And since I said this back on Day 2, that would mean someone would have given me this "disadvantage" on Night 1. Would anyone really do that?

Vic @ 22/1/2016 17:32

Ari @ 22/1/2016 5:53 Herm @ 22/1/2016 11:49 Ari is also another player that tries to figure stuff out, but the only thing that holds him back for me atm is that he really hasn't lynched scum. Ive lynched all the dead scum This is isn't true, you left yesterday without lynching because there wasn't time to do anything.

I did lynch Jay, I just unlynched later :) technically not a lie my Vic

##lynch Wikey

Seems like the best choice at the moment.

well, wikey was posting for a bit. now he is gone.

Timmah @ 22/1/2016 10:02

Wikey @ 22/1/2016 5:29 I'm Vanilla. Just want to clear that up now! I don't get Timmah's suspicions on me at all. His entire argument appears to be based on the fact that I've been the second most popular lynch alongside scum on two occasions...Okay. I think scum are playing this very carefully and not defending their scum buddies too hard if at all, jumping on any their buddies lynches. I've been saying it since the Titan/Miko lynch, that the ones to look at where the ones who pushed for Miko, NOT Titan. Dadd was the exception to the rule imo. Scum lynching me to save their buddy on either of those occasions would have been dumb, because they would stand to implicate themselves once I'd flipped. If it is, as Timmah says, a situation where scum had to choose between two of their own, you have to ask yourself what is more valuable than a freaking PGO...because that was basically an extra kill, which would undoubtedly have come in handy at this late stage of the game. Anyway, do with this what you will, we have leeway. Sorry I haven't been as active as I would have liked, I've had less time for this than I initially expected. I think we are in a good position. There probably isn't anymore than 2 scum left, 3 at most. There probably isn't a third party. My argument at the moment is that right at this very moment it appears that the not a single one of the 4 votes on you in the last day phase are mafia. Given that a mafia member was lynched, how exactly would you explain that phenomenon?

Do I not consider this exact question in the post you are quoting?

I don't know for certain, but I reckon the remaining scum are pretty much throwing their own under the bus at the first sign of trouble to avoid casting shade on themselves. After seeing what a mess Dadd made when he intervened to save Miko, I wouldn't blame them if that is the case! So it's either that, or they are just inactive as fuck. Without Dadd's intervention on Day 2, Miko would have been lynched over both me and Titan. Would you be applying this same flawed logic to Titan if he was still alive?

I don't like been accused of being scum based on circumstances that are completely beyond my control. Conveniently, I wasn't even around for both major lynch trains on me. Seems a bit of a coincidence, don't you think?

Timmah @ 22/1/2016 11:17

well, wikey was posting for a bit. now he is gone.

Wanted to check if Jay cast any votes on Day 2 to see if this theory of mine lines up with his voting patterns. Turns out he didn't show!

So, your only argument is that scum is just lynching scum all game? I don't buy that at all. I especially don't buy that on D2 when there was absolutely no reason for them to be doing that with how that day ended.

Do we really think there's a backup doc too when we've already had a doctor and a bodyguard?
I believe in a Mafia Doctor..

Wikey - vanilla
Timmah - backup doc
Angi - pacifist weird voter person
Bryce - tracker

Anyone else I am missing who claimed?

First of all, I think your blowing the Day 2 train on me way out of proportion. I was the third highest in the votes, but Miko and Titan were ahead by a fair few. Are you suggesting that Dadd lynching Titan was not only an attempt to save Miko, but an attempt to save me too? That because he chose to lynch Titan over me, that might mean I am scum?

Because that makes no sense! Dadd's vote and Vernon's vote on me would not have been enough to put me in the lead, and Miko would have gotten lynched.

And yesterday's vote. If I am scum, why would my buddies lynch Jay over me? He was PGO! A very powerful role for Mafia.

Scum are either actively throwing their own under the bus, or simply not intervening to defend them. Perhaps the reason there was no town on my train is that scum aren't voting very often, leaving us to it.

Wikey (4/7) - Timmah, JC, Vic, Ari
Curtis (1/7) - Vernon
Brian (1/7) - Angi
Timmah (0/7) - Vernon
Ari (0/7) - Bryce
Angi (0/7) - Bryce, Ari

Vern For Mod 2016 @ 22/1/2016 17:46

Wikey - vanilla Timmah - backup doc Angi - pacifist weird voter person Bryce - tracker Anyone else I am missing who claimed?

Sounds about right.

Vern For Mod 2016 @ 22/1/2016 11:44

Do we really think there's a backup doc too when we've already had a doctor and a bodyguard? I believe in a Mafia Doctor..

Bryce being protected by a mafia doctor doesn't make much sense. He was the clinching vote on Jay yesterday, and it seems far more likely that the mafia would attack Bryce than Ahoda.

Well, as I say, you guys can do what you want, we don't lose much by losing me. But I'm telling you, scum are playing games.

##Lynch Brian

Sorry if you got upset Brian, I do understand that you were away on a tour but wasn't caught up entirely before you explained. We are getting down to the wire of who could be scum, I don't believe you're making things up as an excuse but ruling more and more people left you remain on top.

Vern For Mod 2016 @ 22/1/2016 11:46

Wikey - vanilla Timmah - backup doc Angi - pacifist weird voter person Bryce - tracker Anyone else I am missing who claimed?

backup cop, not doc. Sorry to rain on that parade about a mafia doc.