I'm not confident at all Vic but Curris gives a great argument and really........I have felt town vibes from him all game.

JC @ 19/1/2016 22:45

Timmah @ 19/1/2016 21:16 I'm still in my tunnel so I'll ##lynch JC Dadd's flip reinforces that for me. If dadd flipped town I'd have reconsidered. Maybe... As for herm. I really don't know. I'm back and forth thinking about his claim. Honestly, if Angi hadn't just claimed and flipped Miller in the last game, I'd think herm was slam dunk scum. Can I do anything to mend that burnt bridge? I'm not scum, and if you think I made a dumb choice, then there is definitely a chance I made a dumb choice. I'm definitely pro-town, and I can prove my role (eventually). I'd rather not claim, unless forced, as I'm more help to the town if I don't have to claim.

This was on D5, so there were a lot of people who hadn't claimed at that point. If he was lying about this hint, and a real town BP came up later, he'd then be forced into this somewhat narrow type of role to claim that he'd also have to prove

Well if you think of who might be a pacifist in TWD then you will know I'm town

And who would be Miller? Is there any character that is town but looks scummy??? At most........ Ari's character would be that and he wasn't lol

Alright this isn't fair I have never even seen TWD so idk shit about the characters

Angi do you want me to lynch you

Angi @ 27/1/2016 22:56

I'm not confident at all Vic but Curris gives a great argument and really........I have felt town vibes from him all game.

I have too. There's a few things throwing me off though. Most being is that I still believe if he was Town that he would've been killed last night. At this point I feel like Mafia would want someone like Curtis dead over Vernon, Vernon could've easily been persuaded to tie the vote onto someone else if there is only one scum left so why kill him?

I get the argument Curtis is making about him not being killed but I can't wrap my head around it

don't be talking about characters...

Vic @ 27/1/2016 23:03

Angi @ 27/1/2016 22:56 I'm not confident at all Vic but Curris gives a great argument and really........I have felt town vibes from him all game. I have too. There's a few things throwing me off though. Most being is that I still believe if he was Town that he would've been killed last night. At this point I feel like Mafia would want someone like Curtis dead over Vernon, Vernon could've easily been persuaded to tie the vote onto someone else if there is only one scum left so why kill him? I get the argument Curtis is making about him not being killed but I can't wrap my head around it

I don't know what else I can say about that really, I think I covered it pretty well. Mafia would have (is having) an easier time pushing a lynch on me than they would Vernon. Angi wouldn't have voted Vernon, and I don't think JC would've either. I looked fishier to most people after my vanilla claim and then the incorrect Ari lynch where I was the alternative. I looked at it completely differently than you did I guess, because I would've been really surprised if mafia killed me last night since I'm such a target right now

Curtis @ 27/1/2016 23:12

Vic @ 27/1/2016 23:03 Angi @ 27/1/2016 22:56 I'm not confident at all Vic but Curris gives a great argument and really........I have felt town vibes from him all game. I have too. There's a few things throwing me off though. Most being is that I still believe if he was Town that he would've been killed last night. At this point I feel like Mafia would want someone like Curtis dead over Vernon, Vernon could've easily been persuaded to tie the vote onto someone else if there is only one scum left so why kill him? I get the argument Curtis is making about him not being killed but I can't wrap my head around it I don't know what else I can say about that really, I think I covered it pretty well. Mafia would have (is having) an easier time pushing a lynch on me than they would Vernon. Angi wouldn't have voted Vernon, and I don't think JC would've either. I looked fishier to most people after my vanilla claim and then the incorrect Ari lynch where I was the alternative. I looked at it completely differently than you did I guess, because I would've been really surprised if mafia killed me last night since I'm such a target right now

I get that. But like I said, look at the options. Let's say it's Herm.

I was hiding behind JC, he's BP, Angi has a vote disadvantage. So the only options are you and Vernon. From Herm's perspective, why not keep Vernon alive? As you said, I even started getting skeptical about Vernon yesterday so maybe he could've gotten me on board. He's also someone, like I have said, that wouldn't be nearly as hard for scum Herm to go up against at this point then you

Idk, maybe we are looking at it differently, but I can't shake it. You gotta see where I'm coming from

I do, and like I said earlier I think it was a bad move for Mafia to kill Vern over Angi either way (that's why the you/angi theory popped in my head). So no matter which angle we look at it from, imo it wasn't a good move and isn't gonna make a whole lot of sense

Herm @ 13/1/2016 17:16

Well, this leadership thing came with some good perks. Seems to be a one time thing? Kinda strange to see the person who almost got lynched yesterday to be the only death.

That's the second time he mentioned perks, plural. Yesterday he said he got THINGS, but he's told us he only got the night protection

Look at Herm's posts today:

http://www.ndimforums.com/fe/thread.asp?threadid=4807&postsby=672

This is the work of SCUM!

Buffy Using PM System One minute ago

Oh ho ho, how the tables have turned

12 hours have come and gone and we've had no progress