I am open to lynching Wikey too though.

Lynches:

Wikey: Curtis, Rito (1/7)
Dylan: Rito, Kiwi (2/7)

Over twelve hours remaining.

Guess I was wrong on Malion!

Dylan brings up a good point about Jeff possibly being a cult leader.
Loads of people keep mentioning "but he could be the sk / third party" - pretty much everyone can be third party :P


Curtis - Doing most of the talking, leading the discussion. Would be pretty bad if he was anti town. Im thinking either town or third party.

Drr - Would have been the worst scumbuddie ever defending grim. Guess I have less suspicion of her now. Probably town or third party.

Dylan - Brings up good points. Not sure about him.

Justin - Did very much like the idea of lynching Greenday from day 1. Im thinking town or third party

Kiwi - I have some suspicion of him. Not sure.

Korr - Town

Leaffan20 - Im thinking Jeff is telling the truth about the BP story. I doubt hes a cult leader and scum. MAYBE SK but with so few kills im starting to doubt there is one.

LSFIssue - Who? Havnt really seen this guy. Rob said he was town which makes him fishy.

Natalie - No one has talked about Natalie a lot. I get that "trying to look innocent" vibe from her posts. Possibly scum

Rito - Im thinking idiot and town.

Shawn - Not sure about this guy. Seems want people to talk more but I dont remember him sharing any of his views about the game. Not sure

Wikey - Curtis brings up good points, wouldnt be a bad candidate for a lynch.

As it stands for me

Town:
Korr

Very likely town:
Curtis
DR
Rito
Jeff
Justin

Not sure:
Dylan
Kiwi

Targets:
LFISSUE
Natalie
Shawn
Wikey

Curtis @ 20/2/2013 18:41

Also there was no SK or Vigilante kill tonight, just like night one. Rob was the mafia kill and Grim died due to Rob's role. Grim was the mafia roleblocker but since she died, she couldn't have blocked the SK or Vig. It wouldn't have gone through. If there's a town roleblocker then maybe they hit the right person

Just remembered that you said this yesterday (day 3)

Quote

UNLESS we think a Rito lynch is a better idea. Vernon just texted me and told me he'll be without internet for a few days. He told me because I'm working on something for him This makes him even more useless

Wondering if that could be the connection to no SK kill last night?

Nah, I think if Vernon is around enough to text curtis and spam it up in here today he was probably around enough to submit a kill or even submit it early. Unless someone really inactive like LSF is the SK and just not submitting, my bet is on the second kill night 2 being a vigilante or someone of some allignment's jack of all trades going off. Frequently vigs can't kill every night, only every other. Two nights with only one kill and so far no strong, solid evidence of blocking or bussing or the like.

On the other hand, the mafia had a doctor. That implies a need for a doctor. Which implies that their faction is at a significant enough risk during the night phases to require added protection to balance it out.

I'm not really sure what the answer is I guess. Its possible the SK if there is one is purposefully withholding their attacks. But there seems to be no logical reason for them to do this either.

I dunno, SK is a very very common role to the point where its absense is surprising, but there is no rule that says one has to be there.

I keep going back and forth on it

1 Members Posting: Tom Brady

Goddamnit wikey I was literally going to go to sleep right now

I'm going to sleep anyway. The muscles that control my eyelids have the final say.

Curtis

lol actually, now that I'm looking through Wikey's posts it's pretty interesting

That makes a nice change.

Curtis

Wikey also threw out the possible Jeff=Cult leader theory to possibly divert which I also said.

Looking back my theory about Jeff made no sense. I got mixed up thinking he survived his attack on the night there was two attacks. I get important details like that mixed up on a regular basis. He was attacked night 1 and survived. The mafia most likely attacked him, unless they decided not to kill. That is the only way Jeff could be a cult leader, and those odds are very small. Even SK is unlikely given that there has only been one night with multiple attacks. So Jeff is either the don or he is telling the truth.

Curtis

During the me/drrr/grim thing, I think the mafia would've chilled and not commented on Grim. They would've just let it simmer out like it was going to and would've focused on the other names that were being tossed around instead

I thought it was silly to bring up Grim out of nowhere when there was more obvious targets, and I still think that now.

Curtis

Tom Brady @ 19/2/2013 8:06 Leaning towards Rito unless some better evidence surfaces against Jeff. I aren't going to cast my vote yet because I am going out for a few hours. When I am back I will read over this properly. Wikey said that during the mess. I would also assume the mafia would most want Jeff gone. The mafia probably thinks that Jeff is lying about his one time BP. They might think he's full BP or the doctor who protected himself night one. That means they wouldn't wanna risk wasting an attack on him again, they'd wanna make sure he was lynched Wikey comes on right after that last post and says this: Tom Brady @ 19/2/2013 13:27 If we lynch Jeff and he is town we know what we are losing a bulletproof townie, but potentially ousting the SK or Godfather. If we lynch Rito and he flips town, we have no idea what we are losing. The evidence against him isn't as strong anyway. The odds are in favor of Jeff been scum. ##Lynch Jeff Suddenly switches from wanting Rito to wanting Jeff, and lynches him. He's saying if we lose Jeff it's no big deal because we know we're losing a BP townie, which is weird. The odds were always slightly higher that Jeff was one time BP/full BP/Doctor, not Don or SK. Then Wikey said that it was :| if Jeff was the Doctor and protected himself night one, which I don't think it is really. We're all selfish, anyone would do it He almost fits the mold exactly for the mafia actions I was looking for earlier

I suddenly switched? Slight exaggeration. I was gone a good few hours before I posted again. When I came back I thought about it and went for Jeff instead of Rito. The way I saw it, Rito could have a far more beneficial role, whereas Jeff had admitted his and I decided we would stand to lose less.

I still think it is :| if Jeff protected himself on night one. I would like to think that if I was doctor and had made just one post on day 1, I wouldn't waste a protection on myself. But maybe that is just me!

Wake up Americans. Its a good morning to hunt some scum.

silly Americans sleeping on prime scum hunting time

Ari @ 22/2/2013 3:38

silly Americans sleeping on prime scum hunting time

And people wonder why it took so long to find Osama Bin Laden....

Kiwi @ 21/2/2013 13:48

Ari @ 22/2/2013 3:38 silly Americans sleeping on prime scum hunting time And people wonder why it took so long to find Osama Bin Laden....

If they even found him...........

Ari @ 21/2/2013 9:34

Kiwi @ 21/2/2013 13:48 Ari @ 22/2/2013 3:38 silly Americans sleeping on prime scum hunting time And people wonder why it took so long to find Osama Bin Laden.... If they even found him...........

Of course they did, they have the body to................oh....no..........wait..............yea, nvm.

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 21/2/2013 0:10

Kiwi @ 20/2/2013 23:57 Shawn @ 21/2/2013 18:53 Dylan @ 20/2/2013 18:33 Looool sucks to suck mafia! That just makes you look suspicious, like I think Curtis said yesterday someone coming on and being like ahh man someone from the town died :(. This is basically the same thing. That person (grim) turned out to be Mafia too. That's not an absolute indicator really. I have a hard time basing a lynch on someone reacting to the night's events. Dylan claiming Jeff was "cleared as a cult leader" is worth looking into though. Who exactly cleared him? Also, what's with all the cult talk anyway? This was meant to be a smaller game, so I could imagine the 3rd party being cult rather than SK, and the extra kill on night 2 being a one-shot killing role (like a Jack, mafia or town aligned) or an every-other-night Vig to keep the nightly death rate down... but when did the talk of a cult first crop up?

I'm thinking Dylan threw that "cult" idea around to throw subtle suspicion on me, I'm starting to think he's mafia more and more

Dylan @ 21/2/2013 1:47

Sorry for the delay I just got back from a bastketball game, I'm back. I felt like Jeff throwing Mal under the bus as the cult leader as if he was attacked because he tried to recruit. I just feel like he would of thrown someone else under the bus, someone he knew that was of the mafia variety. Also Korr visited me this round. It came out as "Good Day Human Ally" It also said that Korr is Town. Not sure how legit that is though.

Still doesn't clear you as human, he could contact anyone really