurkers (Wikey, Kat, Lamps). Undecided on a lot of people. Town vibes on Herm, Buffy, Spider, Shawn. Townish vibes on Nav but Buffy does have a good point on the IM317/Nav stuff, I didn't think much of it at the time. I want Christian and TIB to both be town and I usually have blinders when it comes to them which means they are probably scum. If I didn't mention you it's because I am not pulled either way. or I forgot you

Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 14:20

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 11:16 Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 14:14 My thoughts on jamie haven't changed a whole lot. His role sounds very out of place to me. He looks better because of im317 going hard against him but that was during the time when I was the leading vote getter. Why is his role "out of place?" I can't even understand this reasoning. It's like you're speaking a foreign language. Of all the roles to be suspicious about... is it just that you've never seen it before? I think I've seen a variation of it before but nothing that's so detrimental. It just doesn't seem like it fits in with the theme of this game. What do you mean "all the roles to be suspicious about" what other roles are there to be suspicious about. brian's lynchproof/bulletproof claim? Thematically it makes sense for something like that to exist. Or he could be trying to draw a kill or lynch on himself.

I mean of any roles in general. Also, I think you should stop trying to match it up with a character. The role name "The Leader" could have served enough of a thematic purpose for Shadow. If you're town, I think you're really way over-thinking the theme.

Herm @ 25/11/2018 14:24

He needs to be first on a scum lynch, I think, and he would die if he changed his vote.

He has to be first on any lynch.

Herm @ 25/11/2018 14:24

He needs to be first on a scum lynch, I think, and he would die if he changed his vote.

I can change my vote, I just need to be first on the lynch (the leader of the lynch aka where my role name comes from) or I die.