vladykins @ 18/1/2018 6:21

DS <3=2>1 @ 17/1/2018 22:16 It's okay, just wait until I come out with thumbs vs fingers 2: Is cereal a soup? Nope. It's not even a stew. Unless you make your cereal from boiling the milk, in which case you may be on to something. But soup requires boiling something to get the base essence/oils out, whether animal bones, shells from shellfish, or vegetables.

Gazpacho said FU VLADY. There are tons of cold, chilled, uncooked soups out there.

Not sure I buy cereal as a soup, though.

p.s. FU MODS for locking one of the top 5 threads in the history of this forum.

Primate @ 18/1/2018 9:22

Not sure I buy cereal as a soup, though. p.s. FU MODS for locking one of the top 5 threads in the history of this forum.

No. That thread was awful and should have been locked after 1 post.

Primate @ 18/1/2018 9:22

Not sure I buy cereal as a soup, though. p.s. FU MODS for locking one of the top 5 threads in the history of this forum.

You need to explore more sir. That discussion was boring. BRUTALLY BORING

However I dunno who locked it and it shouldn’t be locked. As much as I hate it

Curtis @ 18/1/2018 8:27

Primate @ 18/1/2018 9:22 Not sure I buy cereal as a soup, though. p.s. FU MODS for locking one of the top 5 threads in the history of this forum. You need to explore more sir. That discussion was boring. BRUTALLY BORING However I dunno who locked it and it shouldn’t be locked. As much as I hate it

I have pretty much read everything in here, and it was definitely top 5.

But that may be because vlady is always funny.

Primate @ 18/1/2018 10:26

But that may be because vlady is always funny.

To be fair I stopped reading all posts after page 2

Primate @ 18/1/2018 9:18

vladykins @ 18/1/2018 6:21 DS <3=2>1 @ 17/1/2018 22:16 It's okay, just wait until I come out with thumbs vs fingers 2: Is cereal a soup? Nope. It's not even a stew. Unless you make your cereal from boiling the milk, in which case you may be on to something. But soup requires boiling something to get the base essence/oils out, whether animal bones, shells from shellfish, or vegetables. Gazpacho said FU VLADY. There are tons of cold, chilled, uncooked soups out there.

Incorrect- check out a recipe for gazpacho and the first step:

http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/alton-brown/gazpacho-recipe-1937573

Quote

Fill a 6-quart pot halfway full of water, set over high heat and bring to a boil. Make an X with a paring knife on the bottom of the tomatoes. Drop the tomatoes into the boiling water for 15 seconds, remove and transfer to an ice bath and allow to cool until able to handle, approximately 1 minute. Remove and pat dry. Peel, core and seed the tomatoes. When seeding the tomatoes, place the seeds and pulp into a fine mesh strainer set over a bowl in order to catch the juice. Press as much of the juice through as possible and then add enough bottled tomato juice to bring the total to 1 cup.

Just because it is served cold doesn't mean the base wasn't boiled originally.

Curtis @ 18/1/2018 10:57

Primate @ 18/1/2018 10:26 But that may be because vlady is always funny. To be fair I stopped reading all posts after page 2

I do too.

so far i've successfully dodged the hotdog/sandwich thing and the finger/thumb thing

retired on top after winning the driveway debate

vladykins @ 18/1/2018 10:20

Primate @ 18/1/2018 9:18 vladykins @ 18/1/2018 6:21 DS <3=2>1 @ 17/1/2018 22:16 It's okay, just wait until I come out with thumbs vs fingers 2: Is cereal a soup? Nope. It's not even a stew. Unless you make your cereal from boiling the milk, in which case you may be on to something. But soup requires boiling something to get the base essence/oils out, whether animal bones, shells from shellfish, or vegetables. Gazpacho said FU VLADY. There are tons of cold, chilled, uncooked soups out there. Incorrect- check out a recipe for gazpacho and the first step: http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/alton-brown/gazpacho-recipe-1937573 Quote Fill a 6-quart pot halfway full of water, set over high heat and bring to a boil. Make an X with a paring knife on the bottom of the tomatoes. Drop the tomatoes into the boiling water for 15 seconds, remove and transfer to an ice bath and allow to cool until able to handle, approximately 1 minute. Remove and pat dry. Peel, core and seed the tomatoes. When seeding the tomatoes, place the seeds and pulp into a fine mesh strainer set over a bowl in order to catch the juice. Press as much of the juice through as possible and then add enough bottled tomato juice to bring the total to 1 cup. Just because it is served cold doesn't mean the base wasn't boiled originally.

You can use stewed tomato right out of the can if you refuse to believe that raw gazpacho exists or any gazpacho outside that one recipe. (They do exist, btw).


I will stop here for a quick cereal lesson:
Cereal doesn't grow out of the ground. It is usually a grain or grains that is ground, pressure cooked, reformed, then baked. Your argument dies there. Even whole oats are cooked.

If that's not enough, there are plenty of completely raw soups out there.

Cereal, otoh, is not a soup.

https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1017577-best-gazpacho

Posting this for vlady who has apparently only seen one cookbook in his life. And it's the one that has gazpacho all wrong, since it didn't even have tomatoes originally.

I guess you could call cereal a soup ingredient if you had to, but in cereal and milk, the milk is more like a sauce than a soup base.

Primate @ 18/1/2018 12:04

vladykins @ 18/1/2018 10:20 Primate @ 18/1/2018 9:18 vladykins @ 18/1/2018 6:21 DS <3=2>1 @ 17/1/2018 22:16 It's okay, just wait until I come out with thumbs vs fingers 2: Is cereal a soup? Nope. It's not even a stew. Unless you make your cereal from boiling the milk, in which case you may be on to something. But soup requires boiling something to get the base essence/oils out, whether animal bones, shells from shellfish, or vegetables. Gazpacho said FU VLADY. There are tons of cold, chilled, uncooked soups out there. Incorrect- check out a recipe for gazpacho and the first step: http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/alton-brown/gazpacho-recipe-1937573 Quote Fill a 6-quart pot halfway full of water, set over high heat and bring to a boil. Make an X with a paring knife on the bottom of the tomatoes. Drop the tomatoes into the boiling water for 15 seconds, remove and transfer to an ice bath and allow to cool until able to handle, approximately 1 minute. Remove and pat dry. Peel, core and seed the tomatoes. When seeding the tomatoes, place the seeds and pulp into a fine mesh strainer set over a bowl in order to catch the juice. Press as much of the juice through as possible and then add enough bottled tomato juice to bring the total to 1 cup. Just because it is served cold doesn't mean the base wasn't boiled originally. You can use stewed tomato right out of the can if you refuse to believe that raw gazpacho exists or any gazpacho outside that one recipe. (They do exist, btw). I will stop here for a quick cereal lesson: Cereal doesn't grow out of the ground. It is usually a grain or grains that is ground, pressure cooked, reformed, then baked. Your argument dies there. Even whole oats are cooked. If that's not enough, there are plenty of completely raw soups out there. Cereal, otoh, is not a soup.

Somebody boiled those tomatoes, even if you didn't. That's the equivalent of saying "You can use broth right out of the can!"- somebody still boiled some bones and/or meat for it to get there.

The primary definition of soup is:

"a liquid dish, typically made by boiling meat, fish, or vegetables, etc., in stock or water."

The secondary definition is:

"a substance or mixture perceived to resemble soup in appearance or consistency."

Gazpacho that is raw will likely fall under the second, but nobody is really going to say that breakfast cereal looks like soup except DS, and he thinks he only has eight fingers.

Primate @ 18/1/2018 12:08

https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1017577-best-gazpacho Posting this for vlady who has apparently only seen one cookbook in his life. And it's the one that has gazpacho all wrong, since it didn't even have tomatoes originally.

You hating on Alton Brown?