No idea!

Like I said, Greenday stands out to me the most, but I have enough reservations about him that I'm willing to give him a pass for now.

Well then, there is only one way to find out:

##Lynch: Greenday

I have a real issue with Greenday's late sign up. I would be very surprised if he is mafia. Third party is an option I think.

I wouldn't call making one or two posts ASKING if someone could come forward with information HARASSING people....

I mean it's not like I'm PRODDING people and constantly saying "I SEE YOU VIEWING SPEAK UP SPEAK UP"

*cough cough*JJ in Dead Zone*cough cough*

I only posted twice to see if someone could give us a lead. Why is that even suspicious?

Oh, and one last thing. I'm pretty sure the delay between me bringing it up and him adding me to the game was a product of him typing up my role and flavor for the PM, not thinking how to rebalance the game.

I agree with the Greenday thing, but I find it more likely he would have a useless town role than mafia. I guess a third party role could've been added too though. I don't like that he joined the game late tbh

Because wanting people to oust their roles is suspicious! On Day 2 the best you're going to get from a town cop is one scan. If they have information, it's still only a single night's worth. They reveal and now they're Night 2's biggest target. With Curtis gone, the chances of a protect on that cop are very low. They die, no more cop in play.

Just because you weren't abrasive about it doesn't mean it isn't a problem. The problem is encouraging someone to oust themselves on Day 2 at all.

I doubt he has a useful town role either tbh.

I think a less useful town role or a third party are more likely than town power or mafia

If we all agree that its unlikely he is mafia than would it be smart to lynch him?

Vic @ 3/1/2014 14:49

If we all agree that its unlikely he is mafia than would it be smart to lynch him?

No...?

Vic @ 2/1/2014 20:49

If we all agree that its unlikely he is mafia than would it be smart to lynch him?

That's the main reason I'm hesitating. Third party is still an option though, and if it's between someone I think is suspicious but probably not mafia and a random lynch, I think it makes perfect sense to go for someone who is suspicious.

Kiwi @ 2/1/2014 20:51

Vic @ 3/1/2014 14:49 If we all agree that its unlikely he is mafia than would it be smart to lynch him? No...?

That was intended for Rose since she seemed to be considering it

deaderrose @ 3/1/2014 14:52

Vic @ 2/1/2014 20:49 If we all agree that its unlikely he is mafia than would it be smart to lynch him? That's the main reason I'm hesitating. Third party is still an option though, and if it's between someone I think is suspicious but probably not mafia and a random lynch, I think it makes perfect sense to go for someone who is suspicious.

Good point.

But I am not sure how much third party would want to know roles... Like hes probably not a SK. So I kinda doubt he has a killing role if he is third party.