[QUOTE=Ari@15/4/2014 14:39
Angi - lynched Greenday. lynched Curtis. lynched Malion. Bandwagony votes.
.[/QUOTE]



The only vote I bandwagoned on was Mal's. Go check your facts.

guys stop talking about character specifics such as what characters are evil. Clearly you can't claim anyone so there's no point.

Angi @ 15/4/2014 16:09

Ari @ 15/4/2014 14:39 Angi - lynched Greenday. lynched Curtis. lynched Malion. Bandwagony votes. . The only vote I bandwagoned on was Mal's. Go check your facts.

Yep, now that I've taken a look, Angi started the Greenday and Curtis wagons. Which, y'know, still isn't great, given that I feel like both of them are town.

Also Tricks, I think Herm only has 3 votes right now but there are also other people who have mentioned possibly voting him and at the time I said his "train" seemed to be growing fast, it's party lynches but partly FOS's and no one else was getting votes at the time. I think after your vote there were about 4 or 5 people who said Herm looked like a good lynch then he got more votes/FOS's after that. Also, Ari's statement about that usually never happening with scum with no defense makes a lot of sense to me.

I think these are the votes today:

Herm: Tricks, Angi, Vernon
Curtis: Ahoda
Vernon: Perry
Brian: Ari, Buffy
Greenday: Shawn

Also, Ahoda's vote is still on Curtis? That's strange since he did it not knowing all the facts and still didn't change it after.

okay, i gotta go!

i can't address everything that's been asked, sorry. gotta go to union station woooo!

IF there is wifi on the bus, i might be able to make some posts, but my laptop's keyboard (specifically keys e-o on the top row) is broken so i use a USB on that rests on top, and that will be in my bug under the bus so my posts w¡ll l00k l¡k3 +h¡s.

##lynch herm

Tricks @ 15/4/2014 17:14

Angi @ 15/4/2014 16:09 The only vote I bandwagoned on was Mal's. Go check your facts. Yep, now that I've taken a look, Angi started the Greenday and Curtis wagons. Which, y'know, still isn't great, given that I feel like both of them are town.

I did say yesterday that I changed my mind on Greenday. JJ is right, he usually gets overly defensive when he's scum and FOSd, so unless he's learned to chill, I think he's town.

I guess it's not even saying I changed my mind....there was a comment Day 1 about how he only talks when he's being lynched so I lynched him to get him talking.

I still stand by my lynch on Curtis last day though. If he turns out to be town, he still sent out some super scummy vibes with that move.

Just off the top of my head, the reads I'm getting on people right now:

town vibes
Ahoda
Perry
Tricks

maybe town
Shadow - hard to get a read on him since this is the first (full) mafia I've played with him. He's put forward some good thoughts though
itsbrianyay - not really seeing the suspicion on him atm
Herm - he's doing some extremely scummy things, but I dunno, I just don't feel like if he was scum he'd be putting himself out there as much as he is
Cash Money
Curtis

on the fence
Greenday - his claim is weird to me. It sounds like a plausible role, but I think it's pretty weird that there'd be two recruiting roles in this game
drr - Perry's claim doesn't prove anything about her alignment, and I've been back and forth on her since D2. And the Hot Cocoa post is making me WONDER
Patrick - has been incredibly lurky and only just now started contributing. I'm pretty sure he always plays like this but still, it's pretty scummy
Buffy - I'm not that sold on her at all, but she's being incredibly defensive about every accusation thrown her way
Ari
Shawn

scum?
g0 - almost all of their posts have seemed like lurking scum to me. What I really don't like is how he's stayed out of lynching anyone and keeps bringing that up as a reason for why he's NOT scum which...is pretty bullshit! It's possible it's just inexperience, which is the only reason I'm not fully convinced
Vernon - like I said, it's entirely based on metagaming, which is the reason I'm not lynching him for it yet. But he does seem like his scum self to me

no idea
Angi
Dylan - I honestly don't remember seeing a post from him (:
Wikey

I agree with you on Tricks, Perry and definitely Vernon. And possibly Patrick

Greenday, I'd say more town. Buffy, she's always defensive (we all are), I don't get scum vibes from her.

Dyl's ded

Dylan is dead.

lol I should have waited because I just went looking for Dylan posts lmfao

I think the Vernon theory is something to consider. I noticed him being pretty calm but didn't think much of it till I read that post on the previous page.

Right now is just a gamble on who to lynch and we'll only find out anything substantial if the person on the brink of lynch role claims.

So I'll just put my lynch vote on

##Lynch Ari

I'm gonna feel pretty dumb if I eventually see that he is Town when and if he gets lynched, but his posts have just gave me bad vibes. I didn't really notice him at all which was the reason I first suspected him, and then he had a really poor reason for lynching Curtis. As I said before I was positive that someone on the lynch Curtis train was mafia, and that turned out to be Hot Cocoa... but it's not FAR FETCH'd for more Curtis lynchers to be questioned

The one thing that's making me legitimately uneasy about my vote for Herm is Vernon. I've had a moderately scummy read on him, especially after his list of suspects with no actual reasoning (and refusal to provide it on request), so hearing that you think this is his scum meta gives me a definite pause.