Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
Page: 1 ... 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
True Detective
 
Justin
User Avatar
Shrink
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -28
Group:Regular
Posts:711
Joined:Dec 8, 2012
Post #181: 21st Jul 2015 10:32 AM 
i really dont give a shit about frank and jordan and i'm not sure how i'm supposed to

this episode was the first one that i enjoyed, though. glad they're finally focusing on a narrative and i'm hoping encompassing half the show in development pays off big time.
 
   
Boc
User Avatar
Posted Image
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 157
Group:Admin
Posts:19,032
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #182: 21st Jul 2015 6:02 PM 
Wikey @ 21/7/2015 5:13
Yeah I can't tell if it's intentional or not, but his lines are really awful. And I do at least agree about Velcoro. Dude's story is the shit.

But for the past several episodes, I have become puzzled about why Frank and Paul are part of the main cast. I feel like this season would be way better if it had just focused on Ani and Ray. Easily the two strongest characters. It's almost as if they figured there would be no topping Rust and Marty so they decided to avoid the duo setup and try something different. And different is fine if it works. But from the very start of this season it hasn't for me.

Can anybody give me a good reason why Paul is in the show? His story has existed on the periphery so far and he just feels tacked on.

And what about Frank? I get that he is linked to the case, but why is he a main character, instead of somebody that shows up now and again to further the mystery?

This is my theory...these four main characters are going to end up pitted against each other due to conflicting interests, all of which we can relate to, and we are going to be split between them. Given that the show has spent most of it's time humanizing them and giving them problems we can understand, I'm convinced that's what they are going for.

I've seen some suggest that Frank is given these pretentious lines because he's a gangster posing as a smart businessman, so he constantly feels like he needs to put on an act. Which I guess I could see, but if so they haven't made it very clear, so ultimately that feels like an excuse for bad writing

And yeah, I'm thinking the same about the 4. I still have enough faith in Pizzolatto that there's SOME point to all this build-up and seemingly unnecessary scenes with Frank/Paul
Posted Image
Posted Image
   
Boc
User Avatar
Posted Image
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 157
Group:Admin
Posts:19,032
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #183: 26th Jul 2015 9:51 PM 
well, that ending was something

Spoiler+
Posted Image
Posted Image
   
Boc
User Avatar
Posted Image
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 157
Group:Admin
Posts:19,032
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #184: 26th Jul 2015 10:07 PM 
Spoiler+
Posted Image
Posted Image
   
Justin
User Avatar
Shrink
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -28
Group:Regular
Posts:711
Joined:Dec 8, 2012
Post #185: 27th Jul 2015 8:20 AM 
Awesome episode!

My gripes of the season hold that I don't really care about the case and even if I re-watch and read I can't bring myself to pay attention to the dynamics at play. They spend 45 minutes an episode throwing their personal stories down our throats then spend 5 seconds explaining who each antagonist is.
 
   
Aspen
User Avatar
Sausage Islander
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 6
Group:Newcomer
Posts:87
Joined:Jun 28, 2012
Post #186: 27th Jul 2015 3:34 PM 


Boc @ 21/7/2015 18:02
Wikey @ 21/7/2015 5:13
Yeah I can't tell if it's intentional or not, but his lines are really awful. And I do at least agree about Velcoro. Dude's story is the shit.

But for the past several episodes, I have become puzzled about why Frank and Paul are part of the main cast. I feel like this season would be way better if it had just focused on Ani and Ray. Easily the two strongest characters. It's almost as if they figured there would be no topping Rust and Marty so they decided to avoid the duo setup and try something different. And different is fine if it works. But from the very start of this season it hasn't for me.

Can anybody give me a good reason why Paul is in the show? His story has existed on the periphery so far and he just feels tacked on.

And what about Frank? I get that he is linked to the case, but why is he a main character, instead of somebody that shows up now and again to further the mystery?

This is my theory...these four main characters are going to end up pitted against each other due to conflicting interests, all of which we can relate to, and we are going to be split between them. Given that the show has spent most of it's time humanizing them and giving them problems we can understand, I'm convinced that's what they are going for.

I've seen some suggest that Frank is given these pretentious lines because he's a gangster posing as a smart businessman, so he constantly feels like he needs to put on an act. Which I guess I could see, but if so they haven't made it very clear, so ultimately that feels like an excuse for bad writing

And yeah, I'm thinking the same about the 4. I still have enough faith in Pizzolatto that there's SOME point to all this build-up and seemingly unnecessary scenes with Frank/Paul


I think I agree with the theory about Frank's dialogue and that's because people have made fun of him for it (subtly) a few times in the show. I.e. Ray saying he's feeling "apoplectic". I also feel that they spent a fair amount of time specifically figuring out how Frank should talk.

He ultimately seems like a guy trying to get into a higher world but things keep following him behind which is reflected in the way he speaks. Like when he says "ain't" constantly.

Idk doe maybe I'm just high

Post Edited by Aspen @ 27th Jul 2015 3:35 PM
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #187: 27th Jul 2015 4:11 PM 
I don't know, that sounds like an excuse for shitty writing to me.

Anyway...

latest ep+
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #188: 27th Jul 2015 4:16 PM 
@Aspen, I ain't totally dismissing that as a possibility though. You do have to wonder how lines like "Blue balls in your heart" and "Never do anything out of hunger, not even eating" made it to film.

But if it is intentional, it isn't working.
 
   
Justin
User Avatar
Shrink
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: -28
Group:Regular
Posts:711
Joined:Dec 8, 2012
Post #189: 28th Jul 2015 3:24 PM 
Vince Vaughn isn't selling it, but I'm not sure that anyone even could. I feel like the lines would need some sort of campiness to them to even play, like a relaxed, jokester character. If they were played with hints of sarcasm and less self-seriousness they could work.

I almost think Robin Williams could've killed this role? A humorous character sure would make the story more engaging, anyways.
 
   
Boc
User Avatar
Posted Image
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 157
Group:Admin
Posts:19,032
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #190: 28th Jul 2015 6:24 PM 
I still think Vaughn's best scene by far has been the one in episode 2 (I think) where he's mocking/threatening the guy that his thugs just beat up. They should've wrote the character more smarmy like that considering it's pretty much Vaughn's specialty
Posted Image
Posted Image
   
Aspen
User Avatar
Sausage Islander
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 6
Group:Newcomer
Posts:87
Joined:Jun 28, 2012
Post #191: 2nd Aug 2015 7:30 PM 
Wikey @ 27/7/2015 16:16
@Aspen, I ain't totally dismissing that as a possibility though. You do have to wonder how lines like "Blue balls in your heart" and "Never do anything out of hunger, not even eating" made it to film.

But if it is intentional, it isn't working.



I don't know man, it's not striking me as awful like awful things usually do. Maybe I'm just a cringey douchebag idk.

I think Vince Vaughn isn't really selling it though. He looks way too much like himself and that's killin it for me.
 
   
Aspen
User Avatar
Sausage Islander
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 6
Group:Newcomer
Posts:87
Joined:Jun 28, 2012
Post #192: 2nd Aug 2015 8:00 PM 
ALSO

Spoiler+



Definitely my least favorite episode this season but EP 7 is on now so PEACE BITCHES
 
   
Aspen
User Avatar
Sausage Islander
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 6
Group:Newcomer
Posts:87
Joined:Jun 28, 2012
Post #193: 2nd Aug 2015 9:08 PM 
Not gonna lie, I fuckin loved that episode.

Spoiler+
 
   
Boc
User Avatar
Posted Image
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 157
Group:Admin
Posts:19,032
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #194: 2nd Aug 2015 9:28 PM 
That was great. Why couldn't the rest of the season be more like that

Spoiler+


90 minute finale apparently? yay
Posted Image
Posted Image
   
Boc
User Avatar
Posted Image
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 157
Group:Admin
Posts:19,032
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #195: 2nd Aug 2015 9:31 PM 
Aspen @ 2/8/2015 20:00
ALSO

Spoiler+



Definitely my least favorite episode this season but EP 7 is on now so PEACE BITCHES

Spoiler+
Posted Image
Posted Image
   
2 Users Viewing (2 Guests)
  Television  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service