Is it possible that FF0's scan was given as vanilla because Samm's PGO was used that same night?

Samm pretty much said on day 4 that he had lost his kill so it must have been used, effectively making him vanilla.

Or am I missing something important?

Oh, and am I the only one who keeps getting Matt and Samm confused? Like, a lot.

Night 3 is just confusing. We know that Boc went for Mal. How did Shawn and Jen die though?

Shawn's role was:
Ted cares about his image and his company a little more than he does about those around him. Each night you may select a player. You will be immune from any actions sent towards you, however any actions used on the player you select will also be used on you.

So it's likely he selected a player who was targeted then? If the mafia went for someone that Shawn chose, there should have been two kills. Who killed Jen? I'm just confused.

We most likely have 2 scum left to oust.

Confirmed/Likely town:

Ari
Boc
Wikey
Samm
Matt
Lamps
Patrick
Paco
ff-zero

Unknowns:

Korr
Animal
Bryce
Justin

One thing to note about FF. As far as I can see, if anyone is lying here it is him. But if he was scum trying a last ditch attempt to throw suspicion on someone, why wouldn't he just full on say that Samm scanned as mafia.

The way I see it, there are only four possible suspects left.

Korr - I don't know why, but Korr's behaviour has seemed very forced to me all game. It's like he is screaming at us "hey guys, look at me, I am town, that is why I am not playing cautiously at all!" I dunno. I wouldn't put it past Korr to set out to play this way from the start to throw us all off.

Animal - Has mostly gone along with everything. Going to go look back at his posts now since nothing is immediately jumping out about him.

Bryce - The only thing that doesn't sit well with me for Bryce is the silencing on night 1. It is not an unheard of tactic for scum to silence one of their buddies early on. And at an early stage of the game, it can be a good move if you want to get in towns good books.

Justin - Terribly inactive! And the kills to me don't point to the work of an inactive killer. He could be the last mafia, but I doubt he is our SK.

Samm´s role sounds weird

I do think that Boc was attacked by a mafia player who might not be paying much attention, which could mean Justin. SK could be a lot of people

Also, with so few suspects left the temptation now would be for everyone to claim. I am not entirely against the idea.

But we would have to be sure that all of the claims currently out there are legit. Are we?

I think more claims can help if it helps understanding what happened night 3 cuz that could fully clear Samm + ff.

Korr is smarter than to attack Boc, if he was mafia. And hes paying attention too :P He could be the SK yes, like most of those left!

Justin seems like a good target. Hasnt done much, inactive and possibly attacked Boc without reading the thread?

This is a sausage fail mafia team

And it had Curtis, lynched. :/

Right...let's sort night 3 out.

Samm claims that is when his PGO was used. So either Shawn tried to hide behind him or Jen scanned him.

Let's say that Jen was Samm's victim for now.

So...Shawn. All I can think is he hid behind Malion and Boc killed him as a result.

But then you have to account for the missing SK and mafia kill. Which is not easy to do.

I am very tempted to claim right now. But I think it needs to be followed up with all the remaining unknowns doing the same. We could end this on night 6.

Tom Brady @ 12/10/2013 13:31

Right...let's sort night 3 out. Samm claims that is when his PGO was used. So either Shawn tried to hide behind him or Jen scanned him. Let's say that Jen was Samm's victim for now. So...Shawn. All I can think is he hid behind Malion and Boc killed him as a result. But then you have to account for the missing SK and mafia kill. Which is not easy to do.

I thought Samm's role only worked against attacks.

Yes, meaning one of Jen or Shawn had to have targeted him night 3, for it to have been used as he claims.

Korr! Bryce! My friends!

How about we all agree to role claim today so we can clear up this mess once and for all!

Justin...I don't expect to be hearing from him anytime soon, so we will just count our losses there. I look forward to hearing from you guys.

If both Bryce and Korr agree to claim, I will lead the way and reveal first.