But Herm makes way more sense as SK than Mafia

Sebclops @ 30/11/2018 22:58

JJ @ 30/11/2018 19:56 Nav, I don't really think you're SK and now I have questions about who survived the attack but you're acting more like frustrated scum than frustrated town to me. Ask your questions

I don't have questions as in - I'm going to ask a list of questions about it. I've already voiced my questions in that I am not sure whether Primate's information that his kill was "unsuccessful" means it didn't go through at all.

JJ @ 30/11/2018 21:59

Primate @ 30/11/2018 22:57 Herm @ 30/11/2018 21:45 Lol at me being Mafia. Autocorrect changed look to lol While it's always possible Herm could be mafia, I think he looks least like mafia than anything per his votes/actions.

The 50 or so times I've seen town herm lynched just for being herm, his behavior and reactions have been different than it has in this game.

Sebclops @ 30/11/2018 23:01

But Herm makes way more sense as SK than Mafia

So does Christian unless he's mafia.

Hey, Nav. Do you remember a game or two ago you made a list of who probably is/is not scum together? Do you have ideas for that in this game?

Primate @ 30/11/2018 21:59

If my kill was redirected, it about had to be shifted to Brian. Would scum Brian have them do that to get town cred?

Conversely, town brian wouldnt lie about it.

Primate @ 30/11/2018 23:02

JJ @ 30/11/2018 21:59 Primate @ 30/11/2018 22:57 Herm @ 30/11/2018 21:45 Lol at me being Mafia. Autocorrect changed look to lol While it's always possible Herm could be mafia, I think he looks least like mafia than anything per his votes/actions. The 50 or so times I've seen town herm lynched just for being herm, his behavior and reactions have been different than it has in this game.

You think Herm is scum every single game.

JJ @ 30/11/2018 22:04

Primate @ 30/11/2018 23:02 JJ @ 30/11/2018 21:59 Primate @ 30/11/2018 22:57 Herm @ 30/11/2018 21:45 Lol at me being Mafia. Autocorrect changed look to lol While it's always possible Herm could be mafia, I think he looks least like mafia than anything per his votes/actions. The 50 or so times I've seen town herm lynched just for being herm, his behavior and reactions have been different than it has in this game. You think Herm is scum every single game.

Untrue

Sebclops @ 30/11/2018 22:01

But Herm makes way more sense as SK than Mafia

I could see Herm or Zersch as SK

I can agree to disagree about herm.

What do you think of zersch?

Sebclops @ 30/11/2018 23:01

If we actually ARE scumhunting beyond the "lol lets lynch Nav" thought process I would say the most likely mafia are brian = Christian > Z >>>> Herm

Primate @ 30/11/2018 23:06

JJ @ 30/11/2018 22:04 Primate @ 30/11/2018 23:02 JJ @ 30/11/2018 21:59 Primate @ 30/11/2018 22:57 Herm @ 30/11/2018 21:45 Lol at me being Mafia. Autocorrect changed look to lol While it's always possible Herm could be mafia, I think he looks least like mafia than anything per his votes/actions. The 50 or so times I've seen town herm lynched just for being herm, his behavior and reactions have been different than it has in this game. You think Herm is scum every single game. Untrue

You're right, I was generalizing and, to be fair, a lot of people think he's scummy when he's town. I'm not saying he can't be scum, I just think if he is scum he's probably more SK but I keep getting town vibes. He's only in unknown/scum category for me because of process of elim.

Primate @ 30/11/2018 23:08

I can agree to disagree about herm. What do you think of zersch?

I feel kind of the same with Zersch in that he gives off good vibes but I do think he could be mafia OR SK. Also, process of elim with him, too.

JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:03

Sebclops @ 30/11/2018 23:01 But Herm makes way more sense as SK than Mafia So does Christian unless he's mafia. Hey, Nav. Do you remember a game or two ago you made a list of who probably is/is not scum together? Do you have ideas for that in this game?

I'm curious what scumhunting Christian has actually done to seem more like SK than Mafia.

As to who is scum together or not together, I haven't seen anything glaring. I usually make note of it as I'm reading. I'll try to think about it as I'm re-reading when I'm at home.

Sebclops @ 30/11/2018 23:16

JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:03 Sebclops @ 30/11/2018 23:01 But Herm makes way more sense as SK than Mafia So does Christian unless he's mafia. Hey, Nav. Do you remember a game or two ago you made a list of who probably is/is not scum together? Do you have ideas for that in this game? I'm curious what scumhunting Christian has actually done to seem more like SK than Mafia. As to who is scum together or not together, I haven't seen anything glaring. I usually make note of it as I'm reading. I'll try to think about it as I'm re-reading when I'm at home.

I don't think he seems more SK than Mafia. I just think if you're mafia, Christian probably isn't.

I've been leaning scum or SK on Zersch. His posts just don't seem to come off as town to me. But then I also feel that I haven't gotten enough game posts from him to get a clearer read.

What do you think of him, Primate? Sorry if you already mentioned it

JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:17

Sebclops @ 30/11/2018 23:16 JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:03 Sebclops @ 30/11/2018 23:01 But Herm makes way more sense as SK than Mafia So does Christian unless he's mafia. Hey, Nav. Do you remember a game or two ago you made a list of who probably is/is not scum together? Do you have ideas for that in this game? I'm curious what scumhunting Christian has actually done to seem more like SK than Mafia. As to who is scum together or not together, I haven't seen anything glaring. I usually make note of it as I'm reading. I'll try to think about it as I'm re-reading when I'm at home. I don't think he seems more SK than Mafia. I just think if you're mafia, Christian probably isn't.

Ah ok. Yeah I can agree with that. I also believe Christian and I are not on the same team.