Kiwi @ 2/1/2014 18:15

Simplton @ 3/1/2014 13:14 Kiwi @ 2/1/2014 18:13 Simplton @ 3/1/2014 13:09 Kiwi @ 2/1/2014 18:06 Simplton @ 3/1/2014 13:04 Kiwi @ 2/1/2014 18:03 Shadow I am just messing with you/putting you under pressure. Your reaction seems a little OTT tbh. Simpleton, Nofo and Colby could all be good targets in my mind. May I ask why? Your posts just kinda seem scummy. The "this is a protown post" was kinda weird/forced to me. The fact 3 town were all on your train and that was it. Also I wonder if im317's vote not counting was a host mistake. Host? If not it must be a role.... And why did you offer yourself up as a target last day? I knew I wasn't a super important role and there were votes on me. So I was saying I didn't mind getting lynched if that was what town believed to be the best direction. As well as gathering more information. If you are town, getting lynched isn't really useful at all, regardless of your role. It seems such a strange thing to do to me. Never know what happens after someone gets lynched. ;) just keep that in mind. Are you town?

Hell yeah! 100 like a fastball.

Not really sure about this Rose lynch. If she comes on, she can be really useful if town.

Kiwi @ 2/1/2014 19:07

Rose's inactivity is really weird. She does that a lot when scum #metagamingftw

She also does that when she isn't home all day.

Now lets see if Rose will post something good.

Rose you have an hour and a half to unlynch you...ready....set...go!

Oops to convince me to unlynch you*

Simplton @ 2/1/2014 18:50

Vic @ 2/1/2014 17:40 Samm @ 2/1/2014 18:39 ##Lynch Vic because I'm a whiney emotional baby and that lynch was dUMB and made just for the sake of making a lynch. So I'm doing the same bIATCH. The guy with over 6 years of mafia experience agreed with me though New year. It's now 7 years.

you broke me, i have shuttered in to a spew of orgasmic pleasure.

TBH I always post non-sensical shit, as the worst mafia host there is, I believe this is my human right.

A lot of these lynches I find are absolutely ridiculous and have no value whatever behind their arguments.

A votal would be nice, also I think the ignoring IM lynch vote is just Matt being incompetent, we should all smite him for it.

Rose are you gonna contribute or nah?

I am typing Kiwi.

deaderrose @ 3/1/2014 13:53

I am typing Kiwi.

:D

I'm in Miami right now so I'm not going to be that active for the next couple days, however even if I wasn't on vacation, I have nothing to contribute in the way of information, hence why I only posted once.

deaderrose @ 2/1/2014 18:53

I am typing Kiwi.

I'm excited!

Simplton @ 2/1/2014 19:26

Rose you have an hour and a half to unlynch you...ready....set...go!

Wonderful. Thank you, your Grace.

I've been goofing off because there wasn't a lot to be talking about. Day 1 didn't provide a lot of clues and I tend to step back until there's something for me to say.

ANYWAY, my thoughts:

Greenday's insistence on someone claiming something is very silly! I'll admit we don't have a lot to base anything off of today, but it's day 2, and we have to work with what little we can. Calling for people to oust themselves is lazy at best and scummy at worst. But... honestly I'm inclined to think it's just lazy. The defensive reaction to getting called out on the other hand is a little (: He didn't really defend his position on why he said what he said. Instead he just tried to immediately discredit Ari for pointing it out. He never tried to back up what he was saying, he just shot Ari's credibility down and blamed any suspicion against him on metagaming, when it isn't. Waking up after the first night and harassing people to come forward is something worth looking at. The identity of the person pointing it out doesn't change whether it's shady or not.

Greenday being a latecomer makes things a little (: but I don't think it's worth ignoring.


Shadow seems to be getting a lot of suspicion but I don't really get why! Nothing he's said has seemed scummy or overly defensive to me. Reacting isn't the same as overreacting, and I don't think he did.

Simplton @ 2/1/2014 18:18

Sansa @ 2/1/2014 12:52 Interestingly, everybody who voted for Simplton is dead now. I wonder if that's a coincidence. I really like Rob for this post. It is protown to point out things like this that give us information/something to look at. Just wanted to throw that out there.

I just wanted to point out that I really dislike this Simplton post.

Simplton @ 2/1/2014 19:09

Kiwi @ 2/1/2014 18:06 Simplton @ 3/1/2014 13:04 Kiwi @ 2/1/2014 18:03 Shadow I am just messing with you/putting you under pressure. Your reaction seems a little OTT tbh. Simpleton, Nofo and Colby could all be good targets in my mind. May I ask why? Your posts just kinda seem scummy. The "this is a protown post" was kinda weird/forced to me. The fact 3 town were all on your train and that was it. Also I wonder if im317's vote not counting was a host mistake. Host? If not it must be a role.... And why did you offer yourself up as a target last day? I knew I wasn't a super important role and there were votes on me. So I was saying I didn't mind getting lynched if that was what town believed to be the best direction. As well as gathering more information.

and I also want to point out that this is retarded.

Town doesn't want to kill town. I understand Day 1 is a crapshoot, but offering to throw yourself on your sword for someone who isn't confirmed and is getting lynched Day 1 is ridiculous. I can somewhat understand the logic here. Chances are TLG was never going to flip scum after nearly the entire game turned on him Day 1, but that doesn't cancel out the possibility of third party, or mafia declaring a lost cause and cutting their losses. If you know you are town and you don't know someone else is, you don't try to sacrifice yourself for them. Shitty role or not, you know what you are, and you can fight for your best interests. Trying to get yourself lynched on Day 1 is just destructive and distracting.

I don't think it's scummy, but I expect better from 7 years of mafia experience!

And that's all I have to say right now, honestly. Greenday is probably the person who bothers me the most, but his late arrival makes it a bit of a stretch for him to be scum. HOWEVER, the game was probably balanced before all the late arrivals, and there was a delay between Matt realizing he signed up and formally adding him to the game. That's enough time to recalculate things and decide the game had room for one more scum. I don't think it's so unlikely that it's not worth considering.

So who do you think we should lynch?