Helios Garabandia @ 24/8/2016 12:57

317, stop lurking and talk. How have you been attacked three times in a row for the same damage? I can think of only a handful of reasons you could have survived, and most of them are not good

really because i can think of 2 ways any player town or scum could have been attacked 3 times and still be alive.

Helios Garabandia @ 24/8/2016 11:57

317, stop lurking and talk. How have you been attacked three times in a row for the same damage? I can think of only a handful of reasons you could have survived, and most of them are not good

ohhh, I've completely skipped 317 in my thinking process. I agree with this, fwiw.

move me up to your top reads, i dare you

My top scum reads would be lamps, Vlady, Brian, Merc, maybe in that order.
Timmah I don't know what to make of you ignoring key parts of my argument but it is what it is.

itsbrianyay @ 24/8/2016 10:59

move me up to your top reads, i dare you

Oh no

thisisbad @ 24/8/2016 17:59

My top scum reads would be lamps, Vlady, Brian, Merc, maybe in that order. Timmah I don't know what to make of you ignoring key parts of my argument but it is what it is.

How is Merc a top read?

I double dog dare YOU.

thisisbad @ 24/8/2016 11:43

The one thing Tim forgot to mention is I said I believe sab after he claimed. And combine that with thinking vern was town, my vote ended up elsewhere. I think I even got into it with someone about me saying I believe sab.

That claim didn't do much in my opinion though. After D1, ahoda was a pretty good bet to be a targeted player so placing a trap in front of him doesn't just automatically scream "town" to me. It was just as likely to harm town, and at the time (before we saw him flip) it could have been a great play if he was scum since he'd have known that scum wouldn't have targeted ahoda.

itsbrianyay @ 24/8/2016 11:59

move me up to your top reads, i dare you

Done. Brian is now amongst my top reads.

my reads

town

22. im317
15. dr
16. Timmah
17. Ole Vern
6. ahoda
7. Oddilus

leaning town

1. Curtis
5. Christian
8. Helios

no idea

10. itsbrianyay
12. thisisbad
13. Drake

need to see more from

14. Dadd
18. Vladykins
19. Lamps

scum

4. Wikey
20. Mercator
21. Chris25

Timmah @ 24/8/2016 11:02

thisisbad @ 24/8/2016 11:43 The one thing Tim forgot to mention is I said I believe sab after he claimed. And combine that with thinking vern was town, my vote ended up elsewhere. I think I even got into it with someone about me saying I believe sab. That claim didn't do much in my opinion though. After D1, ahoda was a pretty good bet to be a targeted player so placing a trap in front of him doesn't just automatically scream "town" to me. It was just as likely to harm town, and at the time (before we saw him flip) it could have been a great play if he was scum since he'd have known that scum wouldn't have targeted ahoda.

Okay, but in my opinion it did. And turns out it was right.

He can't help the hand he was dealt. He believed the whole day. The only thing he had to use one of mine. He used it. Am I supposed to blame him for that? It's like when you get dealt a gun in this game, and then you never use it. What's the point? Use the powers that you have.
He was very specific in saying a mine. I believed it. Turns out, it was an excellent claim. The truth usually is.

im317 @ 24/8/2016 11:04

my reads town 22. im317 15. dr 16. Timmah 17. Ole Vern 6. ahoda 7. Oddilus leaning town 1. Curtis 5. Christian 8. Helios no idea 10. itsbrianyay 12. thisisbad 13. Drake need to see more from 14. Dadd 18. Vladykins 19. Lamps scum 4. Wikey 20. Mercator 21. Chris25

I actually really like this list

im317 @ 24/8/2016 18:04

my reads town 22. im317 15. dr 16. Timmah 17. Ole Vern 6. ahoda 7. Oddilus leaning town 1. Curtis 5. Christian 8. Helios no idea 10. itsbrianyay 12. thisisbad 13. Drake need to see more from 14. Dadd 18. Vladykins 19. Lamps scum 4. Wikey 20. Mercator 21. Chris25

hey my post count is twice (+1 now) as high as yours today, sir

Timmah

It's funny that a guy claimed the truth, I believe the truth, and now you're saying it was a bad claim and I was bad for believing it. Only in Mafia can someone suggest that lying is a much better play than honesty.

thisisbad @ 24/8/2016 11:08

Timmah It's funny that a guy claimed the truth, I believe the truth, and now you're saying it was a bad claim and I was bad for believing it. Only in Mafia can someone suggest that lying is a much better play than honesty.

And according to this reasoning I would have been better off voting to Lynch him, then to believe him.