My reads/lynch suggestions:

Town:
JJ :)
Angi - I believe her claim
Rob - I believe his claim
Vic - I think he's town

Cleared from SK:
Dylan - Semi-active but I haven't seen anything that stands out, only cleared from SK though
Patrick - "

Cleared from Werewolf & Cult (for now):
Curtis - He could definitely be Mafia or Alien but unless there's more evidence than "he could be" I think he's a bad lynch choice

Cleared from Cult (at least N1):
Ari - Less cleared to me than anyone else who's cleared or claimed but I don't find him scummy

Leaning more toward town than scum, good input:
Christian - Either town or scum blending very well
Lamps - "

Semi-active/Not sure:
DD - Hasn't posted a lot but today seems more involved. I don't see anything shady that stands out.
Jeffrey - Same, he's not a huge contributor but he's making sense when he posts.
Schrauben - Seemed very town to me D1 but has definitely dropped off for me.
Samm - Very hard to tell. Seems like he's focused on one person
Chris - I buy that he's not reading 20 pages when he catches up. This is like his 5th game or something but last game was pretty basic. This game is hard to understand for even some vets (:
DR - Disappointing activity and I wouldn't mind if she just claimed if she doesn't plan on playing
Tony - Nothing out of the ordinary for him, which doesn't excuse him. I think his activity picks up when there's pressure on him so I guess just keep that up.

Shady and/or Inactive:
Ahoda - I still don't like his threats of "once I flip you're going to be sorry" and even I think he can admit to trolling D1 and parts of D2. He seemed to get more serious with threat of being lynched but I don't see much input besides defending himself.
Wikey - Completely not helpful, seems to be on purpose.
Moose - She could be town but doesn't add to anything and she keeps getting saved over good town roles.
Paul - Agree with Ari. He's logical and started out D1 with good advice but I'm sure he could recite all that in his sleep. D2 I didn't like his jump on Boc and D3 he hasn't posted at all.
Nofo - Seemed to have been trying to be helpful but then just turned it around. What did he really contribute though? Stating the obvious and sounding logical doesn't make you town if you're not helping find scum.
Matt - I don't like most of his posts and I don't see him actively hunting scum. Moreso just talking about how he has been.


Greenday - I'm putting him a step above Jamie only because he's said more than "hi." Other than than, he didn't post at all D2 and D3 all he did was make one post about me railroading but didn't mention anything about scum. No input/very reminiscent of his scum games to me. Why is there no shade on him at all?

Completely inactive/No way to tell:
Jamie - He's had a pass for two days. He's shown up but hasn't had any input.

Nofo ☭ @ 18/1/2015 14:23

JJ @ 18/1/2015 15:04 Lamps @ 18/1/2015 9:01 Angi @ 18/1/2015 14:42 *sigh* I'm leaving soon, hope you guys get it right today. Lets not lose another valuable member of the town please. Well, looking at your vote, if Nofo is town then we're sure to lose a valuable member of the town since he is contributing a lot. Really? What has he contributed today? Buffy, do you honestly not get how this is a blatant omgus?

Nope. I think you're scum and haven't said anything today to make me think otherwise. This isn't helping.

Jj hell yeah I trolled day 1. It's day 1.

I'm gonna go ahead and retract my statements about Buffy domineering discussion. I'm rereading and she never discredited points. I got distracted because I'm friends with Matt and saw what he wanted to see.

JJ @ 18/1/2015 15:50

Nofo ☭ @ 18/1/2015 14:23 JJ @ 18/1/2015 15:04 Lamps @ 18/1/2015 9:01 Angi @ 18/1/2015 14:42 *sigh* I'm leaving soon, hope you guys get it right today. Lets not lose another valuable member of the town please. Well, looking at your vote, if Nofo is town then we're sure to lose a valuable member of the town since he is contributing a lot. Really? What has he contributed today? Buffy, do you honestly not get how this is a blatant omgus? Nope. I think you're scum and haven't said anything today to make me think otherwise. This isn't helping.

You never once accused me of anything until I suspected you and you haven't given any reason for it but "he suddenly turned against me, so suspicious." That is an OMGUS.

And to be completely honest, I first accused you to reaction test and you did exactly what I thought you would so you confirmed my bias.

Nofo ☭ @ 18/1/2015 14:51

I'm gonna go ahead and retract my statements about Buffy domineering discussion. I'm rereading and she never discredited points. I got distracted because I'm friends with Matt and saw what he wanted to see.

backpedaling?

We're pretty split right now if I got this right.

Tony 1/13 - Lamps, Moose
Wikey 2/13 - Vic, Matt
JJ 0/13 - Ahoda, Matt, Nofo
Curtis 1/13 - Rob
Ahoda 0/13 - Angi
Nofo 2/13 - JJ, Angi
Paul 1/13 - Ari
dr 1/13 - Lamps
Moose 1/13 - Tony
Matt 1/13 - Samm

I'm leaning towards Chris with my vote atm with Christian 2nd.


Serious question to the group. How long we going to let Jaime just hang on? Dude popped on and only said hi.

JJ @ 18/1/2015 16:02

Nofo ☭ @ 18/1/2015 14:51 I'm gonna go ahead and retract my statements about Buffy domineering discussion. I'm rereading and she never discredited points. I got distracted because I'm friends with Matt and saw what he wanted to see. backpedaling?

No, I'm not backpedaling. I'm gonna own up to being stupid. I still think you're making a blatant omgus

JJ @ 18/1/2015 20:04

Lamps @ 18/1/2015 9:01 Angi @ 18/1/2015 14:42 *sigh* I'm leaving soon, hope you guys get it right today. Lets not lose another valuable member of the town please. Well, looking at your vote, if Nofo is town then we're sure to lose a valuable member of the town since he is contributing a lot. Really? What has he contributed today?

He is posting, that's something. People who don't post we have no read on or whatsoever. I didn't even know DD was playing until his post today :x

Lamps @ 18/1/2015 15:14

JJ @ 18/1/2015 20:04 Lamps @ 18/1/2015 9:01 Angi @ 18/1/2015 14:42 *sigh* I'm leaving soon, hope you guys get it right today. Lets not lose another valuable member of the town please. Well, looking at your vote, if Nofo is town then we're sure to lose a valuable member of the town since he is contributing a lot. Really? What has he contributed today? He is posting, that's something. People who don't post we have no read on or whatsoever. I didn't even know DD was playing until his post today :x

What about Greenday? What about Jamie? I see you going after certain people for inactivity but why Rose/DD over them? At least Rose/DD have acknowledged there is a game, DD has posted thoughts, Rose has offered to claim. Why would you want her lynched before she has a chance to do that?

I still wanna know how the fuck Angi thinks checking Curtis twice rules out Psychotrooper

Do you think the Psychotrooper could be one of the people claiming an investigative role?

Nofo ☭ @ 18/1/2015 16:21

Do you think the Psychotrooper could be one of the people claiming an investigative role?

Nevermind, that's dumb. They'd still be guessing in their reports.