If Zach is lying, it is a very creative and well thought out claim.

He was straight on my case when I brought up the possibility of a Cult the other day. Something feels right about this. I believe him.

Mike @ 29/10/2018 12:23

Shadow @ 29/10/2018 12:17 Nobody is going on my town list until I see a role from them. Otherwise they stay at neutral unsure. Why is Merc on your town list mittens? and whats TIB's claim???? People are assigning people town with the notes of "oh I think I know their role, therefore town" The reason we haven't elaborated is because there's a chance the mafia haven't figured it out. So it's better to keep them in the dark if possible. That said, I'd rather TiB claimed, because I don't see the advantage to keeping his role secret now.

Since you've got everything figured out go ahead and claim. You've put enough focus on it that if they didn't know they're trying to figure it out now.

I don't even know how this became a big thing

Thisisbad @ 29/10/2018 12:24

I haven't claimed anything. And for some of you talking bout bad reads and wrong side of anything tyou seem to think we've been lynching scum left and right. I missed the havo lynch cause i voted mittens. If mittens flips town that's on me. But let's not act like this town had its shit together all game

So we've been wrongly assuming you were mason with Nofo?

Ahoda @ 29/10/2018 12:23

Mittens, Buffy wanted you lynched. Why shouldn't I honor her last request?

Because you said you don't see scummittens

THE ROSE @ 29/10/2018 12:24

hey can somebody fill me in: what is the mittens argument

he has mostly posted vague commentary all game long without really scum hunting. at least thats how I first thought it started idk cant speak for anyone else. I was fine with a mittens lynch until the havo/vic deaths. Made me skeptical

I still think Vic would place a mafia member on his day kill list. Which leaves Mittens/Nav/Merc. Thats why I lynched Merc...along the lines of also not being helpful all game and staying distant

TiB, this unexpected hostility from you is making me sad.

Thisisbad @ 29/10/2018 12:27

Ahoda @ 29/10/2018 12:23 Mittens, Buffy wanted you lynched. Why shouldn't I honor her last request? Because you said you don't see scummittens

My reads have been shit. Buffy was spot on. I trust her more then me. (:

Ahoda @ 29/10/2018 12:23

Mittens, Buffy wanted you lynched. Why shouldn't I honor her last request?

Because she was wrong about me being scum.

Shadow @ 29/10/2018 12:28

THE ROSE @ 29/10/2018 12:24 hey can somebody fill me in: what is the mittens argument he has mostly posted vague commentary all game long without really scum hunting. at least thats how I first thought it started idk cant speak for anyone else. I was fine with a mittens lynch until the havo/vic deaths. Made me skeptical I still think Vic would place a mafia member on his day kill list. Which leaves Mittens/Nav/Merc. Thats why I lynched Merc...along the lines of also not being helpful all game and staying distant

I'm pretty certain Merc isn't mafia. Could be 3rd party, but not mafia.

@Shadow: Agreed that Vic would have put a scummate on his scum list. But it's worth pointing out that Havo also called out Mittens several times and expressed a desire to lynch him.

Mittens @ 29/10/2018 12:28

Ahoda @ 29/10/2018 12:23 Mittens, Buffy wanted you lynched. Why shouldn't I honor her last request? Because she was wrong about me being scum.

welp I'm sold!

Maybe Mittens is scum and that is why Vic let his mask slip yesterday. With no townie to latch onto and defend, he had no choice but to choose between his scummates and run with it.

im not saying we need a mass claim day today but i am probably going to kill someone who hasnt claimed tonight

Mike @ 29/10/2018 12:27

Thisisbad @ 29/10/2018 12:24 I haven't claimed anything. And for some of you talking bout bad reads and wrong side of anything tyou seem to think we've been lynching scum left and right. I missed the havo lynch cause i voted mittens. If mittens flips town that's on me. But let's not act like this town had its shit together all game So we've been wrongly assuming you were mason with Nofo?

I didn't say that i said i didn't claim. And i didn't. I still don't know why it became an issue but since you and timmah wanted it out there but yes i was a "mason" with nofo.

I use the term loosely because he had one post day one, and 2 posts night 1 complaining his vote didn't count. Then he gave up. Ive still made the forum a treat - hope you enjoy.

Shadow @ 29/10/2018 10:41

We also have two more masons here undetected that will obviously be trustworthy town if it ever comes to light.

How do you know there are 3 masons? I didn't see anything in Nofo's flip that said there were 3.