Oh, you mean the extra kill? Does it make sense that mafia has an extra kill? Usually that's a town JOAT action. I mean there's an extra scum kill from somewhere but idk if it's a JOAT.

From most to least likely in each category.

Xmen:
Nav
JJ - duh
Shawn - duh x2
Cultis - bleck


Herm - Admittedly his vote on Rose D1 had me fooled. It looked better than it was at the time because of only 5 lynch votes.
Ahoda - Ehhh. I"m only really putting him here because there's a good chance we have 2 Mafia left and he seems worse off than bri.
Brian - still think its weird that both him and Cultis can be town but his behavior has been town like. Could just be bri being a really convincing talker tho.

Sentinel (SK)
Zersch - If Z isn't SK I'll be extremely shocked
Spider - Leaning on believing her as 3P Survivor for now

---

One WAY OUT THERE possibility is that Bufferminator and Shawn are SK and SKiT who decided to yolo it and go with a Mason claim since D1. But I think if we go down that rabbit hole we will just implode lol.

JJ @ 2/12/2018 23:33

Oh, you mean the extra kill? Does it make sense that mafia has an extra kill? Usually that's a town JOAT action. I mean there's an extra scum kill from somewhere but idk if it's a JOAT.

Yeah I do think the extra kill is most likely a Mafia JOAT action.

Sebclops @ 2/12/2018 23:37

From most to least likely in each category. Xmen: Nav JJ - duh Shawn - duh x2 Cultis - bleck Brotherhood Herm - Admittedly his vote on Rose D1 had me fooled. It looked better than it was at the time because of only 5 lynch votes. Ahoda - Ehhh. I"m only really putting him here because there's a good chance we have 2 Mafia left and he seems worse off than bri. Brian - still think its weird that both him and Cultis can be town but his behavior has been town like. Could just be bri being a really convincing talker tho. Sentinel (SK) Zersch - If Z isn't SK I'll be extremely shocked Spider - Leaning on believing her as 3P Survivor for now --- One WAY OUT THERE possibility is that Bufferminator and Shawn are SK and SKiT who decided to yolo it and go with a Mason claim since D1. But I think if we go down that rabbit hole we will just implode lol.

Fixed

What's your theory of why Primate's kill failed, Nav?

JJ @ 2/12/2018 23:45

What's your theory of why Primate's kill failed, Nav?

Possibly another one of the Mafia JOAT actions. Not a block but something else.

9 players alive

1 SK
1-2 Mafia
1 claimed 3P
5-6 Town

If we nail the SK today we go into the night at 8 people alive. Only 1 kill at night. Start the next day with 7 people. So even if we have 2 Mafia left at that point we should still be in good shape.

If we lynch one of the Mafia today and if there are 2, then we're looking at a potential 2 kills at night. Which means we would be at 6 alive - 1 Mafia 1 SK 1 claimed 3P and 3 town. Which is a little trickier.

Essentially we can't afford a mislynch today (or really at any point from today)

##Lynch Nav

I just caught up and LISTEN, I apologize for not attempting to make this more interesting (especially after yesterday) but... I'm Mafia Jack. We have attacked Nav and he has survived. He is absolutely lying and I'm flabbergasted that he has made it this far with the circus surrounding him since jump street.

Oh HELLLL YEA

You know what Zersch, SAME!

Sorry for calling you stanky, it’s only a mild odor at best

Was the extra kill because of you

Nav was definitely trying to broadcast to the mafia that JJ and Shawn were Masons and should be taken out. There was absolutely no reason for him to say that if he was Town

What was it like serving under godfather317 for a night? Was he a fair ruler?

Curtis @ 3/12/2018 7:02

What was it like serving under godfather317 for a night? Was he a fair ruler?

It was a religious experience. He was firm. VERY firm. But yes, fair.

The wind was taken out of our sails when he fell.

SHAKA, WHEN THE WALLS FELL

Nav do you still want us to lynch the SK or