Brian showed up only four minutes after I lynched him to get him to talk. I assume it'd take more than four minutes to write that whole post so I think we're dealing with some Beetlejuice kind of magic lynch thing. Lynch and he shall appear!

Lurking is a scummy word to use Timmah. In my head Lurking is when you check the game thread often but don't post. Not participating would be the definition of not logging in but maybe once a day.

On my phone. I'm about to get on my computer and clear some shit up TIMMAH

okay so this is weird.

day 3:

Wikey @ 15/1/2016 19:09

I know it's rare, but there might not be a vig in the game. We may indeed be dealing with a Mafia / SK setup.

Primate @ 15/1/2016 19:09

Wikey @ 15/1/2016 17:06 First things first, why the hell did that lynch train on me get as far as it did? I posted to explain that I wasn't going to be around, and some of you saw fit to start a train on me. Not cool. I normally wouldn't be suspicious of stuff like that, but the fact that I went to the trouble to say I wasn't going to be around, only to get lynched for 'lurking' strikes me as suspicious. Anyway, it would appear that one of the killing factions was blocked Night 1, given that there was two kills last night and only one Night 1. Not sure who to attribute last nights kills to if we believe there is a vig in the game. Neither Canuck nor Rose struck me as vig targets. That said, I might have missed something suspicious that either of them said yesterday whilst skimming through it. A backup vig died, so it would be pretty odd if there wasn't a vig of some kind.

^ 4 people liked this post: Dadd, Ben, Curtis, Timmah

------------

Day 4:

Curtis @ 17/1/2016 21:58

I'm thinking SK over Vig. The Vig targets are kinda shitty

JC @ 17/1/2016 21:59

Curtis @ 17/1/2016 19:58 I'm thinking SK over Vig. The Vig targets are kinda shitty So, you don't believe we have a Vig, even though we already had a player killed with the role Backup Vig?

....?

it would be explainable if curtis had missed this exchange on day 3, but he hadn't and had clearly liked the post pointing it out.

just weird shit

sorry, that could've been formatted way better, my bad

Alright so if you want to look at D2 and base your lynch off of that then I agree there is a lot of information to be found on that day. HOWEVER. You are looking in the wrong spot my friend. Let's start with my Canuck train.

Anyone who knows me knows I don't read the flavor (: I just never do and I probably should start! Because in my defense that day did not end 24 hours after it started like it was supposed to and I thought I had enough time to start a train since AT THE TIME the only train was Titan and I was fully against lynching him if you recall. Canuck was a lurker if I have ever seen one so I was like maybe this could be a good idea. I realized I was wrong with how much time was left and no way a train could start. Not because I was "called out."

THEN I asked which of Wikey and Miko had more votes to avoid a tie from happening! My vote was still relatively early in the process so a lot of last minute voters hadn't voted yet. At the time I voted, people were voting Wikey/Miko both because they weren't around or contributing. Miko hadn't come in and lynched Titan yet so at the time of my vote there was really no specific reason that people thought he was scummy moreso than someone like Wikey, both were being lynched for inactivity. I was on my phone and slow to check, the day ended and yada yada Titan gets lynched.

So if you want to go by D2 that's fine my friend but you're barking up the wrong tree. Why don't you look at all of my other posts too? I think it's pretty clear I've been one of the more helpful townies in this game. I was also all over Dadd's shit from the moment D3 started before he got any heat. So much to the point that he made posts showing how frustrated he was that I wouldn't leave him alone.

If the reason you think I am scum if from the end of D2 then you are grasping at straws and are just frustrated that I do not agree with you on JC being scum (which I said in my long post last night that I wouldn't be surprised if he was scum so idk if you saw that or what) but I think there are much better choices than myself.

Ya I forgot about backup in the moment and felt silly since I remembered thinking someone else was a dummy for doing the same thing a previous day

How embarrassing Brian why did you have to shine your light onto that???

I'm not even sure how that could possibly be spun into me being scum. What was my master plan in that scenario? Hope everyone else forgot and will now believe there's and SK over a Vig?

If we lynch Herm and he is telling the truth, keep in mind that we don't just lose the Miller. We lose a town member with protection from an attack. I think we should be keeping that in mind!

Bryce's persistent softclaiming is odd. He insists he knows who the vig is, and asks if he should divulge this along with his role. Obviously, the answer to that was going to be no. The vig should stay hidden.

But claiming and telling us who the vig is aren't one and the same. He can claim his role without giving anybody's identity away, surely?

HEY TIMMAH, these are all posts I made D3 regarding Dadd before he even had a lot of heat on him. So like I said if you're gonna say I'm scum then you gotta read more than just a 15 minute stretch of posts


15th Jan 2016 6:40 PM
I don't think it was people thinking he was scum. Titan had a lot of votes on him throughout the entire day and a lot of the votes that were on him when the day ended were people that just hadn't been back online to change them. I think the only two people to add votes onto Titan toward the end were Miko and Dadd and I am curious why they decided to do that.


16th Jan 2016 1:53 AM
I'm also still curious why Dadd lynched Titan last minute yesterday too. Did he ever say why and I just missed it?


16th Jan 2016 3:35 AM
Yeah I was around for it. I've been waiting for Dadd to explain since this day started. That didn't make sense to me at all. And I forgot about the vote thief, that's a great point.

I agree with Timmah. I think JC should just kill Miko. If we lynch him then it allows scum to pile on the train. If we pick another target like Dadd and he does end up being scum, it would be telling if some people stepped in and tried to save him after just losing Miko, assuming they are both town.

I'd still like to hear from Dadd though.


16th Jan 2016 10:06 AM
I'm not tunneling Dadd, I haven't even lynched you. I was just wondering why you put that lynch there at the very end. Was that disadvantage just for yesterday or throughout the entire game?


16th Jan 2016 10:44 AM
We'll get more info from a Miko lynch in my opinion. If he flips scum we'll have a good read on Dadd being scum as well and we can go back and look at the train on Miko yesterday for information. Anyone who jumped on when it seemed like he was the lynch or jumped off at the last minute to save him can be looked at too. Depending on the circumstances yesterday (because it was a clusterfuck and I forget exactly what happened) we can look at the train and determine a lot more than if we just lynch JC.

That was formatted very poorly I'm sorry

i was thinking about the Bryce/Merc thing a little and im wondering if Dadd's bus ability might explain why Bryce thought no active ability Merc was scum.

yeah curt i'm not sure if it's alignment indicative, it just struck me as odd. also any chance to make you look like the dummy you are is a chance i'm going to take!!!

not done with D4 yet but i'm feeling better about JC, but weird about angi. explain more later

I also still think Jay is the best call today. None of his posts helped his case imo

actually nvm angi seems okay