Tricks @ 12/4/2014 23:52

Buffy @ 12/4/2014 22:48 Tricks @ 12/4/2014 23:45 Actually, I doublechecked and Buffy made the post I was talking about (asking Rose to give her result). I saw a post that annoyed me and assumed it came from you, my bad. Well, she's claiming a role and could be scum. I think we should be questioning that role. If she's town and she had a result of someone having a power role, we would have just told the mafia who to kill. That being said, if she's lynched and flips scum, I'm looking at Patrick.

It is a risk, yes, but I think her claim should be questioned instead of just lynching her without trying to figure out if she's telling the truth.

Shadow @ 12/4/2014 22:53

so the theory is mafia doc protected rose? but from who? vigilante role? and if she is BP and mafia in general, someone from the town had to have tried to kill her

No, it means that the kill on Dylan would have killed her too; if he protected someone and he was the kill target, both would die.

WHY ARE THERE SO MANY PAGES


I AM TOO DRUNK FOR THIS

Shadow @ 12/4/2014 23:53

so the theory is mafia doc protected rose? but from who? vigilante role? and if she is BP and mafia in general, someone from the town had to have tried to kill her

Rose got attacked because got Dylan got attacked while he was babysitting her

Lots of drunk people this game!

Dylan was targeted.....so the person he chose to babysit should have died too. Which is either Matt or Rose

Shadow @ 12/4/2014 23:57

Dylan was targeted.....so the person he chose to babysit should have died too. Which is either Matt or Rose

We're pretty positive it's Rose

Buffy @ 12/4/2014 22:54

Tricks @ 12/4/2014 23:52 If she's town and she had a result of someone having a power role, we would have just told the mafia who to kill. It is a risk, yes, but I think her claim should be questioned instead of just lynching her without trying to figure out if she's telling the truth.

Agree to disagree, then. It's not a scumtell, it's just something that annoyed me.

and a roleblocker could not prevent Drr's death so i see the hoopla!

Why are there so many drunk people?

Boc @ 12/4/2014 23:54

Buffy @ 12/4/2014 23:51 Why Can't I Hold All These Greens @ 12/4/2014 23:49 Buffy @ 12/4/2014 23:47 Tim @ 12/4/2014 23:46 Buffy @ 12/4/2014 23:45 Boc @ 12/4/2014 23:39 Tim @ 12/4/2014 23:04 You know what makes no sense to me? Matt was regarded as suspicious, in league with Buffy even, yet the mafia killed him. Why kill someone who's a good scapegoat? Unless it was to throw off suspicion of Buffy because, hey, if Matt was buddies with Buffy, why would they kill him? I think Matt is much more likely to be killed by a vig/SK since he was incredibly scummy yesterday. But this isn't a terrible thought He obviously was not incredibly scummy since he was not scum. I said it yesterday and I'll say it again today. He obviously thought the votes on me were stupid. Look at them. They were jokes. And just the fact that your first post is to ignore Drrr surviving an attack and just agreeing I must be scum because Matt was killed is highly suspicious. Also, you led the train on Jordan last round. Thanks for disabling our doctor. Show me where I lynched Jordan. Show me. I never took my lynch off of Greenday. I wasn't talking to you. You said Greenday was a good lynch but you never took your vote off me. To be fair, you said I wasn't a good lynch and then kept your vote on me. I never said you weren't a good lynch. I said I would switch to a few other people, none of whom had any support. I said I didn't want to lynch the new person who hadn't even had a chance to play. I am perfectly fine with lynching based on past behavior or not helping since it was Day 1 and that included you. We had no such history with Jordan and I thought she should have a chance. I don't really get this. The lynch on Greenday was to get him to emerge from his cocoon, which he did. I think he had one of the higher post counts on D1

I admit I was meta-gaming but I don't apologize for it. I just thought it was weird that, even though everyone knew Jordan didn't know the game had started and was going to post when she got home people still lynched her. I would hate to be a new person and get lynched Day 1 without even knowing the game had started.

because it's saturday night?

We should look at the Jordan train according to Buffy.

itsbrianyay @ 13/4/2014 0:00

because it's saturday night?

And that means...?

Tim @ 13/4/2014 0:00

We should look at the Jordan train according to Buffy.

Thank goodness we have you here to tell us what others are thinking