Tattered Tooth @ 21/2/2021 16:10

im317 @ 21/2/2021 16:58 i think i have further narrowed down my options to just Herm or Maddie. someone sell me on either or them Although I had my doubts on Herm for the first days (even being so active), being a commuter makes sense since it helps to explain the no kills on N1. So unless a very unlikely commuting cult leader is in this game, now I trust him more than ever. Maddie did have solid reasons for not being so active on D4, but that's not the problem. As I stated some times already, when she suddenly didn't want to lynch on D2 (choosing to "follow Timmah" voting for non-present Lamps instead) made me sus of her. After that, D3 was basically speculation. She did interact a bit with Reaper, yet no votes again. Her most notable suspicions have been a OMGUS on me.

That was not me "not wanting to lynch" on D2. I was at a digital work event and didn't come back in time to vote.

None of my suspicions of you are OMGUS, you're just sketch.

But if you want OMGUS, I'll give you OMGUS.

##lynch TT

ooh Maddie that vote on TT looks bad. unless he is scum with Cody he cant have killed last night.

Gabagool @ 21/2/2021 18:16

You do not want to lynch me if you are Kashmiri.

Based on?

Gabagool @ 21/2/2021 18:19

That was not me "not wanting to lynch" on D2. I was at a digital work event and didn't come back in time to vote.

You are mixing up the days, I guess you meant D3.

D2 you posted until the very end, switching from Penner to Lamps.

MADDIE

--- in the blue corner, we have Maddie! Let's go through her game related posts! (from D1 to D3)

Post 5/7:

Sounds like Rodney is scared of Gmaj!

Post 6/7:

I can't lynch Gmaj. I am indebted over the Oregon Trail fuck up.

Post 7/7:

Penner: No, that was me who you messed up with in that game! Maddie: lunch Penner

Post 1/22:

Cody: I agree with badger, the 317 post seems weird Maddie: Ahhhh nothing has changed I see.

Post 2/22:

A number of people most definitely have info about last night. I don’t see why everyone is piling on Timmah before he’s spoken.

Post 3/22:

Rod is a sus mf

Post 4/22:

Rodney: Its too early to kill Maddie, I just want you to know I know you're scum Maddie: This is going to age very poorly.

Post 5/22:

Sussing im317 is such a cop out.

Post 7/22:

Killing me would be a waste for town.

Post 8/22:

Reaper is sus also.

Post 9/22:

I'm going to let you all in on a little secret... Spoiler + I have no idea what's going on.

Post 13/22:

Lead us into the light, 317!

Post 14/22:

I'll lynch Penner again! lunch Penner

Post 18/22:

Penner: Herm, TT, and Maddie will look very bad after my flip Maddie: I'm quivering with fear.

Post 21/22:

why Lamps

Post 22/22:

lunch Lamps I'll follow Timmah

Post 1/26:

Rodney: are there 2 mafias or was one 3p? Maddie: I would guess there are two factions. India vs. Pakistan and then Kashmir is town.

Post 2/26:

Yeah Timmah could be an Indian hitman.

Post 3/26:

Rodney: 317 is the only one i trust now but also people are probably getting recruited Maddie: Put this in the museum of mafia history plz

Post 4/26:

Ok so normally I get extremely sus of anyone who harps on recruiting, because I feel like it’s scum trying to distract, but in this case, given the theme of the game, I almost wouldn’t be surprised if both scum teams had the ability to recruit to try to “win over” Kashmir in order to gain autonomy over the region.

Post 7/26:

Rodney: I guess I would rather go for someone who could be Pakistani unlunch Badger: Why does it matter if we lynch Indian or Pakistani? Both factions have lost the same amount of people, and scum is scum. Maddie: Because Rod is prob Indian lololol

Post 8/26:

Probably a misguided theory, but building off of what I said before, would also not be surprised if all the Kashmiris are VT and whatever scum team recruits the most wins in addition to their survival win con.

Post 9/26:

Lamps: Oh right, Maddie, why did you jump my train when the vote was between Penner and IM at that time yesterday? Maddie: Because I believed both 317 and Penner’s claims and Timmah was the only person I felt decently enough yesterday. I didn’t have a read on you.

Post 10/26:

Lamps: They're not all VT. But did you just say you're either VT Kashmiri or scum? Maddie: Correct

Post 13/26:

I'm sorry, Herm, but I really think you're scum after the last two pages. Suddenly you're saying you'd lynch the people you referred to on your "no lynch" list? I'm confused.

Post 15/26:

Badger: Maddie ILY but I really don't understand why you felt the need to claim so early with like no pressure on you. Maddie: I didn't intend to! I was hoping someone would kill me instead of a PR.

Post 24/26:

Badger: The Reaper lynch isn't feeling right to me anymore. I think we should be doing either Tib or Maddie. Unlunch Maddie: If you're actually worried about Kashmiri numbers, do not lynch me.

IM317

--- in the red corner, we have im317! Let's go through his game related posts!

Post 1/3:

Ahoda: I admire spin writing such a long write up full well knowing maybe 3 people will read it Spin: That's 3 more than normal, so winner! im317: so its me and who else? seriously it was good and good flavor can help make a game work.

Post 3/3:

the only thing i remember about that game is town killed me and i had a bunch of the items that we would have needed to have a chance when they did it. so its there own fault for losing.

Post 1/9:

no deaths. would Spin make an all recruiting game? scum factional kill blocked?

Post 2/9:

Badger: Is this a potential scum slip indicating that 317 could be part of a recruiting faction? im317: recruiting in this series is an almost(?) every game thing. might even be an every game thing actually. if i had changed the order of sentences in my post would it be less suspicious? i suppose i should have checked the rules on survivals to see if an unannounced survival could explain it as well. thought i don't see anything about survivals in the rules i do seem to remember Spin not sharing that info.

Post 4/9:

killing me would be a waste. there have only been a few soft pushes on me as an easy target. when i flip town you would learn nothing.

Post 5/9:

Badger: Honestly I feel pretty good about my scum read on 317. I also find it a little sus that people are saying that they are skeptical of Cody's alignment after claiming his role. It would be a huge risk for a mafia role blocker to out themselves day 2. im317: i agree about Cody but disagree about 317

Post 6/9:

oh you are actually lynching me. sorry bit distracted. im a plain citizen

Post 7/9:

Badger: Do you have any scum reads 317? im317: sadly no. been working on something all day and nothing has stuck me. lunch Penner like you claim to, i know i am town.

Post 8/9:

Herm: Maybe they are both scum? im317: could be we are both town

Post 9/9:

Timmah: I think there’s a good chance they’re both vanilla town im317: i mean with a vanilla cop/doc its defiantly a strong possibility.

Post 1/7:

Maddie: I would guess there are two factions. India vs. Pakistan and then Kashmir is town. im317: and there is almost defiantly some 3rd party in play. the rest of the world never leaves this area alone in these games. maybe Russia again?

Post 2/7:

Herm: It took you so long to cast a vote so I was very suspicious of you yesterday. im317: i was in and out of the game thread all day, mostly out. so i had not cast a vote and then when i came for the last half hour i had a bunch to catch up on. so i read it all before casting a vote.

Post 3/7:

Badger: Both Ahoda and Nav were killed rather than being lynched. I don't think either the Indians or the Pakistanis are a SK faction because because we've seen members from both factions be killed. Also I think it's unlikely Spin would do a game with a team of SKs after it just having been done last game. Cult is more likely IMO, or some other weird 3rd party faction. im317: so even thought i liked this post i want to point out that we still cant rule out a different type of 3rd party killer. we had an arsonist in one of these games, or was it just someone searching for a non existent arsonist? might be time for a terrorist to pop up for different flavor.

Post 4/7:

Rodney: Theory : Timmah knew to shoot Ahoda because their blocker blocked him night 1 im317: interesting and worth coming back to later Gmaj: Could all the Kash VTs please start playing overly aggressive? im317: :effort:

Post 6/7:

woah were at 5/7 already? this seem a bit to easy/fast to anyone?

##lynch im317

I would be down with Rodney as well.

I was going to do Day 4 as well, but it took too long.

I am going to eat dinner now, but I'll be here.

I am tempted to lynch Rodney tbh.

I’m actually wondering the same. I don’t think it’s likely that 317 and Maddie are a pair right.

So I feel it’s either rod/Maddie or rod/317 ?

Sigh. Where is Timmah I want his input

not totally opposed to Rodney but i kind of feel like why would he counter Badger as scum?

My theory is that he believed Badger would flip some kind of recruiter.

Herm @ 21/2/2021 10:45

Nav is praying to the Mafia Gods right now that we mislynch town today lol.