Ahoda must certainly be scum with his list.

By the way, good job Buffy!

Herm @ 16/11/2017 4:06

Ahoda must certainly be scum with his list.

I wouldn't be surprised. I always write him off but the fact he is tunneling on me (which I think is silly course) makes me think he could be scum.

*silly of course

So I have been thinking, seeing as we don't seem to have a SK, maybe the Mafia is like more buffed up than usual.

2 third party and 8 mafia maybe? So far 3 has flipped, 4 if Sock was scum.

Herm @ 16/11/2017 4:13

So I have been thinking, seeing as we don't seem to have a SK, maybe the Mafia is like more buffed up than usual.

I can assure you the Mafia is not "buffed up!" Hmmmph!

Did anyone post a night kill list? Also a Spin night list lol? I forgot why he said he didn't get a result on Night 3.

I made an executive decision to edit the opening flavor post to add in the hidden text for Timmah's role.

Ahoda @ 16/11/2017 1:48

##lynch jj

Just when I started to be convinced you were town. How does lynching JJ have priority over 3/4 (?) mafia out there? It's not like they aren't pretty obvious, either.

JJ @ 16/11/2017 3:45

btw I told Josh to give that doll to Mittens, damn you, Josh!

This was initially a joke post (although I am mad about it Josh!) but really, giving the doll back to me seems like a scum move. If he had given it to someone who was likely to be killed, that could've proven my role. Scum would not want that to happen.

Edge @ 16/11/2017 4:17

I made an executive decision to edit the opening flavor post to add in the hidden text for Timmah's role.

Yay, now I'm eating my pie.

Ugh, inb4 Ahoda makes a dumb post now.

JohnnyDollar @ 16/11/2017 2:47

Classic scumittens. You always seem scum because you are. Dadd looks to be town to me. Herm, cherry and peach are not even remotely the same. Not sure why you'd lie about that tho so maybe it was a mistake. Don't think you'd have anything to gain, but still a little sus. Did Zach visit someone else who died? I had him pegged for town, but is there a chance of some hidden text where there is a chance he kills someone? Is that a thing? Where is Spin? With RB dead, I suspect we will have some news.

Hello scum

TIB, Ahoda, Josh and Johnny Dollar final four mafia?

Alright so. Here are my thoughts.

Notes/Claims so far

Leaning Town
1. Seb - fantastic, handsome, sexy boy. Obvious town

3. Dadd - Claimed Odd Night Vig. I buy it for now

6. Timmah - Claimed Pie giver. Buying it for now. Seems town.

8. Jamie - Softclaimed some sort of redirecting role. Lean town on him.

15. Spin - lol Insane Cop tbh

16. Ben - HOLLA HOLLA HOLLA. Has to be Town.

18. Patrick - Apparently DS softclaimed that he and Patrick are Masons.

19. Brian - Town Inventor.

24. Darren Sanders - See Patrick.

26. Zach - Seems like a clumsy type of Town role.

That's 9 people. One 3p claim so far.

4. Buffy - Claimed 3p Voodoo Girl. I buy it.

That leaves us with 8 people.

We started with 30 total. A conservative guess for the number of Mafia players at the start would be a minimum of 8 to a max of 10.
3 Mafia players have flipped so far. We're looking for anywhere between 5 to 7 Mafia still left. Maybe 1 or 2 more 3p roles.

Of the 8 people left -

5. Josh - Claimed Princess. Ehhhhh. Shaky.

10. Herm - I have gotten good warm and fuzzy feelings from Herm all game but now I'm questioning it.

12. Lamps - I've felt good about him on D3 and D4 but need to revisit it. Has softclaimed some sort of visiting role.

14. TIB - Good vibes from him. His reads have been scary good. Lean town for now but unsure.

22. Ahoda - Has given good vibes apart from tunneling on me for a bit.

25. Johnny Dollar - Unsure about him. Has TRIED to appear town but I'm not buying it.

27. Mittens - Has seemed pretty scummy but IDK how much of that is because people just assume him to be scum?

29. Chris - Has done literally nothing either to help or hurt town.

30. Vic - I've started doubting his claim and think he can be GF still.

Basically what I'm trying to say is, it's a numbers game. Of this group of 8 that includes

Josh
Herm
Lamps
TIB
Ahoda
J$
Chris
Vic

IMO there are more scum than town. And of those 8, Chris would be the first person I'd suspect of being Mafa who hasn't had to do anything so far because he's been able to stay UTR.

Yes I am aware that from other's point of view, I can be added to this list of unknowns. But as I have mentioned repeatedly I have zero problems claiming and the stuff I've said between yesterday and today is a pretty good hint towards what my role is.

I'm also aware that not everyone on the list of 9 Townies that I've mentioned will agree that the others are town. This is subjective of course and it's what I'm personally leaning towards.

tl;dr my suspicions of Chris is based not on evidence against him but more so process of elimination based on information given out by others.