I dunno how MST works because I'm an idiot :curtis:

Sorry for prematurely locking it for a bit

DD @ 21/1/2015 4:21

Sorry I'm here! Initial thought is that the mafia ate up vic's mistake. I think a vic lynch today would be a huge mistake, and honestly I think the same about Dylan. I don't like how that train picked up at all. I would say maybe an FOS on greenday? Seems defensive but maybe that's just the way he talks

Well you think Vic and Dylan are bad choices, maybe find a better choice and vote for them? You dont seem to be eager to help at all.

##Lynch Greenday

Lynching Dylan would be stupid after his claim. He might be full of shit but we'll see in the future surely

Curtis @ 21/1/2015 7:03

I dunno how MST works because I'm an idiot :curtis: Sorry for prematurely locking it for a bit

Im not entirely sure, but I think there is an hour and 15 left?

Ari @ 21/1/2015 2:04

Curtis @ 21/1/2015 7:03 I dunno how MST works because I'm an idiot :curtis: Sorry for prematurely locking it for a bit Im not entirely sure, but I think there is an hour and 15 left?

An hour and 55

Votes:

Dylan - Paul, Chris, Ahoda, Wikey (4/10)
Greenday - Paul, Christian, Matt, Curtis (3/10)
Paul - Ari, Wikey (1/10)
Wikey - Lamps, Paul (0/10)
Chris - Ahoda (1/10)
Vic - Lamps (0/10)
Matt - drr (1/10)

I dont like DD coming in saying "these guys are bad choices!" and then not come up with any counter suggestions.

Then I didnt like Matt voting Moose yesterday and now he is agreeing with DD and randomly voting Greenday. Why is Greenday a better lynch than Dylan? They have both softclaimed informative roles.

I wasn't wanting to claim, especially since I'll likely be targeted tonight. But on the off chance I don't, I can help town.

I still get a really fishy feeling from Dylan, i don't trust greenday either but just the way Matt has been playing this game so far kinda makes me wonder whats really going on.

Greenday's role could be useful, but he also said he didn't want to contribute because of Vic. Seems kind of like an excuse.

I agree with Ari that Matt may be a better lynch than Greenday. While I really dislike Greenday's excuse for not contributing, his role may be legitimate. Matt has several strikes against him between the JJ targeting, he posted multiple posts against her and lynched her before claiming his logic was flawed.

I still am leaning towards Greenday (I think Curtis missed my lynch vote on him), but I can see a strong argument for Matt. Still not sold on Paul either, but that ship has sailed today. He targeted both Moose and Boc and was absent yesterday (albeit for a game, which if we are letting dr slide, might as well let him slide to I suppose) and showed up today when people started lynching him.

Curtis @ 21/1/2015 7:07

Votes: Dylan - Paul, Chris, Ahoda, Wikey (4/10) Greenday - Paul, Christian, Matt, Curtis (3/10) Paul - Ari, Wikey (1/10) Wikey - Lamps, Paul (0/10) Chris - Ahoda (1/10) Vic - Lamps (0/10) Matt - drr (1/10)

You forgot Dylan so its 4-4 tie now.........

Dylan, why should I vote for Greenday over you?

Ari @ 21/1/2015 3:02

Curtis @ 21/1/2015 7:07 Votes: Dylan - Paul, Chris, Ahoda, Wikey (4/10) Greenday - Paul, Christian, Matt, Curtis (3/10) Paul - Ari, Wikey (1/10) Wikey - Lamps, Paul (0/10) Chris - Ahoda (1/10) Vic - Lamps (0/10) Matt - drr (1/10) You forgot Dylan so its 4-4 tie now......... Dylan, why should I vote for Greenday over you?

Thanks...........

25 minutes

Is a tie a no lynch? Someone's gotta vote

My Von you must unlynch. Unless you strongly feel I should jump to Dylan but I dunno if that's a great idea. TALK TO ME! 13 minutes

Soft-claiming an investigative role with several potentials in a role deck of this size and magnitude (so there's a great likelihood of any one of them existing) is a very, very easy claim to make. Much safer than Wikey's mason claim which can be discounted by other players.

It doesn't really persuade me, but I'm missing something so I'll go read up.