itsbrianyay @ 5/3/2017 23:19

Okay, yesterday's final tally should be updated?

Brian, you are TRULY the best!

Zersch @ 5/3/2017 23:22

Buffy @ 5/3/2017 23:18 Zersch @ 5/3/2017 23:15 Every time I see the tongue emoji I remember that one mafia game where someone paid tribute to Christian's love for that emoji by having a death flavor where his tongue strangled someone to death. Do you also remember when you were SoA Big Bad? Sorry, unrelated. (: Of course, the game we should have never won but did.

No, we should have! And we were awesome!! Still loving Rose's death flavor song.

So Ahoda's love obviously killed Lamps, with his heart bursting from his chest.
Dylan's role being hidden seems like it could have been the mafia cleaning up after the kill.
So Merc either killed Ahoda or im317.
That's my guess.

Buffy @ 5/3/2017 23:27

Zersch @ 5/3/2017 23:22 Buffy @ 5/3/2017 23:18 Zersch @ 5/3/2017 23:15 Every time I see the tongue emoji I remember that one mafia game where someone paid tribute to Christian's love for that emoji by having a death flavor where his tongue strangled someone to death. Do you also remember when you were SoA Big Bad? Sorry, unrelated. (: Of course, the game we should have never won but did. No, we should have! And we were awesome!! Still loving Rose's death flavor song.

Oh don't get me wrong, you all killed it.

I was just thinking about the Vern SK/Doctor thing that should have scattered the house of cards everywhere.

Primate @ 5/3/2017 23:25

My hints weren't huge, looking back, but I did try to steer you guys away from vlady.

Do you have info as to why Vlady is town?

If Merc is Vig, no way he would've killed 317.

Thinking we have a Third Party killer to go along with Vig and Mafia

Christian @ 5/3/2017 22:21

jamie ♂ @ 5/3/2017 23:13 Primate @ 5/3/2017 23:10 So in the name of not focusing on vlady, what do you make of there being 2 Cliffords and the note attached to timmah's death? what are u talking about 2 cliffords? ahoda was cliffords owner and timmah was clifford himself? Probably meant 2 from Clifford? Be more specific, Primate!

Yeah I got confused. I thought they were both clifford, but what do you guys make of the hidden text from his role.


What about the passive part of his role where his alignment could change. Seems sort of likevtraitor role element.

Zersch @ 5/3/2017 23:30

No, we should have! And we were awesome!! Still loving Rose's death flavor song.

Oh don't get me wrong, you all killed it.

I was just thinking about the Vern SK/Doctor thing that should have scattered the house of cards everywhere.[/QUOTE]


Vern was so bad he was good! Okay, stopping now.

For the record JJ, I will always push for inactives to go on day 1, for three reasons (unless there are trolls in the game, in which case they take priority).

1. Inactive players make the game boring.

2. They are pretty toxic to town. Allowing them to make it deep into the game gives scum a lot more control over end game lynch trains. They often end up getting lynched later on in the game anyways and I'd rather waste the lynch on them when we don't have any relevent information to go on.

3. Being an inactive player doesn't really indicate to me whether they are town or scum. I've voted inactives day 1 and hit scum plenty of times. Just because sometimes you hit town doesn't mean it isn't the play that makes the most sense.

That's fine, Badger, but Christian pointed out what he was probably claiming (and he was right) and that's a townie.

You also advocated for townie DS to be lynched D2 which I agreed with so not faulting you there. It cleared up a lot.

And you were part of the push for Nofo D3 which I disagreed with. I get it I just disagreed.

I'm just saying we haven't had a mafia flip until today and that was a night kill and even though you have seemed townie you haven't ever advocated for a mafia kill. No one else has, either that we know of. I'm just saying, you aren't town to me yet.

Vic @ 5/3/2017 23:25

I agree with most of this. I think Merc is town, but I agree about there not being any traditional roles so far. Claiming Vig on D2 is risky as hell if he's not actually that so I tend to believe him. Also, Herm wasn't posting Arthur pictures.

You are right about Herm not posting those pics, it was Maddie. Herm made a joke about Arthur being kinky and it stuck out in my mind.

And with regards to Merc, I do agree that claiming vig is incredibly risky. But he was also 'outed' by DS as visiting a dead person, so it might have been a gut reaction to admit it so he'd look less scummy. IDK, I'm a little up in the air on him and would like to hear from him today.

Primate @ 5/3/2017 23:32

Christian @ 5/3/2017 22:21 jamie ♂ @ 5/3/2017 23:13 Primate @ 5/3/2017 23:10 So in the name of not focusing on vlady, what do you make of there being 2 Cliffords and the note attached to timmah's death? what are u talking about 2 cliffords? ahoda was cliffords owner and timmah was clifford himself? Probably meant 2 from Clifford? Be more specific, Primate! Yeah I got confused. I thought they were both clifford, but what do you guys make of the hidden text from his role. What about the passive part of his role where his alignment could change. Seems sort of likevtraitor role element.

What do you mean, what do we think? Timmah could have changed alignment if he had visited anyone from the show Clifford (ie. Ahoda). I think it's pretty obvious. And like I've said before, I think that's why Jamie keeps being mentioned as Town at the start and end of days, because alignments can change.

The Ghostwriter advocated for a Mafia kill by calling Ahoda sketch yesterday.

The mysterious disembodied stranger is the only hero we have.

Also, for what's it's worth. Ahoda voted to lynch Vic yesterday. It seemed like a joke lynch, but something to keep in mind.

And there may just be something to the Herm/Arthur thing, if Ahoda actually did slip up.

Yeah the Timmah alignment thing was discussed more than a few times yesterday. In fact it was what lead to that horribly rude time I called you Susmate. You were FOSing me because I was discussing the flavor, that there had to be a scum Clifford character.