| |
Curtis
First Place Dick
  | | Reputation: 1,170 | | Group: | Admin | | Posts: | 79,236 | | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #166: 15th Nov 2015 5:04 PM | |
HEY...I finally continued after all of my annoying issues. I now own THREE copies of S2!!! So annoying
I'm playing S2 on PC but played S1 on Xbox so I don't have my save, which means all of my S1 choices were randomized. That sux. I guess I kinda hope S1 choices don't effect S2 that much now...but at the same time I hope it does because that's cool
Replayed 2x01 so I'm right back to where I was. Made all the same choices except this time I gave the dying dude water, I thought I had done that the first time but I guess not
Gonna get into new territory with 2x02 either tonight or tomorrow | |
| | | |
Curtis
First Place Dick
| | Reputation: 1,170 | | Group: | Admin | | Posts: | 79,236 | | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #167: 21st Nov 2015 12:55 AM | |
|
NEW TERRITORY!!!!!!!!
- Bridge fight was intense. I was worried I'd lose Nick there
- Nick killing Matthew was even more tense. C'MON NICK! I felt bad for him though and kinda stood up for him when I could except for one time which he was pissed at me for. Ohhhhhh well! Nick>>>Ben as far as the group fuck up goes, easily. FUCK Ben!
- Hate Rebecca. Like Alvin enough
- KENNY!!!!!! Figured it was him showing up based on the trailer for this one. It was obvious after his 'death' that he'd be coming back eventually. Glad he did come back tho. I had a great relationship with him throughout S1 and always stayed on his good side so yippee (my s1 save isn't a factor though :( ). I still have the picture of his family but it gave me no prompt to show him. Hopefully later
- One of the hardest choices I've had to make in the game...sitting with Luke or Kenny. WHY WAS THIS SO HARD! I sat there for a full minute and debated internally. Decided to sit with Kenny so I could make talk more about Lee. All I wanna do is talk about Lee
- Liked Walter but MAN was he filled with rage. He started to scare me!! I lied to Walter and then pushed Nick to tell him the truth. Walter saved him later. I had no idea until I read KC's spoiler tag that you could lose Nick there. That would've SUCKED! That's disappointing to know because now I can't help but feel like he'll die soon like Carly anyway :((((. I wonder how relevant they can really make him if he's dead for half the players. What a shame. Although....if you helped Pete instead of Nick, would Nick have died? If so, I wonder how the bridge scene would've played out
- Also didn't know Alvin could die, he's alive in mine. I thought maybe Carlos could die but I wasn't sure
- RIP Walter we hardly knew ye. Ty for saving Nick
Friendship: Took blame for Sarah's photo?
Took blame - 41.5%
Loyalty: Who did you sit with at dinner?
Sat with Kenny - 65.1%
Honesty: Told Walter the truth about Matthew?
Lied about Matthew - 26%
Forgiveness: Nick's fate?
Convinced Walter to forgive Nick - 84.2%
Bravery: Left to find Kenny?
Surrendered - 46%
Sounds like mine wasn't as crazy as KC's or some of the rest of yours (just the Walter death) but it was still great. I also didn't know who Bonnie was so there was no impact there. I had no idea who would make it out of the hostage situation so that entire thing was incredibly tense. One of the best parts about this new cast is that I can't tell who might develop into a central character/ally of mine. First I thought it was Pete but RIP. Now I can't tell if Luke or Nick will sorta be the main one because I keep feeling like either can die at any moment. No one seems off limits to me really |
| |
| | | |
Curtis
First Place Dick
| | Reputation: 1,170 | | Group: | Admin | | Posts: | 79,236 | | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #168: 21st Nov 2015 5:24 PM | |
|
Oh men, what an ending
- Didn't help Sarah with her chores. Getting tired of her SHIT! I don't like to always act one way towards a particular character. Like I'll take Kenny's side most of the time but once in a blue moon I'll tell him to stop yelling or something so that I stay realistic. Same with Sarah. I always calm her down and help her out but sometimes I think it's better to tell her to stfu and treat her like an adult, so I didn't help her out there. Apparently Reggie dies either way. RIP, he was funny. I figured he'd fuck everything up during an escape plan down the road so him dying that early surprised me
- Didn't tell Bonnie about Luke. WHY WOULD I! Didn't seem like a good idea at all and I still didn't really like her at that point. Didn't like or trust her until she said "we leave tonight". Then I was on board with her
- Tried to take the blame for the walkie. I try to own up to mostly everything as Clem and never blame anyone else. I know Clem's gonna survive anyway so why not. I'd hate for someone else to die because of it. POOR KENNY!
- Watched Kenny kill Carver at the risk of the group thinking I'm a sociopath. Maybe they'll just think Clem's got BALLS! I dunno. I didn't wanna miss the death scene though, that would've sucked. Especially since it was so gory and satisfying. Do you miss it completely if you say no? I assume so. I thought Carver would be the antagonist for a bit longer tbh, or throughout all five episodes. He was good
- Cut off Sarita's arm. Ehh, no brainer. I don't really like her yet and don't particularly care what happens to her. I think she'll die at some point anyway to break Kenny down more
The ending was great. Alvin was THE MAN. The shot of him in Carver's chair waiting with the loaded gun was awesome, so were his last words. I felt bad for him and I'm so glad he survived the lodge
I figured Carlos would die before getting to deliver the baby just to make that whole situation hell in the future. That was still unexpected though. I thought Sarah would get the bullet but not him. He died so fast for a relatively important character
The new girl shooting the asshole guards' dick off was great |
| |
| | | |
Curtis
First Place Dick
| | Reputation: 1,170 | | Group: | Admin | | Posts: | 79,236 | | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #169: 22nd Nov 2015 9:11 PM | |
|
Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh shiiiiiiiiiiit
- Bye Sarita. I didn't care that much, I only cared because I knew it'd fuck Kenny up. I wonder what would've happened if I went for the walker instead. I'm sure she would've died and Kenny would find a slightly different reason to blame me
- Nick's dead. FUCK THAT! I hear Luke and Sarah yelling at the trailer park, round the corner, and walker Nick is stuck in the fence so you put him down. I liked Nick a lot and his off screen death felt cheap after you work towards getting Walter to forgive him. This saddens me
- I uhhh...left Sarah behind. The first time they asked me to leave her or talk sense into her it was a no brainer, I tried to talk sense into her. I thought I'd be prompted to give her her glasses since they were in my inventory and that it would somehow help. Then they asked me the same thing a second time. RED FLAGS! I figured it wasn't great to push my luck and in the last millisecond I left her. I thought for sure Jane would die instead of Sarah and Jane>>>Sarah. I was relatively okay with Sarah dying even though her reaching out to me and getting devoured was fucked up. But Clem is a much stronger version of Sarah and I can't imagine she'd live much longer anyway, so I was fine with the game making the point of Clem being way more fit for this world than other people her age are
- Didn't rob Arvo. After the creep with the station wagon, no WAY! That's how Lee ultimately got killed ;_;
- Crawled through the ticket booth. Uhhhh...okay?? Does Mike or Bonnie go instead and get bit by the walker inside or something? What a silly/random choice
- Held the baby. Again, weird major choice
- Didn't shoot Rebecca. I figured all hell would break lose for sure if I did and I couldn't see Rebecca eating the baby if I didn't, not sure they'd have a baby devoured scene really (: . But then ofc all hell breaks lose even if I didn't. I guess the consequence is that they blame Kenny instead of blaming me for whoever doesn't survive
Great cliffhanger, and now I don't have to wait!!!!!!! :)
Worried for my boy Mike. I never once cared for Rebecca honestly. Still not 100% around on Bonnie yet, she's just kinda boring. I'm worried this whole thing will boil down to me choosing between Luke and Kenny since its been that way ever since meeting Kenny. If choosing which table to sit at was that hard for me, possibly choosing which to save will be a nightmare. I sided with Kenny more than Luke in this episode but I generally always side with Kenny anyway to calm him down and make him like me |
| |
| | | |
KC
Shooore
  | | Reputation: 93 | | Group: | Admin | | Posts: | 11,472 | | Joined: | Mar 1, 2013 |
| Post #170: 22nd Nov 2015 9:36 PM | |
|
I was worried about the same thing, but they do both survive if you save Sarah.
Sarah ultimately dies anyway though in much more brutal fashion. You pretty much nailed the point home, she was not cut out for the world and there was nothing we could have done to push her any further. |
| 
|
| | | |
Curtis
First Place Dick
| | Reputation: 1,170 | | Group: | Admin | | Posts: | 79,236 | | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #171: 23rd Nov 2015 11:11 PM | |
|
FINALE TIME YIPPEE/BOO!!!
I'm gonna keep a thread open and post thoughts as I go unlike the last season two ones that I've done. I always forget shit by the time I end up typing those up
- First two lines in previously of: "Killing one in order to save many is part of survival". "I look at Kenny now and he's broken, and broken people get reckless." I see where this is going. I SEE EXACTLY WHERE THIS IS GOING TELLTALE
- I figured Jane would come to save the day but the way it happened was perfect. Then Kenny just caps the guy GO KENNY!
- lol so none of our heroes died? I thought for SURE Mike would at least since he was underdeveloped. I thought his body would crash down in front of me during that cut scene. Kinda meh that none of them did die but oh well. Mike/Luke/Kenny are all wounded so I'm sure one will die because of their wound
"My friend Lee, he was a good man." ;___;
- Kenny's eye OOF! I wish they developed Alvin a bit more because he's getting mentioned post-death a whole lot
- You know what'd be so cool. If Kenny (with his one eye) keeps breaking and eventually becomes THE GOVERNOR from the show/comics. If they took liberties with the story that would be such a great twist
- Mike's hesitation with the baby is always great. Calling them ugly weird little aliens. He might be my favorite new character. RIP in advance
- I'm worried Kenny's gonna run off with the baby or some shit
- BONNIE'S GOT LUKE-FEVER!
- I got the whole group around the fire having a good time CAN'T WAIT FOR IT TO GO TO HELL!
- That's....how Luke dies? I'm shocked they didn't throw in a major Luke or Kenny moment. The shot of him slipping down into the darkness was very sad :( . Every member of the new group is dead now
- FUCK ALVO! He's not sympathetic to me at all. I keep telling Kenny to cool it but that's more for Kenny's sake, not Alvo's. Every shot of him sneering makes me hate him even more
- Kenny: "I wish Lee was here" ;______;
- Mike and Bonnie NO!!!!!! I don't like this ONE BIT! It seems out of character for them to do this and not stay loyal. Take all our food and leave the baby? NO WAY MAN!
- Lee dream sequence......................... I am so happy
- Here's where having to randomize my S1 choices takes me out of it. They talked about Lilly killing Doug and then showed that we still let Lilly come with us. Lilly killed Carley in mind and I left that DOUCHE behind to rot!
I played out the final act without any commentary because I was so wrapped up in it so here's my choices/thoughts:
- Protected the baby ofc. Seems like no repercussions?
- Went out to help Luke
- Did not ask to leave with Mike. FUCK that! C'mon Mike, I had so much faith in you
- Did NOT shoot Kenny. No way. They made it pretty obvious to me that Alvin Jr was actually alive based on Jane saying "You'll see how he is" and shit. SO MANIPULATIVE! She was BAITING him into a deadly fight and into me killing him, I didn't like that at all. She was overall kinda selfish (leaving the group etc), where as Kenny (as broken as he is) is 100% selfless all of the time and I appreciate that way more. I didn't consider shooting him for a second
And thank GOD I didn't, because my ending was so perfect. I loved it. We got Alvin Jr back and found Wellington. The lady at the gate turned us away and then Kenny suddenly begged to let just Clem and Alvin Jr in. I knew right away that that's how the story had to end, it was just too good. Kenny's cries to the lady were heartbreaking, and when she says "They agreed to let the kids in, I tried to get you too but--" and Kenny interrupts her and tearfully yells out thank you....the best. The hardest choice was staying there without him or going back on the road with him, but letting his sacrifice play out felt like the right ending for me. And Lee would've done the same thing :(
Perfect ending and great game. I watched the other endings and am SO glad with the way mind ended up. The AJ/Jane/family one I wasn't into at all. Alone with AJ is eh. Those were the two that had a higher percentage than mine. The story was all about my relationship with Kenny. That's how I played a lot of S1 and that's how I played it here. This ending felt like what the entire story (over both seasons) was leading up to and had the biggest emotional impact on me by far
where's S3 |
| |
| | | |
Patrick
Sole Survivor
 | | Reputation: 63 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 7,435 | | Joined: | Jun 25, 2012 |
| Post #172: 24th Nov 2015 1:02 AM | |
| | |
| | | |
KC
Shooore
| | Reputation: 93 | | Group: | Admin | | Posts: | 11,472 | | Joined: | Mar 1, 2013 |
| Post #173: 24th Nov 2015 4:17 AM | |
|
|
| I left that DOUCHE behind to rot! |
|
Hey FUCK YOU buddy!
|
|
| | | |
Curtis
First Place Dick
| | Reputation: 1,170 | | Group: | Admin | | Posts: | 79,236 | | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #174: 24th Nov 2015 6:40 AM | |
Curtis will remember that. | |
| | | |
Boc
 | | Reputation: 157 | | Group: | Admin | | Posts: | 19,204 | | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #175: 24th Nov 2015 7:36 PM | |
Lilly was the best. Still disappointed I didn't get to run off with her and Clem in S1 |  |
| | | |
Curtis
First Place Dick
| | Reputation: 1,170 | | Group: | Admin | | Posts: | 79,236 | | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #176: 24th Nov 2015 8:09 PM | |
|
| Lilly was the best. Still disappointed I didn't get to run off with her and Clem in S1 |
????? | |
| | | |
Boc
| | Reputation: 157 | | Group: | Admin | | Posts: | 19,204 | | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #177: 25th Nov 2015 12:48 AM | |
o I thought you were talking about Lilly instead of Doug (: | |
| | | |
Dyl
Butt Not Even Visible
 | | Reputation: 80 | | Group: | Moderator | | Posts: | 13,554 | | Joined: | Jun 25, 2012 |
| Post #178: 25th Nov 2015 1:10 AM | |
Doug was the best! | "So, uh, what are we saying here? If we save LA from a nuclear bomb, then you and I can get together for dinner and a movie?"
|
| | | |
Shadow
Mr. Cat
 | | Reputation: 80 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 8,742 | | Joined: | Sep 16, 2013 |
| Post #179: 19th Feb 2016 1:52 PM | |
Finished
|
| I'm so sad I had to shoot Kenny |
| |
| | | |
Shadow
Mr. Cat
| | Reputation: 80 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 8,742 | | Joined: | Sep 16, 2013 |
| Post #180: 19th Feb 2016 2:01 PM | |
moar
|
I didn't appreciate Bonnie and Mike being out of character and abandoning the group. Bonnie would go from loving me to giving me the COLDEST of shoulders. Fucking bitch. I hated that little arvo guy and wish I SHOT HIM!!!
When it came down to Kenny vs Jane I was like fuck and I had a feeling during the fight that I was gonna have to shoot Kenny. I had no idea Jane was setting a fight up and that the baby was actually alive. When Clementine said "not again" I assumed the baby turned into a zombie or something. I was happy to have Kenny back this season because SEASON 1 REPRESENT! (Where is Christa btw???) buttttt Kenny was unbearable for the longest time these last several episodes. He was too chaotic and turning into Carver. (Beating a kid to a pulp) And then I thought about how he was driving everyone away anddddd idk I saw Jane as my closest ally and friend for awhile. I decided to forgive her because fuck I don't want to end the game alone. I am just a kid with a baby I can't survive. |
| |
| | | |
| 4 Users Viewing (4 Guests) |
|
|
